본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Factoring Origin of Life Hypotheses into the Search for Life in the Solar System and Beyond

Longo, Damer · 2020

공개 학술지 Life 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2020년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Longo & Damer (2020), Life · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 6개 올림 이 장 1787낱말
← 앞 장

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

6장 · Factoring Origin of Life Hypotheses into the Search for Life in the Solar System and Beyond — Factoring the Hypotheses into Future Research and Life-Detection Missions

A common assumption in the field of astrobiology is that habitable worlds possessing sources of energy, liquid water, and CHNOPS elements are abodes for life by default. The reality is more nuanced. In order for microbial life to thrive in a habitable environment, it must first originate there or be transported from another location. These processes require prerequisites which are not met by traditional definitions of habitability alone. Therefore, origins of life hypotheses should be factored into the search for biosignatures in the Solar System and on exoplanets. Two alternative hypotheses describing the origins of life propose that microbial life began at submarine hydrothermal vents or in fluctuating terrestrial hydrothermal pools. Alkaline submarine vents provide microbial life with energy in the form of thermal and chemical gradients, vent chimneys where the synthesis of organic compounds can take place, and an environment sheltered from the cataclysms of the Late Heavy Bombardment 3.9 billion years ago. Hot springs are comprised of freshwater pools with wet-dry cycling, which can readily assemble lipid membranes encapsulating polymers of catalytic length and select for increasingly robust protocells. Although both hypotheses have unresolved questions and potential limitations, they are currently our most-investigated models for how microbial life could have begun on Earth and other habitable worlds. As Section 3 and Section 4 proposed, the two alternative hypotheses of “vents and fields” can help guide the search for life beyond our own planet. Factoring in these hypotheses, Figure 7 summarizes the prospects for an origin of life on each of the prospective destinations for future astrobiology missions.

Future research on the origins of life on other worlds can follow three primary paths: theory, experimentation, and exploration. This review article suggests a modified astrobiology strategy for the next decade, which builds on abiogenesis hypotheses as well as today’s missions and experiments: “Follow the water to where life can start and spread.” It represents an early attempt to define parameters, questions, and assumptions related to the origins of life that can help guide experimentation and planetary exploration in the coming years. Key questions include the following:

• Was early Mars “warm and wet” or “cold and icy?” How would the Noachian climate affect the transport of microbes from hydrothermal systems to other locations?

• How did Martian deluges in the Hesperian and Amazonian periods impact conditions for life? What biosignatures might be left behind from temporary upwellings?

• Could Martian biota develop photoautrophy during the Noachian and Hesperian? How would this development, or lack thereof, impact the search for Martian biosignatures?

• Did Martian hydrothermal systems persist long enough for early microbes to evolve the ability to deposit stromatolitic biosignatures? If not, what simpler biosignatures could be discovered by future missions?

• Have Europa and Enceladus held oceans for the entire history of the Solar System? Can hydrothermal vents form under the conditions of extreme pressure present at Europa’s ocean floor?

• Without continental weathering, are there alternative sources for phosphorus on Europa, Enceladus, and exoplanets with global oceans?

• Can microbial life can be transported between planetary environments (“limited Panspermia”)? If so, could life start in a Martian hot spring and travel to Enceladus or Europa, penetrating the ice shell and accessing the energy-rich environments of a hydrothermal vent? Alternatively, could life start in a hydrothermal vent on an icy moon and be transported to Mars or Earth?

These questions and their answers are likely to change as new research is conducted. Future research could define new parameters, and incorporate additional perspectives and theories which describe requirements for microbial life. Additional research on the submarine vent and hot spring origins of life hypotheses might also influence future developments in astrobiology. If one hypothesis becomes clearly favored over the other, space exploration efforts could be directed to search for life on worlds possessing this specific environment.

Future experiments should aim to simulate extraterrestrial hydrothermal systems in the lab. One such facility is the McMaster Planet Simulator, which has already simulated photochemistry in the atmosphere of Titan. The University of New South Wales (UNSW) and the University of Cincinnati are constructing hot spring simulators to test the hypothesis that life began in hydrothermal fields. Multiple submarine hydrothermal vent simulation chambers are active. These experiments provide controlled conditions, and are more predictable than natural hydrothermal systems. One valuable experiment to perform in a facility such as the UNSW hot spring simulator would be to replicate the expected temperatures, pressures, and atmospheric compositions of early Mars. This test could determine whether these variables affect the self-assembly of membranes and polymers in hot springs during wet-dry cycling.

Future experiments in submarine vent simulators could determine whether prebiotic chemistry can occur in a phosphate-poor environment such as the ocean of Europa. Prior studies have determined that amino acids and oligonucleotides can be synthesized in marine hydrothermal vents on Earth, but it is unclear whether this biochemistry is possible in the absence of phosphorus. It would also be advantageous to use a natural experiment to corroborate laboratory results stating that vesicle formation and polymerization are possible in submarine vents. This could be accomplished by dispatching a robotic submersible to an alkaline vent system such as the Lost City Complex. The submarine could drill a hole in a vent chimney, inject Carbon 14-labeled CO2, loiter for several hours, and return samples for analysis. This experiment could verify that organic polymers such as formic acid and formaldehyde can be synthesized in submarine vents, and it could enable direct comparisons with similar experiments conducted in hot spring environments.

The search for extraterrestrial life is currently one of the highest priorities of the scientific community. The missions of the early 21st century have discovered extensive evidence of water on ancient Mars, subsurface oceans on the moons of the outer Solar System, and dozens of potentially habitable exoplanets. Given this abundance of riches, what strategy should we follow to search for evidence of microbial life beyond Earth? One broad proposal would be for every astrobiology mission to incorporate a specific origins of life hypothesis into its scientific rationale. This argument could incorporate questions such as these:

• Is the mission dependent on an origin of life in submarine vents or hot springs?

• If it is searching for life in a different location, such as a lake or an ice sheet, how were microbes transported to this site from a hydrothermal system?

• What biosignatures should the mission search for at its destination?

Beyond this general suggestion, the marine hydrothermal vent and terrestrial hydrothermal field origins of life scenarios suggest several specific mission architectures which could be implemented in the coming decade. One quandary in the search for life on Mars is the destruction of biosignatures on the planet’s surface. Over billions of years, organic material is decomposed by ultraviolet radiation and microfossil-bearing outcrops are eroded by aeolian activity. Deep drilling could be used to detect organics and other biosignatures in sequences of marine or terrestrial hydrothermal sediments. This strategy enabled the detection of organics in the Dresser Formation, and it will be utilized on Mars by the European Space Agency’s (ESA) ExoMars rover. Despite the advantages of deep drilling, the experiences of the InSight geophysical lander suggest that hardware reliability and unknown surface properties remain problematic; astronauts on-site may be required to reach depths of more than a few meters below the surface. Until drilling technology improves, sample return from multiple sites could be an alternative approach to biosignature detection. Returning Martian rock and soil samples to laboratories on Earth has the potential to answer numerous high-level questions in planetary science, and NASA’s Mars 2020 rover represents the first step towards this goal. However, if Noachian Mars had a “cold and icy” climate and/or Martian life never developed photoautrophy, it would be unreasonable to expect that biosignatures would be found during the first sample return mission; each traditional sample return campaign costs 6–8 billion dollars. If subsequent missions returned small, targeted samples (~100 grams rather than ~500 grams), the price of a sample return mission could potentially drop to about 2 billion dollars. This would enable the exploration of multiple diverse locations where life could have originated and thrived, such as the Eridania Basin, the Columbia Hills, and Nili Patera.

Climate models suggest that Venus could have been habitable for up to 3 billion years, but there is no geomorphologic or spectroscopic evidence for hydrothermal systems in current datasets. Therefore, one next step in the exploration of the planet could be an orbiter similar to NASA’s VERITAS or ESA’s EnVision, which could pinpoint habitable environments on Venus and map its mineralogy. Multiple mission concepts for Europa and Enceladus have proposed flying through the moons’ plumes, using mass spectrometers to search for biosignatures. Such missions would indirectly sample the uppermost levels of the oceans, accomplishing a search for biosignatures for a moderate cost. One challenge for these concepts is that it is unclear how microbes in the open ocean of an icy moon would gather energy; microbial communities might be concentrated around hydrothermal vents on the seafloor to collect thermal energy. If so, a “cryobot” capable of melting through kilometers of ice may be required to conduct a comprehensive search for biosignatures on ocean worlds.

NASA’s Dragonfly mission is a rotorcraft scheduled to land on Titan in 2034 and traverse ~100 km. During its traverse, the spacecraft will sample a variety of terrains; its data could be used to explore how far prebiotic chemistry can progress in the absence of life, and which organic molecules could naturally be available for an origin of life in a hydrothermal system. Dragonfly’s destination is Selk Crater, where the mission could explore an impact-generated hydrothermal system and search for biosignatures in a cryogenic hydrothermal field. Beyond the Solar System, exoplanets with moderate surface water fractions are more favorable to an origin of life in either submarine vents or hot springs than ocean planets. Therefore, upcoming observations by the Hubble Space Telescope should focus on measuring the percentage of water by mass of transiting habitable-zone exoplanets. This procedure has already been employed for the TRAPPIST-1 system. Planets hypothesized to have both continents and oceans can then be studied in detail by the upcoming James Webb Space Telescope.

Conclusions

The coming decade will see significant advances in the search for life beyond Earth. However, the number of worthy planetary mission concepts will always exceed the resources available to design and build spacecraft. A planetary environment conducive to an origin of life is likely to either harbor extant life or preserve biosignatures. Therefore, origins of life hypotheses should be factored into astrobiology frameworks and life-detection missions. Conclusive success in the search for extraterrestrial life may be realized only after decades of additional missions, laboratory experiments, and field studies by hundreds of multi-disciplinary researchers integrating and testing many perspectives, including various scenarios for how life might begin.

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.