There have been many attempts to define what music is in
terms of the specific attributes of musical sounds. The famous
nineteenth-century critic Eduard Hanslick regarded ‘the
measurable tone’ as ‘the primary and essential condition of all
music’. Musical sounds, he was saying, can be distinguished
from those of nature by the fact that they involve the use of
fixed pitches, whereas virtually all natural sounds consist of
constantly fluctuating frequencies. And a number of
twentieth-century writers have assumed, like Hanslick, that
fixed pitches are among the defining features of music. Now it
is true that in most of the world’s musical cultures, pitches are
____________________. However,
this is a generalization about music and not a definition of it,
for it is easy to put forward counter-examples. Japanese
shakuhachi music and the sanjo music of Korea, for instance,
fluctuate constantly around the notional pitches in terms of
which the music is organized. [3점]