이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.
5장 · Oxygen and ROS in Photosynthesis — Formation of ROS in Thylakoid Membranes (1)
The PETC employs three membrane protein complexes: PSI, PSII, their respective light-harvesting complexes (LHCI and LHCII), and the cytochrome b6/f complex (Cyt b6f, a plastoquinol-plastocyanin-oxidoreductase). Electron transfer between the complexes involves two mobile electron carriers, PQ and plastocyanin (PC). The liposoluble PQ mediates electron flow from PSII to Cyt b6f complex, and the water-soluble lumenal protein PC mediates electron flow from Cyt b6f to PSI. ROS are formed in several sites of the PETC, including PSII, PSI, the PQ pool and the light-harvesting complexes (LHC).
Formation of 1O2 in Thylakoids
The production of ¹O2 in plants occurs mainly by the interaction of O2 with excited states of Chls (where ¹Chl* and ³Chl are the excited singlet and triplet states of Chl, respectively) via spin-conserved reactions, (Reactions (102) and (103)).
Reaction (102) is negligible because the lifetime of ¹Chl* is very short (~10⁻⁸ s). The lifetime of ³Chl is around 10⁻³ s under anaerobic conditions. In solution, the quenching of ³Chl by O2 mostly occurs via ¹O2 generation with a second-order rate constant of 2 × 10⁹ M⁻¹ s⁻¹. ³Chl is formed both in the LHCs and in the reaction centers (RC) of PSII and PSI. In the LHCs, ³Chl is formed by intersystem crossing (ISC) from ¹Chl* and in the RCs by charge recombination. In PSII, the charge recombination between P680+ (the primary donor) and QA− (bound quinone) produces ³P680. ³P680 is formed through a time-dependent “virtual triplet state” of the primary radical pair P680+ Pheophytin (Pheo)−. A triplet state of P700, the primary donor of PSI, can also be formed via charge recombination.
Chls are mostly bound to LHCII and CP47 and CP43 proteins of PSII and the PSA A/B proteins of PSI. According to the high concentration of Chl in chloroplasts, around 60 mM, a significant formation of ³Chl via ISC in LHCs should be observed. However, there is no experimental evidence for the production of ¹O2 by the formation of ³Chl in LHCs in vivo. The formation of both ³Chl and ¹O2 has been observed in isolated LHCs. The formation of ¹O2 was found in isolated LHCII with an electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) measurement of 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine as a spin trap of ¹O2. The appearance of long-lived ³Chl in LHCs has been suggested to result from a small population of Chls that are substantially uncoupled from the matrix of LHC. In a reconstructed Chl-protein complex, light-dependent ¹O2 formation is lower by a factor of four compared to free Chl. As the isolated protein does not contain pigments that would effectively quench ³Chl or ¹O2, it was suggested that the low ¹O2 formation is caused by the tight packing of Chl molecules inside the hydrophobic zone of the pigment–protein complex where the interaction of ³Chl with O2 is limited. The same situation can probably be realized in LHCs where Chls are tightly packed. Furthermore, LHCs contain carotenoids that efficiently quench ³Chl. In addition, the highly efficient transfer of excitation energy to the RC lowers the probability of ISC. Thus, ¹O2 can only be formed in LHCs in sites where Chl is weakly bound to the protein matrix and ³Chl cannot be efficiently quenched by carotenoids.
The main source of ¹O2 appears to be O2 reacting with ³P680. As in the case of antenna complexes, the formation of ¹O2 in the RC also depends on two factors: the lifetime of ³P680 and the probability that O2 reacts with ³P680. Assuming that the accessibility of O2 to ³P680 is not changed significantly in different conditions; the yield of ¹O2 generation in the RC of PSII is mainly limited by the rate of ³P680 formation. The formation of ³P680 proceeds via charge separation and charge recombination. The formation of the excited singlet state ¹P680* is followed by the formation of the radical pair [P680+Pheo−]. In the next step, an electron from Pheo− is transferred to QA and the pair [P680+PheoQA−] is formed. P680+Pheo− can recombine to yield ³P680, and the formation of ¹O2 with a high yield was observed in an isolated PSII RC lacking QA and a functional donor side. In thylakoid membranes where both the donor and acceptor side are functional, electron transfer to QA and then to QB prevents the formation of a long-lived primary radical pair. However, pairs [P680+Pheo−] and [P680+PheoQA−] recombine when forward electron transfer is impossible. A fraction of the recombination of the pair [P680+PheoQA−] produces [P680+Pheo−QA]. Originally, [P680+Pheo−] is formed from [¹P680*Pheo] in a virtual singlet state ¹[P680+Pheo−] that recombines to ¹P680*. However, the long lifetime of the state [P680+PheoQA−] destroys spin correlation, and therefore the recombination [P680+PheoQA−] to [P680+Pheo−QA] often produces a virtual triplet state of the primary radical pair ³[P680+Pheo−QA] that has such a spin configuration that its recombination to an excited state of the primary donor produces a triplet, ³P680. At 40 K, the triplet state is mainly localized on the monomeric chlorophyll ChlD1, while, at 25 °C, about 30% of this state is associated with the chlorophyll PD1. Thus, the site of ¹O2 production is mainly localized in the D1 protein of PSII. The formation of ³P680 has a high probability because the two β-carotene molecules of the PSII RC are located far from ChlD1 and PD1, at 19.9 Å and around 30 Å, respectively. Such a long distance does not allow for the direct quenching of ³P680.
¹O2 generation by photosynthetic samples has been measured using several methods, including the spin traps 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine, 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-4-piperidone, 3-[N-(β-diethylaminoethyl)-N-dansyl]aminomethyl-2,2,5,5-tetramethyl-2,5-dihydro-1H-pyrrole, trans-1-(2′-methoxyvinyl)pyrene, histidine and Singlet Oxygen Sensor Green. The 1270 nm luminescence has been used to measure ¹O2 generation by isolated RC complexes. The methods of ¹O2 measurement were recently reviewed.
The absolute rate of ¹O2 production can be estimated by comparing the signal strength (e.g., 1270 nm luminescence intensity, fluorescence yield, the yield of 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1yl) oxyl or EPR signal amplitude) with the signal obtained from a sensitizer chemical with a known ¹O2 yield. The main limitation of such an estimation is that, in photosynthetic material, ¹O2 may be effectively quenched before reacting with the sensor, and therefore all estimates of ¹O2 yield of photosynthetic material represent a lower limit. At the PPFD (photosynthetic photon flux density) of 2000 µmol m⁻²s⁻¹, histidine-dependent O2 uptake measurements showed that isolated PSII RCs (6 Chl/RC,) produce ¹O2 at a rate of 4000 µmol ¹O2 (mg Chl)⁻¹ h⁻¹, with a quantum yield 0.16. The yield of ¹O2 per ³P680 is very high, as the quantum yield of ³P680 formation in the same preparations was 0.3. 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine measurements at the same PPFD showed that isolated thylakoid membranes produced 3.73 × 10−7 1O2 molecules per Chl molecule s⁻¹, and the quantum yield of ¹O2 formation was 2.59 × 10⁻⁴. Assuming 490 and 173 Chls per PSII and PSI, respectively, and a PSII:PSI ratio of 1, the ratio of Chl to RC of PSII is 663 for a plant thylakoid membrane. Thus, isolated RCs and thylakoids produce, at PPFD 2000 µmol m⁻²s⁻¹, 21,600 and 0.89 ¹O2 per RC per h, respectively. The large difference probably reflects differences in both the actual ¹O2 production rate and in the experimental method. In cyanobacteria illuminated at PPFD 2300 µmol m⁻² s⁻¹ in deuterium oxide, a decrease in O2 concentration in the presence of histidine showed ¹O2 production of approximately 27 µmol (mg Chl)⁻¹ h⁻¹, suggesting that ¹O2 production in vivo may actually be of the same order of magnitude as the maximum rate of O2 evolution. A similar conclusion was drawn from measurements with isolated RCs.
Inactivation of the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) of PSII leads to an increase in the redox potential of the QA/QA− pair, so that ³P680 is no longer formed, and therefore virtually no ¹O2 can be produced through recombination reactions. However, even in this situation, some ¹O2 production can be expected because inactivation of the Mn-cluster leads to the oxidation of organic molecules, presumably by P680+ or TyrZ•+ (the redox active tyrosine residue in the D1 protein), and the formation of organic hydroperoxides. Recently, ¹O2 formation has been detected in Mn-depleted PSII membranes and correlated with R• formation on the donor side of PSII. It was proposed that ¹O2 is formed via the Russell mechanism, Reactions (9), (104) and (105).
Thus, the formation of ¹O2 associated with PETC can proceed both via the interaction of O2 with ³Chl and decomposition of ROOOOR (Reaction (9)). The formation of ¹O2 can occur in at least three sites of PETC: (1) LHCs; (2) RC of PSII; and (3) the donor side of the PSII (Figure 1).
PSI is not considered as a site of ¹O2 production, although theoretically the formation of ³Chl can occur through charge recombination between P700+ and its electron acceptors. In isolated PSI membrane fragments, the recombination of [P700+A0−] in the presence of dithionite was found to lead to the formation of the triplet state in PSI RCs with a quantum yield of approximately 30%. In PSI particles, the flash-induced absorption changes at 820 nm are attributed to the formation of ³P700 via conversion of the cation–anion biradical pair [P700+A0−], with a yield approaching approximately 50% for 10 ns. It was found that an increase in absorption at 820 nm is immediately followed by a multiphasic decay, including a major fast phase within 5–10 µs and an intermediate phase (about 10–15% of the signal) within 2 ms. Interestingly, O2 does not affect the decay. It can be speculated that this indicates that O2 is unable to efficiently quench ³P700 in isolated PSI complexes and thereby produce ¹O2. It seems that, even if ³P700 is formed in PSI, its quenching by O2 is minimized. It has also been suggested that charge recombination mainly occurs between P700+ and phylloquinone A1−, which minimizes the formation of ³P700 triplet. ¹O2 could be detected in PSII membrane fragments and PSII core complexes but not in PSI particles under the same conditions. However, isolated PSI-LHCI supercomplexes of Arabidopsis produced ¹O2 at a rate of approximately one tenth of that measured in PSII-LHCII supercomplexes, and the rate of ¹O2 production by PSI-LHCI supercomplexes of the low-carotene szl1 mutant was approximately one fourth of that measured in PSII-LHCII supercomplexes. There is also some evidence that the Fe-S centers of PSI produce ¹O2.
Oxygen Reduction in PETC
The first evidence that O2 can accept electrons from PETC was observed by Mehler who found that O2 was consumed and H2O2 evolved under the illumination of broken chloroplasts. Light-dependent O2 consumption as an indicator of Mehler’s reaction has been reported also in vivo in algae and cyanobacteria, and in isolated intact chloroplasts with the capacity for CO2 fixation. Later studies have shown that O2 reduction occurs in different sites of the PETC (including both PSII and PSI), and illumination of thylakoids triggers the appearance of several forms of reduced O2, including O2•−, HO2•, H2O2 and HO•. Because the acceptor side of PSI is the major site of O2 reduction in thylakoid membranes (see reviews), the term “Mehler’s reaction” has become synonymous with O2 reduction at the acceptor side of PSI, with H2O2 as the final product.
Formation of Reduced Forms of Oxygen, O2•−, H2O2, HO•, in PSII
Although ¹O2 is the main ROS produced in PSII, O2•−, H2O2 and HO• have also been found to be formed. The contribution of PSII to the generation of O2•− in the intact chloroplast is generally small. The O2 consumption associated with O2 reduction by PSII membranes capable of water-splitting is about 1 µmol O2 (mg Chl)⁻¹ h⁻¹ or 4 µmol O2•− (mg Chl)⁻¹ h⁻¹ when O2 is the only electron acceptor. The rate of O2 reduction is higher in disintegrated PSII complexes, which might suggest that, during stress conditions in vivo, when the structure and functional activity of PSII are disturbed, more O2•−, H2O2, or HO• is produced in PSII.
Of the redox active components of PSII, the Pheos and QA and QB may be able to reduce O2. Formation of 21 µmol O2•− (mg Chl)⁻¹ h⁻¹, measured as an SOD-dependent cytochrome c reduction, was observed in D1/D2/cytochrome b559 (cyt b559) complexes illuminated at 200 W m⁻² in the presence of an artificial electron donor. D1/D2/cyt b559 complexes lack QA and the Mn-cluster, and therefore the result suggests that PheoD1− (Pheo bound to the D1 protein) can be involved in the generation of O2•−. However, the reaction of O2 with PheoD1− is expected to be negligible in native RCs because of the very short lifetime of PheoD1− (Table 2). The redox potential of PheoD2/PheoD2− (Pheo bound to the D2 protein) is 80–210 mV more negative than that of PheoD1/PheoD1− and therefore, if PheoD2− is formed, it would have a low enough redox potential to reduce O2.
It is difficult to tell whether QA− can reduce O2, as the Em of the pair O2/O2•− depends on the hydrophobicity of the environment. If the environment of O2 is equivalent to an aqueous solution, QA− would have a low enough potential to reduce O2, whereas the redox potential of O2/O2•− in a hydrophobic environment is so low that QA− would be a poor reductant, although its lifetime is long enough for chemical reactions (Table 2). However, the participation of QA− in O2 reduction has been suggested. O2•− production was found to increase in the presence of an inhibitor of electron transfer at the QB site of PSII, DCMU (3-(3,4-di-chlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethyl urea), which was explained by the fact that DCMU increases the lifetime of QA−.
The production of O2•− by both PSII with a functional Mn-cluster and by Ca2+ and Cl−-depleted PSII was detected using 5-diethoxyphosphoryl-5-methyl-1-pyrroline-N-oxide as a spin trap. The generation of O2•− at QA may occur due to the flexibility of the redox potential of QA/QA−, that has been reported to range from −80 to −200 mV (Table 2) and to depend on the structural and functional state of PSII. A shift in the redox potential of the QA/QA− to a negative direction may cause the enhanced production of O2•− in a PsbS (a chloroplast-localized protein required for NPQ) knock-out mutant.
Double-reduced QA has a very negative redox potential (Table 2) and can reduce O2. However, QA2− can only be formed by chemical treatment or by strong illumination in the absence of O2. Thus, the involvement of QA2− in O2 reduction seems unlikely.
Reduced QB is less likely to reduce O2 than QA− because the redox potential of QB/QB− is around −45 mV (Table 2). Although QB− has a much longer lifetime than QA− when electron donation from QA− does not occur (Table 2), the quinone in the QB site is involved in proton-coupled electron transfer, and the redox potential of QB− becomes positive when the quinone is protonated (Table 2). The possible generation of O2•− by quinones at QA and QB pockets is illustrated in Figure 2A.
In untreated chloroplasts, cyt b559 is found in high potential (HP), intermediate potential (IP) and low potential (LP) forms. A very low potential (VLP) form was observed in isolated RCs of PSII and seems to be an isolation artefact. The Em values of the three forms of cyt b559 are (see review):
• HP form: 350–450 mV;
• IP form: 150–260 mV;
• LP form: −50–110 mV.
The ratio between the forms is variable and depends on isolation procedure. For example, modification of the donor side of PSII by removal of the Mn-cluster leads to the conversion of the HP form to the LP form. In intact chloroplasts, the ratio of HP to LP forms was found to be 58 to 31, with respective redox potentials of 383 and 77 mV. In untreated PSII membranes, the ratio HP:IP:LP was estimated as 44:31:25, with redox potentials of 375, 228 and 57 mV, respectively. In isolated thylakoid membranes, 85% of cyt b559 was in the HP form. The values measured from intact chloroplasts may best reflect the situation in vivo.
Cyt b559 has been suggested to be involved in cyclic electron transfer around PSII, where PQ bound in the specific binding pockets QD and QC acts as both an electron donor and an electron acceptor. This idea is supported by the finding that PQH2 can reduce cyt b559 in both intact chloroplasts and in PSII RC preparates. The photoreduction of cyt b559 was found in isolated thylakoids and was inhibited by DCMU. In Triton X-100-solubilized PSII particles, which mostly have the LP form of cyt b559, short-chain PQs stimulated both photoreduction and dark oxidation of cyt b559.
The involvement of cyt b559 in electron transfer reactions of PSII indicates that cyt b559 is a redox active component that can potentially reduce O2. It has been shown that fast, dark reoxidation of the PQ pool in thylakoid membranes is not caused by direct oxidation of PQH2 by O2, and it was suggested that the LP form of cyt b559 can transfer an electron to O2 and thereby act as a PQH2:O2 oxidoreductase. In isolated PSII membranes, O2 has been shown to compete with prenylquinones for oxidation of the LP form of cyt b559, suggesting that LP cyt b559 can form O2•−. Exogenously added short-chain quinones significantly enhance O2•− production by PSII. This finding was interpreted to indicate that these quinones reduce LP cyt b559, which then undergoes spontaneous autoxidation, resulting in O2•− formation.
However, the reduction in O2 by LP cyt b559 is thermodynamically unfavorable, taking into account that the redox potential of the LP form is usually within 20–110 mV in untreated membranes, although sometimes an LP form with a negative potential is observed. To explain O2 reduction via an apparently thermodynamically unlikely reaction, it has been suggested that the E0′ of O2/O2•− should be calculated by the Nernst equation, due to differences in concentrations of O2 and O2•−. According to the Nernst equation, and assuming concentrations of 250 µM and 500 nM for O2 and O2•−, respectively, the redox potential becomes close to 0 mV. Thus, the electron transfer from LP cyt 559 to O2 becomes feasible. However, it seems that the comparison of standard middle point potentials is more correct, as cyt b559 is bound within a protein matrix, and a considerable difference in the local concentrations of O2 and O2•− is questionable.
이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.
