이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.
5장 · Factoring Origin of Life Hypotheses into the Search for Life in the Solar System and Beyond — Discussion of Parameters that Influence Astrobiology
Several planets, moons, and exoplanets possess the environmental conditions required for an origin of life in either submarine hydrothermal vents or terrestrial hydrothermal fields. Given these conditions, there are several supplementary questions which impact the detectability of biosignatures on Mars and other habitable worlds. This speculative section will discuss potential biosignatures which could be discovered in a habitable planet’s fossil record.
Hydrothermal Systems as First and Last Outposts for Life on Mars
Mars’ surface most likely transitioned out of habitability at some point in the Noachian or the Hesperian; however, the absolute age of this transition out of surface habitability remains uncertain. The MSL Curiosity rover is exploring Mount Sharp in Gale Crater, a 5.5-km-tall central peak with rock layers recording much of Mars’ history. Lacustrine mudstones on the crater floor were dated to between 3.86 and 4.56 billion years in age. Between 3.3 and 3.7 billion years, the geologic record transitions to phyllosilicate-bearing rocks altered episodically by brine. This implies that, in at least one location, the surface of Mars supported liquid water after signs of life on land and in the oceans appeared in Earth’s fossil record.
Therefore, a hypothetical origin of life on Mars could have occurred in roughly the same half-billion-year period as it did on Earth, in the “first outposts” of hydrothermal system such as Home Plate, Nili Tholus, and the Eridania Basin. Unlike lakes and river systems, hydrothermal sites require only small amounts of water and a subsurface heat source to remain active. Models predict that conditions supporting the presence of surface hot springs persisted through the conclusion of the Hesperian. However, with the loss of the primordial atmosphere and the cessation of the majority of volcanic activity, these hot spring systems would eventually have become inactive. To exist on Mars today, microbes would need to migrate from a surface hydrothermal system into subsurface refugia. On Earth, hot springs and submarine vents are underlain by a system of plumbing which connects them to groundwater and magma sources. Ancient Martian microbes could have theoretically settled in the subterranean chambers of such a hydrothermal plumbing system. As ancient geothermal fields ceased activity, their waters sublimating into the thinning atmosphere, microbial life could have continued to thrive in the upper levels of the hydrothermal plumbing, protected from the increasingly sterilizing conditions at the surface. These microbes would have been halophilic, as water would have become increasingly salty as they migrated deeper within Mars’ crust to reach warm, liquid regimes as the core cooled. Similar to rock-dwelling life on Earth today, these colonies would have been be chemolithotrophs rather than phototrophs, and would have been able to persist in wet, rocky environments with scarce energy resources.
Radar observations by Mars Express have detected at least one subsurface lake 1.5 km below the planet’s surface. Although these bodies of water are highly saline, some halophilic chemolithotrophs are able to tolerate similar conditions on Earth. If life on Mars began in the “first outposts” of hydrothermal systems, it may still persist today in these subsurface lakes. Subsurface drilling missions searching for remnants of the Noachian biosphere might consider targeting bodies of water located beneath or near ancient hot springs and submarine vents, as these locations could have been inoculated by surficial colonies.
Hydrothermal systems on Mars would have been most massive and hospitable during the Noachian and the Hesperian due to the large quantities of water on the surface and the large amounts of internal heat radiating out from the core. However, they could have easily experienced episodic upwelling into the Amazonian, serving as “last outposts” for life able to survive on the otherwise uninhabitable surface of Mars. Terrestrial hydrothermal systems are often centered on a magma source for only a few thousand years due to continental drift. This does not apply to a planet such as Mars with low levels of tectonic activity; a hot spring or hydrothermal vent would have remained stationary over its heat source for the duration of the life of the magma chamber. Even terrestrial hot springs far removed from active magma plumes occasionally re-erupt and create temporary pools of water as trace amounts of magma and water seep to the surface. This is analogous to conditions on Amazonian Mars, where the planetary core was solidifying beneath hotspot plumes with no accompanying tectonic activity. It is a reasonable conjecture that periodic eruptions of hydrothermal systems could have carried organic material and entire microbial communities from subsurface lakes to localities on the surface. Hydrothermal vents and fields on Earth have excellent biosignature preservation potential. It therefore follows that the most recent and most accessible chemical biosignatures, morphological textures indicative of stromatolites, and microfossils may be found at ancient hydrothermal sites such as Home Plate. More recent silica deposits such as those in Nili Patera and Melas Chasma might also be ideal targets for in situ investigation.
If microbes colonized the Martian subsurface via a system of hydrothermal plumbing, they could have also been occasionally carried to the surface by deluges. While some Martian channels formed gradually through steady fluvial erosion, others were carved by short, catastrophic releases of water triggered by volcanism. These flooding events began in the Late Hesperian and continued through the early Amazonian; they were the final known appearances of large quantities of water on the surface of Mars. Temporary paleolakes were created in at least two dozen locations by flooding. These lakes could have been temporary refugia for halophilic chemotrophs. Jezero Crater, the landing site for NASA’s Mars 2020 rover, is one of the short-lived Martian paleolakes formed by deluges. In such an environment, the rover could potentially discover microfossils preserved in deltaic sediments. However, due to the temporary nature of the lake, organics and other biosignatures will most likely be present in trace quantities; finding them might require an intensive search.
Photosynthesis and Other Energy Sources for Microbial Life
Phototrophs comprise a majority of Earth’s biomass and energy production. The ability to store light energy in carbohydrates enabled photosynthetic bacteria to colonize the majority of Earth’s surface, and it could have led to a similar distribution of life on Mars and/or Venus. Genetic sequencing suggests that complex microbial communities capable of photosynthesis evolved as early as 3.4 billion years ago. If the development of photosynthesis proceeded at similar paces on Mars and Earth, primitive phototrophs could have conceivably developed before Mars left surface habitability. These microorganisms could have survived through the conclusion of the Hesperian; however, as atmospheric pressure decreased, water levels receded, and radiation flux increased, they would have been unable to retreat underground and most likely would have gone extinct. However, hypothetical Martian phototrophs could have created stromatolites before going extinct; the prospects for the detection of such biosignatures will be discussed in the next section. On the other hand, photosynthesis would most likely have developed on Venus if its hydrosphere persisted for the 2–3 billion years predicted by some climate models. As the solar energy flux on this planet is 1.9 times that of Earth, photoautrophy would be an advantageous adaptation for hypothetical Venusian microbes.
The distribution of Martian biosignatures may be dependent on the development of photoautrophy. On Earth, chemosynthetic bacteria and archaea are not as widespread as their photosynthetic counterparts. Photosynthetic life during the Hesperian may have been able to colonize much of the planet’s surface. Without photosynthesis, however, life is dependent on localized environments such as hydrothermal systems for energy. As hydrothermal systems ceased activity, so too would their microbial colonies. Although a purely chemosynthetic Martian biosphere would still produce microfossils and biogenic organics, they would most likely be concentrated around hydrothermal systems and rare compared to those produced by phototrophs.
Inadequate sources of energy may also pose a challenge to life in the oceans of Europa and Enceladus. Submarine hydrothermal vents could produce a constant supply of thermal energy for thermophilic microbes. Although the net energy output of a submarine vent is 8–9 orders of magnitude lower than that of sunlight, it is sufficient to support small communities of chemotrophs. The open ocean, however, has an extremely low energy density. Microbes on Europa cannot be photosynthetic, as light does not penetrate the moon’s icy crust. Therefore, life on ocean worlds may only persist near the seafloor, rather than in the uppermost and most accessible levels of their oceans.
Stromatolites and Other Advanced Biosignatures
A last piece of conjecture centers around the question of what forms of life we might expect to find on a dying planet. One common assumption is that any Martian microbial community would have produced stromatolites. Stromatolitic structures are created by the growth of communities of phototrophs, which form layered mats of microbial refuse. They first appeared 3.5 billion years ago during the Archaean, and likely peaked in abundance and diversity about 1.25 billion years ago. Terrestrial hot springs, such as those in the Pilbara, typically preserve fine-scale stromatolitic textures. One proposed interpretation of an MSL Curiosity image of a mudstone in Gale Crater is that the surface of the rock is covered by a microbial mat. However, the presence of stromatolites on Mars is dependent on a specific set of cellular functions which may never have evolved while the planet was habitable.
Photosynthesis and the ability to leave stromatolites in the rock record imply advanced cellular machinery. This would necessarily include a genetic code supporting a protein translation system, featuring ribosome-like organelles. The development of these systems may require evolutionary selection and recombination over tens to hundreds of millions of years across an extensive landscape of watery environments. On the Earth, early life would have been able to expand its range rapidly, actively colonizing new environments in the open oceans, land, and the marine shore. The subsurface would also expand the extant microbial biosphere. Therefore, life on Earth would have the benefit of a vast and increasing “combinatorial volume” which would support the exploration of many evolutionary pathways.
Mars had rapidly-declining habitability at its surface due to the cessation of its hydrologic cycle and the evaporation of all standing bodies of water. Life might not have had enough combinatorial “runway” to develop the complex and robust machinery required to produce stromatolitic textures. Life discovered in the subsurface of Mars might resemble an early form of chemolithotrophs, the majority being autotrophic and some existing as heterotrophs living off the organic material produced by autotrophs. Would such microbial communities leave behind direct fossil evidence of stromatolites, or be robust enough to leave traces of individuals preserved as microfossils? Given the complexity of stromatolites, Martian microbes may not have been capable of such producing such biosignatures. This implies that surface rocks may contain the chemical signatures of life, but limited fossil evidence of microbial communities.
Testing Origins of Life Hypotheses Using Planetary Exploration
Just as origins of life hypotheses could be used to guide the missions of the next decade, planetary exploration could shed light on whether life began in hot springs, submarine hydrothermal vents, or a different environment altogether. Making such a determination is nearly impossible using the terrestrial point of reference alone, since Earth’s Hadean rock record has been almost entirely destroyed by tectonic and aqueous activity. A search for biosignatures on Europa or Enceladus may be particularly valuable for downselecting between origins of life hypotheses. These moons most likely have marine hydrothermal vents, but lack hot springs and other proposed environments for biogenesis. If their oceans are found to be habitable but lifeless after billions of years of hydrothermal activity, it would strongly suggest that an origin of life in submarine vents is unlikely, or dependent on elements such as phosphorus not present on ocean worlds. If this knowledge was coupled with convincing evidence of past life in an environment such as Home Plate on Mars, it could indicate that life required subaerial hot springs or similar environments to get started. If, on the other hand, convincing biosignatures were found on Enceladus or Europa, they would probably provide convincing support for an origin of life near submarine vents.
Although few, if any, Hadean rocks survive today, a record of Earth’s early history could be preserved on the Moon. During the Late Heavy Bombardment (4.1–3.8 Ga), hundreds of kilometer-scale asteroids impacted the Earth’s surface; each impact would have ejected numerous rocks into Earth orbit. As the Moon was located at one-third of its present distance from the Earth, it would have gravitationally collected 8 million tons of ejecta. Without aqueous weathering or plate tectonics, fragments of Earth meteorites might be preserved for billions of years. Earth meteorites can be identified on the Moon through the analysis of zircon crystals; one such sample was found in an impact breccia collected by Apollo 14. This 4.1 Ga piece of ejecta dates from the Hadean, and is older than any known terrestrial rock formation. Ejecta sourced from submarine vents and hot springs could conceivably preserve a record of the history of life’s origin older than the Nuvvuagittuq Belt or the Dresser Formation. In fact, the Moon may also preserve a record of Venusian, Martian, and extrasolar biosignatures, albeit in low concentrations. NASA’s Artemis Program and related efforts present an excellent opportunity to conduct an extensive search for Hadean impact ejecta within the coming decade.
이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.
