Overview of Bee Pollination and Its Economic Value for Crop Production
Khalifa, Elshafiey, Shetaia, El-Wahed, Algethami, Musharraf et al. · 2021
공개 학술지 Insects 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2021년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.
이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.
4장 · Overview of Bee Pollination and Its Economic Value for Crop Production — Bee Pollination vs. Non-Bee Pollination
Bees are considered the most effective pollinators; however, the contribution of other insect pollinators cannot be considered negligible, as they serve to increase and stabilize crop pollination and rely on these plants for the supply of pollen and nectar. The main groups of other insect pollinators are butterflies, moths (Lepidoptera), some flies (Diptera), and beetles (Coleoptera).
Hoverflies vs. Bees
Hoverflies (Diptera: Syrphidae) are considered the most anthophilous family in the order Diptera. Episyrphus balteatus DeGeer is one of the most common hoverfly species to usually be found in agricultural areas, and several recent studies have confirmed its contribution as a pollinator of many crops around the world. One crop that is pollinated by hoverflies E. balteatus is oilseed rape, which is an important crop in temperate regions. It has been shown that when E. balteatus is involved in the pollination services of this crop, sufficient numbers of seeds per pod are produced, demonstrating the ability of E. balteatus as a pollinator of edible crops. The drone fly, Eristalis tenax L., has also been reported as a successful pollinator of numerous managed crops, such as pak choi (Brassica rapa subsp. chinensis) and onion in New Zealand, onion, spring turnip rape (Brassica rapa L. subsp. oleifera), and carrot (Daucus carota L. subsp. sativus) in Germany, sweet pepper (C. annuum) in Canada, and kiwifruit in Italy. Consequently, according to Brad and Megan, E. tenax L. is often kept in large numbers in fields during the crop flowering period.
A study in Germany looked at the impact of pollination by the solitary mason bee O. rufa and two hoverfly species (E. tenax and E. balteatus) on oilseed rape. This study showed that the fruit yield and number of seeds per pod improved with an increase in bee abundance relative to hoverfly abundance, and that five-fold higher density of hoverflies than red mason bees were required to achieve the same fruit sets and yields. Thus, mason bees were more effective pollinators of this crop than hoverflies.
Butterflies vs. Bees
Around 180,000 species of butterfly and moth (Lepidoptera) are reported and make up to about 10% of all recognized insect species. Butterflies represent approximately 10% of Lepidoptera and tend to visit psychrophilic flowers that offer small to medium volumes of dilute nectar. These flowers are characterized by brightly colored petals with a mild and pleasant aroma and a flat platform that enables the butterflies to land in the inflorescence. Large- to medium-sized butterflies act as pollinators via their wings. Gloriosa minor Rendle (Colchicaceae) is a dry land floral plant in Kenya that depends on butterflies for pollination, and consequently the production of seeds, which are a source of colchicine. Caesalpinia pulcherrima was pollinated mainly via butterflies which carry the pollen on their wings.
Angadeniaberteroi is an endangered species that has large, showy, yellow, and tubular flowers with no notable fragrance. The tubular shape of these flowers gives them a complex structure, so any pollinators that are attracted to this plant should have body parts that are specifically adapted to this morphology, including mouthparts that are long enough to find the nectar. Both bees and butterflies visit A. berteroi, allowing a comparison of their efficiency. The long-tongued bees’ heads are wider than the apical portion of the pollen chamber, forcing them to touch the reproductive parts of the flower, and these bees rarely revisit the same flowers. Long-tongued bees appear to be efficient in gathering nectar and transporting pollen. By contrast, the two groups of butterflies that visit the flowers [skippers (Hesperiidae and non-skippers) carry very small amounts of pollen on their proboscides, do not deposit this pollen on the stigmas of the flowers, and frequently visit the same flowers, thus appearing to act as nectar thieves. The frequent visitation of the same flower by an insect is known to have negative effects. For instance, flower re-visitation can lead to abortion of the fruit and ovule due to self-pollen deposition on the stigma, explaining why the mouthparts are associated with the efficacy of the pollination process.
Moths vs. Bees
Moths can be categorized as having a crepuscular or nocturnal lifestyle and are recognized as one of the main pollinators of a large variety of plant species in different habitats around the world. The information on the role of moth pollination in natural habitats is available where about 227 flowers have been pollinated by moths. Moths are frequent floral visitors, and there are a number of encounters between plant species and moths. Moths pollinate approximately 40% of plant species in rural landscape environments, such as meadows, pastures, old farms, field edges, and roadsides. Consequently, the role of moths in agricultural environments is often attributed to their pollination of non-crop plants, which contributes to increasing the biodiversity in agro-ecosystems, offering a widely appreciated ecological function. Moths may also pollinate some unique plant species, such as some orchids. At present, however, the role of moths in pollination is likely underestimated due to the limited number of studies on this topic.
An evaluation of insect pollination levels on sunflower crops in the central Darling Downs during the day and night showed that Western honey bees were the most recurrent visitors, with populations averaging 65.3 bees per 100 flower heads across 42 crops through mid-morning. By contrast, Helicoverpa armigera Hübner moths were observed visiting the plants during the night, averaging 3.9 individuals per 100 flower heads between 7 and 8 pm and being registered in 33 crops. Thus, moths visited the flowers for less than 2 h per night whereas bees were active for 9 h. The small population size and low level of activity of moths indicated that bees played a significant role in sunflower pollination in this area.
Beetles vs. Bees
Beetles (Coleoptera) belong to one of the most diverse insect orders and their role in pollination systems is increasingly being recognized. Some flowering plants depend on pollination by certain types of beetles. For example, species in the subfamily Cetoniinae (Scarabaeidae) are common pollinators in the tropics. More than 184 species of angiosperms are exclusively pollinated by beetles (e.g., Magnolia in Magnoliaceae). Some beetles use flowers as rendezvous sites besides their usage in their food which enhances their role as pollinators. Unlike tropical pollinators, beetles depend on odor to find flowers, while Hopliine beetles exclusively use visual indications and, even without nourishment or smell, are attracted to bright colors. Beetles are always associated with the pollination of open bowl-shaped flowers. Beetles were found to be the second most important insect group contributing to pollination services in both Lambir (27%) and Kakachi (17%) in Malaysia and India, respectively. Both bees and beetles together represent more than 60% of the pollination services of tree species in Lambir and 34% of those in Kakachi. Bees play the main pollinator role in Lambir (32%) followed by beetle-pollinated species (20%), but the beetle Hopliini sp. (Scarabaeidae) is one of the most effective pollinators in the southwestern area of Cape Province and Namaqualand. Therefore, there is a need for further studies to clarify the ecological role of beetles and their effectiveness as pollinators.
Thrips vs. Bees
Thrips (Thysanoptera) are pollinators of plant species, however they are still poorly studied. These tiny insects have piercing-sucking mouthparts and are usually noticed on flowers, where they depend on nectar, pollen, or the cell content of plant tissues in their food. Thrips have been noticed in the flowering period of coffee species C. arabica L. and C. canephora L. in the southern state of Chiapas, Mexico in three flowering seasons (2013–2015). Several species of thrips on coffee flower were noticed to be carrying a few pollen grains on their bodies. Bees have increased fruit production of coffee by 50% more than wind in shaded coffee agro-forests, South India. The role of other insect visitors with bees including Thysanoptera in coffee was insignificant as they did not touch the flower anther or stigma enough times in addition to performing infrequent visitation.
Wasps vs. Bees
Social wasps (Hymenoptera) are among the pollinators in the Neotropical region. As predators, they can behave as flower visitors. Many factors attract wasps to flowers such as flower color and shape. Wasps are attracted to reddish brown, dirty purple, and dirty brown flowers. Schremmer (1962) has noticed that wasps are attracted to small flowers with bulbous, wide entrances and sucrose-rich nectar. Floral scent is one of the main factors attracting wasps. For example, social wasps are the main pollinators of Epipactis helleborine L. due to their scent. Another study has been done on the coconut flower in the presence of wasps and honey bees. The wasps (Polistes crinita Felt) failed as a pollinator because of their disability in loading adequate amounts of pollen and their behavior in deterring the honey bee. In contrast, honey bees were effective as pollinators to coconut.
Conclusions
Bee pollination provides a wide variety of benefits to humanity, contributing to food processing, raw materials, medicines, fibers, social, cultural values, and the maintenance of biodiversity and environmental protections. Bees’ pollination has direct effects on the profitability and productivity of a substantial amount of global crop varieties, including most vegetables, seeds, and nuts, and some high-value agricultural products, such as coffee, cocoa, and rapeseed. Currently, 5–8% of all global crop production would be lost without the pollination services provided by bees, necessitating changes in the human diet and the expansion of agricultural lands to resolve shortfalls in crop production. Bees are faced with many challenges that can distort their lives, including shifts in land use, climate change, pesticides, genetics and cultivation management. Concerns regarding the decline of domestic and wild bees have intensified the need to encourage the usage of the wild pollinators on agricultural lands. As wild bee trips have increased with the development of high-diversity bee habitats in the surrounding landscape, the restoration of high-diversity bee habitats is necessary to increase free pollination levels. A secure atmosphere for bees should be provided to produce healthy crops. The use of insecticides and pesticides is damaging to human health because both crops and bee products become contaminated with agrochemicals that humans must eventually ingest. Although the roles played by non-bee pollinators cannot be ignored, bee pollination remains a precious asset that should be protected. Bee pollination must be enhanced not only to improve environmental balance but also to maintain food security worldwide. The role played by bees is important for worldwide crops and certain medicinal plants, with significant effects on quantity and quality. Researchers should focus their attention on studying the impacts that bees have on crop quality, which should provide more detailed data regarding how bees can alter the chemistry of certain crops.
Institutional Review Board Statement
Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement
Not applicable.
이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.
