본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Oxygen and ROS in Photosynthesis

Khorobrykh, Havurinne, Mattila, Tyystjärvi · 2020

공개 학술지 Plants 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2020년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Khorobrykh et al. (2020), Plants · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 9개 올림 이 장 2967낱말
← 앞 장 다음 장 →

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

6장 · Oxygen and ROS in Photosynthesis — Formation of ROS in Thylakoid Membranes (2)

A possible alternative solution is that cyt b559 mediates the formation of semiquinones at QD and QC sites. Experimental evidence of the reduction in O2 by a loosely bound plastosemiquinone anion radical (PQ•−) at the QC site was provided by Yadav et al.. The authors showed that PQ•− can be formed by a one electron reduction in PQ at the QB site and one electron oxidation of PQH2 by cyt b559 at the QC site. Because a PQ molecule has been crystallographically detected in the QC site, PQ might be tightly bound within the QC pocket and act as an electron carrier from cyt b559 to P680. The environment of the QD pocket is probably flexible and lipophilic and can facilitate a PQ/PQH2 exchange. In this case, the PQ pool can serve as an electron donor for cyt b559. It might be proposed that the formation of O2•− in a cyt b559-dependent pathway couples cyt b559 and quinones and depends on the redox state of the PQ pool (Figure 2A). The rate constant of cyt b559-mediated reduction of O2 was estimated to be about 10⁻⁶ M⁻¹ s⁻¹ inside the thylakoid membrane, assuming that the reaction proceeds as a second-order chemical reaction.

The formation of O2•− in PSII causes the formation of H2O2 via spontaneous dismutation (Reaction (5)) or via a cyt b559-dependent catalytic reaction. In isolated RCs of PSII, cyt b559 was found to exhibit SOD activity. As proposed by Pospíšil, the catalytic formation of H2O2 by cyt b559 proceeds as a two-step reduction–oxidation reaction involving two molecules of O2•−. The first step is reduction of cyt b559 (Fe3+) to cyt b559 (Fe2+), Reaction (106). The second step is the oxidation of cyt b559 (Fe2+) by HO2•, the protonated form of O2•−, with formation of cyt b559 (Fe3+) and H2O2, Reaction (107).

According to this mechanism, the catalytic disproportionation of O2•− should be pH-dependent because the protonated form of O2•− is needed.

In addition to its formation by the dismutation of O2•−, H2O2 might also appear during incomplete oxidation of H2O by the Mn-cluster. It has been suggested that incomplete oxidation of H2O can occur during the two-electron oxidation of water by the Mn-cluster at the transition from the S2 state to the S0 state. However, the two-electron oxidation of water during the transition of the Mn-cluster from S3 to S1 does not result in the formation of H2O2.

In PSII, the Fenton mechanism involving a metal (M) cation, Reaction (58), can also function, leading to the formation of HO•.

In PSII, HO• can be formed both in the dark and in the light. HO• formation was shown when PSII membrane particles were heated in the dark. The authors suggested that this process is associated with heat-induced changes of the PSII donor side and proceeds via the Fenton mechanism. The formation of HO• was suppressed by CAT and metal chelators, indicating that the appearance of HO• is related to the decomposition of H2O2. However, a high concentration of CAT, around 5000 U/mL, was required to suppress the appearance of HO•. Exogenous calcium and chloride prevented the appearance of HO•. Furthermore, no HO•-related EPR signal was observed after removal of the Mn-cluster by Tris-treatment of PSII membranes. These data confirm that the Mn-cluster is likely involved in HO• formation in PSII under heat stress in the dark.

The light-dependent formation of HO• occurs in untreated PSII membranes. Experimental results suggest that HO• can be produced in the light by two pathways: firstly, by the well-known Fenton mechanism and secondly, by the reduction of a peroxide bound to the non-heme iron on the acceptor side of PSII. The formation of HO• at the non-heme iron is initiated by the binding of O2•− and formation of an O2•−-iron complex that can be protonated to a ferric–hydroperoxo complex, Reactions (49) and (50). The ferric–hydroperoxo complex can be decomposed via reduction by QA− with the formation of HO• and a ferric–oxo ((Fe3+)-O−) complex, Reaction (108).

where L is a ligand. Reaction (108) can be considered as a Fenton reaction proceeding with a bound hydroperoxide. The possible sites of formation in PSII are shown in Figure 2B.

The formation of bound hydroperoxides has been found to occur on the donor side of the PSII (Figure 2C). The mechanism is associated with the formation of a long-lived species, having a high positive redox potential in PSII. In PSII membranes holding an intact Mn-cluster, the O2 consumption rate is very low, around 1 μmol O2 (mg of Chl)⁻¹ h⁻¹, but the rate becomes 6-fold higher in alkaline-treated and Mn-depleted PSII membranes. O2 consumption was found to be associated, at least partially, with the generation of a component with positive charge(s) on the donor side of PSII, as the electron donors diphenylcarbazide and ferrocyanide suppressed the rate of O2 consumption caused by disruption of the donor side of PSII. A further study revealed that the removal of Mn from the OEC of PSII leads to O2 photoconsumption with a maximum at the first flash, with a yield comparable to the yield of O2 evolution on the third flash measured in the PSII samples before Mn removal. Inactivation of the OEC can lead to the formation of both P680•+ and TyrZ•. In the absence of electron donation from the OEC, both will have a long lifetime, and will therefore be able to interact with surrounding molecules such as Chls, carotenoids and amino acids. Based on these results, it has been proposed that the formation of peroxides on the donor side of PSII proceeds via a radical chain mechanism, starting with P680•+ (or TyrZ•), Reactions (104), (105) and (109).

The evidence of ROOH production on the donor side of PSII was obtained using the specific fluorescence probe SPY-HP. In this work, highly lipophilic peroxides (LOOH) and relatively hydrophilic ones (ROOH), were distinguished by the rate of reaction with Spy-HP. The formation rates of both LOOH and ROOH were estimated to be 0.022 µmol LOOH (µmol RC)⁻¹ s⁻¹ and 1.11 µmol ROOH (µmol RC)⁻¹ s⁻¹, respectively. The formation of carbon centred radicals, in turn, was found in PSII membranes with EPR spin-trapping technique when PSII membranes were treated by high light and heating. It has recently been found that exposure of Mn-depleted PSII membranes to high light results in the formation of protein radicals located mainly in the D1, D2, CP43 and CP47 proteins. The formation of protein radicals is suppressed by diphenylcarbazide, indicating that protein radicals were formed by the oxidation of proteins by P680•+ or TyrZ•. The formation of protein radicals was correlated with the formation of hydroperoxides measured with the SPY-HP probe. The formation of R• can initiate chain propagation reactions, and thereby lead to accumulation of ROOH (Reactions (105) and (109)).

Formation of Reduced Forms of Oxygen, O2•−, H2O2, HO•, in PSI

The acceptor side of PSI is believed to be the predominant site of O2 reduction in thylakoid membranes, as O2 reduction depends on the PSI activity (see reviews). It has been shown that both the photoreduction of cytochrome c and photooxidation of epinephrine, which have been used as traps for O2•−, were inhibited by SOD. This indicates that the reduction in O2 proceeds via univalent reduction, and O2•− was identified as the primary product in illuminated thylakoids. The predominant role of PSI in O2 reduction was shown in experiments with specific inhibitors that block PETC at different sites, and using a PSI-deficient mutant. The photoproduction of O2•− in thylakoids is inhibited by DCMU and can be restored by the addition of AscH2 and N,N,N′,N′-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine, to provide electron donation to PC and P700, respectively. This indicates that the contribution of PSII to the photoproduction of O2 in thylakoids is small. A slight influence of O2 on the steady-state level of Chl fluorescence in a PSI-deficient mutant of Oenothera sp. was attributed to insignificant leakage of electrons from PETC to O2, due to the suppression of Mehler’s reaction. On the other hand, a significant rate of O2 reduction by thylakoids was observed in the presence of dibromothymoquinone (DBMIB) and dinitrophenylether of 2-iodo-4-nitrothymol (DNP-INT), inhibitors of PQH2 oxidation by Cyt b6f,. It was found that the contribution of other sites of PETC, besides PSI, to O2 reduction increased with an increase in light intensity, and at high intensities achieved 60% of total O2 reduction in PETC. These data suggest that PSI is not the only site of O2 reduction in thylakoid membranes, but other sites of PETC can contribute to O2 reduction. Thus, experiments with isolated PSI membranes can provide more correct measurements of activity of PSI in the photoproduction of O2•−.

The electron transport chain within PSI (Figure 3) consists of two quasisymmetrical branches (A and B) containing six Chl, two phylloquinones (A1), and three 4Fe-4S clusters (FX, FA, and FB). Two Chl a molecules have been assigned to the spectroscopically characterized primary acceptor A0. Another pair of Chl a molecules is located between P700 and A0 and assigned as accessory Chls that may participate in excitation and/or electron transfer (for more details, see review).

The mechanism of O2 reduction in PSI is still under debate. It was suggested that O2•− production within the thylakoid membranes most likely occurs via autooxidation of the membrane-bound primary electron acceptors in PSI, possibly 4Fe-4S clusters (FX, FA, and FB). The Em of FA/FA− and FB/FB− and FX/FX− vs. NHE were estimated to be −479, −539, and −650 mV, respectively (Figure 3). The reduction in O2 by FX is thermodynamically favorable but kinetically less likely than a reduction in O2 by FA− or FB−, as the lifetime of FX− is less than 50 ns (Figure 3). When FA and FB clusters are reduced, the lifetime of FX is limited by charge recombination [P700+FX−] and estimated to be ~250 µs.

Electron transfer from FB− to Fd occurs within 1 µs, and therefore the oxidation of FA− and FB− by O2 in an aqueous region is not kinetically favorable in the presence of oxidized Fd (Figure 3). The lifetimes of FA− and FB− become much longer if Fd is mostly reduced or its diffusion to the FA and FB sites is limited. The charge recombination of [P700+FA−] and [P700+FB−] has a lifetime of about 50 ms when no extrinsic electron acceptors and donors are present. The rate of O2•− production by PSI in both isolated thylakoids and isolated PSI complexes ranges from 15 to 30 µmol O2•− (mg Chl)⁻¹ h⁻¹, corresponding to 2.5–4.5 O2•− per P700 s⁻¹ if the ratio of P700 to total amount of Chl is 1 to 600 for isolated thylakoid membranes. The rate of O2•− production is at least one order of magnitude higher in PSI subchloroplast fragments in the presence of the surfactant Triton X-100 than in its absence. The Km value for O2 in photoreduction by PSI was estimated to be 2–3 µM in both thylakoid membranes and PSI subchloroplast fragments and the second order rate constant for O2 reduction by the electron acceptors of PSI was calculated to be 1.5 × 10⁷ M⁻¹ s⁻¹. In another work, the Km value for O2 was estimated to equal to ~8 and ~3 µM for thylakoids, in the absence and in the presence of Triton X-100, respectively.

Experiments with O2•−-dependent protein iodination showed that O2•− can also be produced in the aprotic interior of the thylakoid membrane close to the RC of PSI. Thus, not only FA and FB, but also FX and A1, might be involved in O2•− production within the thylakoid membrane. It has been suggested that O2•− mediates cyclic electron transfer by donating electrons to Cyt b6f or to P700+, and this cycle would explain why the observed rate of O2•− production is low in intact PSI. The increase in O2•− production in PSI subchloroplast fragments in the presence of Triton X-100 could result from the prevention of the putative O2•− mediated cyclic electron flow around PSI, due to the disintegration of the supermolecular structure of PSI by Triton X-100. The increase in O2•− production in the presence of ammonium ions, and amines is considered as evidence of an O2•−-mediated cyclic electron flow in PSI, as these substances supply protons to the membranes and accelerate the dismutation of O2•−. The dismutation of O2•− prevents the O2•−-mediated cyclic electron flow, thereby increasing the detectable production of O2•−. Thus, dismutation of O2•− in thylakoid membranes and cyclic electron flow in isolated PSI complexes would explain why the rate of O2•− production is similar in these two preparations.

It has recently been suggested that the reduction in O2•− by FA, FB and FX occurs in a lipophilic region. As the dielectric constant in the immediate environment of the FA and FB centers is 5.4, the redox potential of O2/O2•− in aprotic medium (−550 and −600 mV vs. NHE in DMF) should be used in comparisons of the redox potentials of PSI cofactors and O2/O2•−. Thus, the difference in the redox potentials of O2/O2•− and PSI redox cofactors FA/FA− and FB/FB− would make the reduction of O2 by FA and FB thermodynamically less favorable. If we assume that O2•− is produced via O2 reduction by FA and FB in a lipophilic environment, then the differences in redox potentials would easily explain why the rate of O2•− production is low in PSI subchloroplast fragments. In this case, the effect of Triton X-100 would be to make the immediate area of FA and FB less lipophilic, which would shift the redox potential of O2/O2•− toward positive values.

According to the Em, Fx and A1 would be favorable reductants of O2, even in an aprotic environment, as the Em values of the pairs A1/A1− located on the A- and B-branches of PSI electron transfer chain are −0.7 and −0.81 mV, respectively (Figure 3). Indeed, phylloquinone A1 stimulated the flash-induced photoconsumption of O2 when added to thylakoid membranes from which A1 had been partially removed. It was suggested that A1 could be the main reductant in O2•− production in PSI. However, results regarding the importance of the phylloquinone in O2•− production vary. Firstly, the stimulation of O2 photoconsumption by addition of A1 was observed only on the first flash. The appearance of O2•− on the outside and inside of thylakoid membranes was tested with hydrophilic and lipophilic cyclic hydroxylamines that react with O2•−, forming nitroxide radicals with a specific EPR spectrum. In this work, a significant effect of SOD on the formation of both hydrophilic and lipophilic nitroxide radicals suggested that 90% of O2•− is formed at the membrane surface or outside of the membrane. On the other hand, evidence of the participation of A1 in O2•− formation was obtained with PSI complexes isolated from menB mutant, a phylloquinone-less knockout strain of the gene encoding 1,4-hydroxynaphthoyl-CoA-synthase of the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803. The mutant contains PQ at the phylloquinone-binding site A1. In the mutant, the redox potential of PQ bound to the A1 site was −553–−693 mV, close to the redox potential of FX/FX− and about 100 mV more positive than that of A1/A1−. O2 photoconsumption in isolated PSI complexes of the mutant was found to be slower than in the wild type. The low rate of O2 photoconsumption in the mutant was explained by the difference in the redox potentials of PQ and A1, and the results suggest that A1 is the main site of O2 reduction in PSI. N,N,N′,N′-Tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine and AscH2 were used as electron donors.

A1−, located in the B-branch of PSI, decays within 20 ns by electron transfer to FX, whereas electron transfer from the A-branch A1− takes 170 ns (Figure 3). A1− can accumulate in high light when electron transfer from A1− to FX is limited. In this case, the electron flow from FA and FB to the MDA radical can prevent the accumulation of A1−, which minimizes the interaction of O2 with A1−. MDA is formed mainly by a reaction between APX and AscH2 (Reactions (62)–(64)). MDA can also be formed by a reaction between AscH2 and O2•−, and MDA is an effective electron acceptor of PSI, effectively competing with methyl viologen. The reduction in MDA by PSI occurs via reduced Fd. In summary, a number of AscH2-related reactions can influence the photoreduction of O2 by PSI (Reactions (34), (62)–(64) and (110)–(113)), and the large number of reactions and reactants makes it difficult to estimate the importance of AscH2/MDA/DHA in O2 reduction in PSI.

From data presented by Kozuleva et al., the rate of O2•− production by PSI can be estimated to be 2.5 O2•− per P700 s⁻¹ according to the O2 consumption rate (250 µmol O2 (mg Chl)⁻¹ h⁻¹) assuming 40 molecules of Chl per P700 in isolated PSI complexes. If the production of O2•− by PSI proceeds as an elementary second-order reaction, then the second-order rate constant is about 10⁴ M⁻¹ s⁻¹ for a saturated concentration of O2 in aqueous solution. 4Fe-4S clusters of PSI can have a low efficiency toward O2 reduction, and the second-order rate constant of the reaction of O2 with Fe-S proteins like Fd is about 10³ M⁻¹ s⁻¹. However, the rate of O2 reduction by PSI was saturated to above 20 µM of O2, with the second-order rate constant 1.5 × 10⁷ M⁻¹ s⁻¹ at a high light intensity. The reaction of O2 with semiquinones having low redox potential proceeds with rate constants in the range of 10⁸–10⁹ M⁻¹ s⁻¹. These data may suggest that cooperation between 4Fe-4S clusters and phylloquinones A1 can provide flexibility for the O2•− formation inside and outside of the thylakoid membrane. In high light, O2•− formation by A1 becomes more important, which leads to the accumulation of O2•− within the membrane.

In the aqueous phase, the dismutation of O2•− is catalyzed by SOD (Reaction (5)). Intramembranous formation of O2•−, in turn, can lead to the formation of H2O2 within the thylakoid membrane due to the reaction of O2•− with PQH2, Reaction (114).

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.