Perspectives on improving photosynthesis to increase crop yield
Croce, Carmo-Silva, Cho, Ermakova, Harbinson, Lawson et al. · 2024
공개 학술지 The Plant Cell 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2024년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.
출처 Croce et al. (2024), The Plant Cell · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문
이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.
6장 · Perspectives on improving photosynthesis to increase crop yield — Manipulating stomatal features to improve photosynthesis and water use efficiency
By Tracy Lawson
Gaseous exchange between the leaf interior and the external atmosphere is determined by stomatal conductance (gs), and therefore, stomatal regulatory mechanisms play a pivotal role in determining the rates of photosynthetic carbon assimilation (A) and the loss of water through transpiration. Both of these physiological processes hold paramount significance for overall plant performance, productivity, and yield. The importance of CO2 uptake for photosynthesis is self-evident; however, water loss is equally vital for evaporative cooling and the maintenance of optimal leaf temperature to facilitate photosynthesis (Long et al. 2022), as well as transpiration driving uptake of essential nutrients from the soil to the aerial parts of the plant. The regulation of stomatal aperture, which balances CO2 uptake and water loss, is thus fundamental in determining plant water use efficiency, determined as A/E or intrinsic water use efficiency (Wi) when assessed directly as a function of gs, (A/gs) (Lawson et al. 2010). The significant impact stomata have on photosynthetic processes has led to increasing recognition of their potential as valuable targets for manipulation, to enhance crop performance, as well as to develop future crops that can tolerate the challenges posed by climate change (Matthew and Lawson 2019).
Stomatal conductance is the product of both anatomical features and biochemical factors, providing several research avenues for exploitation and manipulation for improved performance. Manipulation of stomatal density (SD) through changes in expression of key genes in the stomatal development and/or patterning pathways has clearly illustrated their potential to either increase the rate of carbon assimilation through removing stomatal limitation (Tanaka et al. 2013; Buckley et al. 2020) or enhance the water use efficiency (Wi; Bertolino et al. 2019). Although there are various approaches to manipulating stomatal numbers (Bertolino et al. 2019), genes within the epidermal patterning factor (EPF) and epidermal patterning factor-like (EPFL) family have been a particular focus (Harrison et al. 2020). Overexpression of EPF1 and 2 has demonstrated that a reduction in SD (and conductance) resulted in improved drought tolerance and increased water use efficiency (Bertolino et al. 2019; Leakey et al. 2019). However, decreased stomatal conductance usually lowers the rate of carbon assimilation; therefore, it is intriguing that reducing SD (by between 46% and 58%) in the key C3 crops, rice and wheat (Caine et al. 2019; Dunn et al. 2019) did not impose any diffusional constraints on carbon assimilation. Overexpressing EPFL9/STOMAGEN increases SD leading to a greater conductance associated with enhanced A (Tanaka et al. 2013; Sakoda et al. 2020), highlighting the impact of diffusional constraints on carbon assimilation (Lawson et al. 2012). However, it is important to note that while augmenting SD to increase stomatal conductance may appear promising for removing diffusional constraints (Sakoda et al. 2020), increased water loss erodes water use efficiency (Lawson and Blatt 2014). Furthermore, high SD has been linked to stomatal clustering and impaired stomatal kinetics, resulting in reduced stomatal conductance and rates of carbon assimilation (Dow et al. 2014). These effects are attributed to reductions in critical ion channels necessary for guard cell (GC) osmoregulation and pore opening, such as reduced K+ channel activity (Papanatsiou et al. 2016). Therefore, while the manipulation of SD presents a promising avenue for modifying stomata conductance, it is becoming evident that future endeavors should adopt a more holistic approach that considers both anatomical aspects and functional attributes such as stomatal kinetics (Fig. 9).
The close correlation between the rate of carbon assimilation and stomatal conductance (under steady-state conditions) is well established (Wong et al. 1979); however, it is not always constant (Lawson and Morison 2004), and under dynamic conditions, stomatal responses to changing environmental conditions are an order of magnitude slower than the rate of carbon assimilation, leading to a temporal disconnect between these two processes (Lawson and Blatt 2014). Slow stomatal opening has been reported to reduce carbon assimilation by ca. 10% across a range of species, while slow closure leads to unnecessary water loss that can erode water use efficiency by up to 50% (McAusland et al. 2016). Significant species and cultivar differences in the kinetic responses of stomata that depend on anatomy and biochemistry have been demonstrated (McAusland et al. 2016). This research has led to increasing interest in the rapidity of stomatal conductance and GC regulation as novel targets for improving carbon assimilation and water use efficiency (Lawson and Vialet-Chabrand 2019). Recently, Papanatsiou et al. (2019) used optogenetics to enhance solute fluxes in GCs, accelerating stomatal opening and closing, and verifying that enhancing stomatal kinetics improved water use efficiency with no carbon penalty. Engineering ion channels involved in K+ fluxes in the GCs has further demonstrated the potential to increase the kinetic responses of stomatal conductance and improve water use efficiency (Horaruang et al. 2022). GC metabolism also holds the promise of offering numerous innovative targets for manipulating both the rapidity of stomatal responses and the coordination between carbon assimilation and stomatal conductance (see review by Lemonnier and Lawson 2023).
Smaller stomata have been proposed to have faster kinetics (Drake et al. 2013), most likely facilitated by the greater surface area to volume ratio enabling more rapid solute and water exchange between GCs and the surrounding cells (Hetherington and Woodward 2003). However, to date little is known about the genetic regulation of stomatal size, and no key targets have been identified for manipulation. Stomatal size has been linked to stomata density, with smaller stomata associated with higher density (Drake et al. 2013); therefore, it may not be possible to manipulate size independently of density. The shape of the GCs and cells that surround them (called subsidiary cells) also influence the speeds at which stomata open and close (Franks and Farquhar 2007). Raissig et al. (2017) confirmed the importance of subsidiary cells in Brachypodium distachyon mutants lacking these cells, which resulted in slower kinetics and reduced stomatal conductance. These findings have opened up subsidiary cell metabolism and transport as a potential new avenue of research to explore novel targets for increasing stomata kinetics (Gray et al. 2020) (Fig. 9).
While the scope of this perspective may not encompass all recent advancements, it is worth noting that numerous exciting developments in stomatal research could provide new opportunities to improve crop performance in a changing climate. Nonfoliar stomatal behavior is gaining increasing attention due to the significant impact on photosynthesis and crop yield (especially during periods of plant stress). Additionally, current work has demonstrated considerable water loss associated with these nonfoliar tissues, providing possible new targets to improve whole-plant water use (Lawson and Milliken 2022). While most research primarily concentrates on leaf-level stomatal responses, recent studies have unveiled differences in stomatal kinetics between the adaxial and abaxial stomata (Wall et al. 2022). This discovery opens up the potential to independently manipulate these two surfaces, if the genes responsible for the stomatal patterning on each surface can be elucidated. However, if we are to exploit the potential targets highlighted in this perspective we need a greater understanding of GC signal transduction pathways, metabolism, and the mechanisms that coordinate carbon assimilation and stomatal conductance.
Natural variation in intrinsic yield potential
By Jeremy Harbinson
The model of Z-scheme oxygenic photosynthesis, with the CBB cycle fixing CO2, is the dominant photosynthetic process of the biosphere, and as such, it provides most of the energy and biomass that supports life on Earth. The consistent use of a Z-scheme CBB cycle photosynthetic engine means that there is little variation in the basic physiological and biochemical mechanisms of photosynthesis. However, since the colonization of land by the embryophytes in the late Ordovician (Clarke et al. 2011), this basic mechanism has been adapted by evolution to face the challenges of photosynthesizing optimally in the diverse environmental niches found in the terrestrial biome.
Photosynthesis is a complex process that depends on the cooperative activity of many processes so it can be tuned or optimized along many dimensions, for example, resource use efficiencies such as for light, water, and mineral nutrients, responses to temperature, leaf architecture, and longevity, tolerance to abiotic stress, recovery from stress, etc. These axes for adaptation are individually complex; for example, light can vary in myriad ways (e.g. intensity, spectrum, periodicity, fluctuations over differing time scales) during the life of a leaf or plant. This has resulted in the evolution of variation in photosynthetic traits (e.g. Björkman and Holmgren 1963; Flood et al. 2011; Yamori et al. 2014; Faralli and Lawson 2020). Taking the maximum rate of photosynthetic CO2 fixation per unit leaf area (Pmax, units μmol m⁻² s⁻¹) as an example, for a plant using the C3 photosynthesis mechanism it has been estimated that Pmax should be about 55 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹ at an irradiance of 2,000 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹ (Nobel 1991). Some C3 plants (e.g. desert winter annuals) achieve a slightly higher Pmax [60 to 65 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹ for Chylismia (formerly Camissonia) claviformis (Mooney et al. 1976) and Palifoxia linearis (Werk et al. 1983)]. In contrast, a typical C3 crop plant will have a Pmax of 20 to 30 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹ (Nobel 1991), deciduous forest tree species a Pmax of about 10 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹, while for permanently shaded rainforest understory species, Pmax is 1 to 5 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹.
Despite the variation for photosynthesis observed in natural systems, it has been argued that photosynthesis in crop plants cannot be improved because it has already been optimized by natural selection and evolution. This argument is, however, only partly correct because plants in nature do not experience the same pressures as plants in agriculture. The wide diversity of photosynthetic properties found in nature, including among the wild ancestors of crop plants, in broad terms is expected to represent different optima for photosynthesis adapted to different naturally occurring niches. These niches are, however, often limiting in various ways, for example, in water and nutrients (such as nitrogen and phosphate), and plants in nature usually experience strong competition from their neighbors (Theeuwen et al. 2022). In agriculture, however, competition with noncrop plant species is usually eliminated (or largely so), nutrients and water are often supplied, and attack from pests and diseases are managed, so far as possible, especially in intensive agriculture and protected horticulture. These agricultural environments do not have any perfectly natural analogs, so evolution will not have optimized photosynthesis for agriculture, and it can therefore still be improved in crop plants. In principle, therefore, photosynthesis is no different to those other plant properties that have been improved by domestication and breeding, despite their having been previously optimized by evolution in the wild ancestors of our crop plants. In the past, however, breeding for improved photosynthesis has occurred only to a limited extent, owing to the difficulty of phenotyping for photosynthesis alongside the complexity of the process (Theeuwen et al. 2022).
Variation in photosynthetic properties of land plants is a valuable resource in terms of understanding the operation and limitations of photosynthesis and finding photosynthetic syndromes or traits that could potentially be used to improve crop plant photosynthesis. The contribution that natural variation can make to understanding and improving photosynthesis can be divided into the following five broad categories:
• The limits to the adaptability of plant photosynthesis to extreme habitats and environments.
• Trait variation within or across species that facilitates the physiological analysis of traits and the identification of their underlying mechanisms.
• The co-occurrence of subtraits that reveal syndromes of evolutionary adaptation of photosynthesis.
• Physiological models or templates that serve as options for improving photosynthesis.
• Sources of genetic (or allelic) variation that can be used to breed (including by means of novel plant breeding techniques) for improved photosynthesis.
In addition to providing a way to extend our knowledge of the operation and regulation of photosynthesis and the limits reached by evolutionary refinement of the process, the occurrence of natural variation of photosynthesis implies there must be an underlying genetic underpinning. If we can unravel this genetic basis of variation for photosynthetic traits we can begin to systematically breed for improved photosynthetic traits. The importance of linking variation in photosynthesis (i.e. phenotypic variation) to genetics is paramount whether or not novel plant breeding techniques or conventional breeding is used to genetically improve a plant. The problem is that while the genes for the headline components of photosynthesis (e.g. the subunits of PSII or PSI) are well known, the genetic basis of variation in many key photosynthetic properties is poorly understood, even when the physiology of that variation is well known. For example, the maximum rate of photosynthesis is correlated with numerous changes in the protein, lipid, and cofactor composition of the leaf, alongside anatomical differences (e.g. Osmond et al. 1980; Schulze and Chapin 1987; van Bel and Gamalei 1992; Brodribb et al. 2007; Taylor et al. 2022). Higher rates of photosynthesis are, for example, correlated with greater activities of Cyt b6f complex or Rubisco, but this increase in activity is largely achieved by there being more of these components per unit area and not by there being super Cyt b6f or Rubisco (i.e. complexes with substantially higher specific activity; e.g. Osmond et al. 1980; Makino et al. 1997; Schöttler et al. 2015; Miller et al. 2017). The genetic basis for how an increased amount of these complexes per unit area of leaf is achieved is poorly understood despite phenotypic variation in Pmax being widely studied and encountered. The same can be said of other photosynthetic traits (or subtraits). This does not mean, however, that no natural variation exists for genes coding for the headline components of photosynthesis—such variation does exist (e.g. Prins et al. 2016; Prinzenberg et al. 2020) and can potentially be exploited.
If there is variation for a trait within a species, or a pool of species, that can be hybridized to give rise to genetically segregating offspring, then it is possible to correlate phenotypic variation with genomic variation using a mapping population and by this means identify genomic regions—QTL—within which a gene or genes that are causal for phenotypic variation are located (e.g. Harbinson et al. 2012; Theeuwen et al. 2022). Mapping populations can be constructed in various ways (Theeuwen et al. 2022), but critically they need to contain variation for the trait under investigation. The individuals comprising the population (typically 100 and often many more, depending on the nature of the population) must also be genomically mapped using markers (commonly SNPs) that essentially serve to describe the variation of the genome. If there is both genomic and phenotypic variation, these can be correlated and regions of genomic variation that are associated with phenotypic variation identified. A critical requirement is that of phenotyping; photosynthesis is strongly affected by the environment and is, in any case, difficult to measure rapidly and on the large scale needed to adequately phenotype a large population. This can be achieved by the large-scale use of portable gas analyzers or by using robotic chlorophyll fluorescence-based imaging systems (e.g. Flood et al. 2016). Comparing marker-assisted breeding and genomic selection on the one hand with genetic modification and gene editing on the other hand, the latter requires the identification of genes whose variation results in phenotypic difference, while the former can be carried out knowing only the association between phenotypic variation and variation in genomic markers (e.g. single-nucleotide markers or SNPs)—an approach that is widely used in commercial plant breeding [see Theeuwen et al. (2022) for a summary of QTLs and their use].
Improving photosynthesis is still a largely unexplored strategy for enhancing crop productivity, offering a means to expand crop improvement possibilities while sustaining yields. Even considering only the land plants (the embryophytes), photosynthesis has a wide range of properties many of which vary not only from species to species, but within a species. In some cases, these properties and their variation are not well explored. This natural variation for photosynthesis is, nonetheless, a valuable resource for improving crop photosynthetic properties, providing us with physiological templates and genetic resources with which we can improve crop photosynthesis using either conventional or novel plant breeding techniques. To make best use of this resource, we need to better understand the limitations on photosynthesis in the field and improve the tools needed for identifying phenotypic variation for photosynthesis. We also need better tools for identifying the causal genes underlying photosynthetic variation and, finally, develop strategies for applying these discoveries in crop improvement programs.
이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.
