본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Factoring Origin of Life Hypotheses into the Search for Life in the Solar System and Beyond

Longo, Damer · 2020

공개 학술지 Life 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2020년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Longo & Damer (2020), Life · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 6개 올림 이 장 3352낱말
← 앞 장 다음 장 →

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

4장 · Factoring Origin of Life Hypotheses into the Search for Life in the Solar System and Beyond — Evaluation of Habitable Worlds Using the Hypotheses

Over a dozen planets, dwarf planets, and moons in our Solar System are confirmed or hypothesized to have harbored liquid water at some point in their histories. Each potentially habitable world presents a unique set of conditions which may or may not be favorable to an origin of life; these conditions will be described and assessed in this section.

Mars

Although Mars has lacked permanent bodies of liquid water for the past three billion years, its early history resembled that of the Earth. Deuterium-hydrogen ratios in carbonaceous chondrites suggest that water was delivered to both Earth and Mars early in their respective histories, so Mars could have been habitable as early as 4.6 billion years ago. Widespread deposits of hydrated minerals such as phyllosilicates, carbonates, sulfates, and chlorides formed during the Noachian period (4.6–3.7 billion years ago) in at least 10 classes of aqueous environments. Three habitable ancient environments have been ground-truthed and characterized by the Curiosity, Opportunity, and Spirit rovers from this timeframe. During the Hesperian period, Mars gradually left surface habitability; the atmosphere was stripped by the solar wind, water on the surface became acidic, and catastrophic deluges carved transient lakes and rivers. By the end of the Hesperian, the surface of Mars was no longer permanently habitable. Therefore, an origin of life on Mars would most likely have occurred between the end of the Late Heavy Bombardment (3.8 Ga) and the end of the Hesperian period (3.0 Ga).

Noachian Mars met all of the conditions required for an origin of life in marine and terrestrial hydrothermal systems (Figure 3). Marine hydrothermal sediments have been detected on Mars, albeit in one location to date. The Eridania region is an interconnected network of five deep basins, which held an ancient sea 3.8 billion years ago during the late Noachian. The floors of these depressions are covered in massive blocks of chaos terrain around 400 m tall, which contain numerous alteration minerals including phyllosilicates, carbonates, serpentine, and talc. Michalski et al. concluded that these sediments were most likely produced in a deep-sea hydrothermal system. As each basin’s hydrothermal sediments cover a roughly circular area 100 km in diameter, the Eridania sea would have provided a vast expanse of catalytic surfaces and energy sources to support prebiotic reactions. In addition to seas such as Eridania, Mars may have held a large ocean in its northern hemisphere during the early Hesperian period. Isotopic analysis lends support to this theory, but no deep-sea hydrothermal sediments have been detected in Vastitas Borealis as of this writing.

Candidate Noachian and Hesperian hot springs have been discovered in multiple locations on Mars. The best-studied of these systems is located in the Columbia Hills in Gusev Crater, and it was discovered by the Mars Exploration Rover (MER) Spirit in 2007. The rover found nodular clasts, which are covered in digitate structures and composed of 85% opaline silica, adjacent to a volcanic tephra deposit named Home Plate. Gertrude Weise, a patch of soil containing more than 90% Opal A, was exhumed adjacent to these rocks. The particular mineral assemblages found by the rover could have formed in either silica-precipitating hot springs or volcanic fumaroles. Several subsequent findings, including a stratiform distribution of silica and the inability of sandblasting to produce digitate structures, provide strong support for the hot spring interpretation. MER Spirit remotely detected silica at Pioneer Mound, a one-meter-tall structure northwest of Home Plate. Pioneer Mound has a profile which resembles extinct hot spring mounds such as those at Puchuldiza, Chile. If this is indeed the origin of Pioneer Mound, it could have powered wet-dry cycling conducive to an origin of life in a hot spring. Lithostratigraphic analysis indicates that the candidate silica sinter in the Columbia Hills forms a discontinuous layer sandwiched between two volcanic units. Therefore, the deposits are most likely late Noachian or early Hesperian in age. Analyses of archival MER data, coupled with the exploration of analog environments, has suggested that the centimeter-scale digitate structures which protrude out of the nodular clasts could be biomediated microstromatolites. Due to their high biosignature preservation potential, these silica deposits have been identified as high-value targets for future exploration.

In addition to the ground-truthed ancient hydrothermal system in the Columbia Hills, multiple candidate Martian hot springs have been observed from orbit. Perhaps the most convincing example is located in Nili Patera, a late Hesperian volcanic caldera. Multiple opaline silica deposits have been documented on the flanks and in the surroundings of Nili Tholus, a 520-meter volcanic cone within the main caldera. Unlike the silica cobbles at Home Plate, the Nili Patera silica deposits are amorphous rather than opaline. However, these minerals could have easily been dehydrated through diagenetic alteration by the Martian atmosphere or by surficial iron. The formation of hydrated silica requires aqueous weathering, and it most often occurs in hydrothermal systems. Given their former volcanic setting, the deposits in Nili Patera are most likely products of hot springs or fumaroles. The low sulfur abundance of the Syrtis Major region suggests the former, but the latter remains a non-trivial possibility in the absence of fine-scale mineralogy data. A second occurrence of candidate hydrothermal silica has been detected in southwest Melas Chasma, Vallis Marineris. The silica occurs in mounds 100–200 m in diameter, which fill low-lying depressions within the extensive regional lakebeds. It is difficult to explain their distribution, as hydrothermal and volcanic features are rare throughout Vallis Marineris. The hydrothermal origins hypothesis for the Melas Chasma silica has not yet explained how lava percolated to the surface in this select location. The silica deposits in Nili Patera and SW Melas Chasma have both been dated to the late Hesperian period, when Mars was transitioning out of surface habitability; however, conditions could potentially have supported hardy microbes. Finally, hydrated silica has been detected in the Jezero Crater delta, near the landing site for the Mars 2020 rover. It was likely sourced from one of the silica deposits in the surrounding Northeast Syrtis Major volcanic region. As it was discovered recently, further research will be necessary to determine whether or not this silica was produced by hydrothermal processes. Given the large number of former volcanic complexes on Mars, other similar hydrothermal sites could await detection.

Although organics-rich solutions in large, stable Noachian lakes may be too dilute to promote the rapid abiotic reactions necessary for an origin of life, they remain subjects of interest to the astrobiology community. Paleolakes formed relatively early on both Earth and Mars, and they present thermally and chemically stable environments in which life can persist for long periods of time. Terrestrial lacustrine environments concentrate decaying organic matter on their floors, which increases the likelihood that Martian lakebeds could preserve Noachian biosignatures. For these reasons, paleolakes have been prioritized as targets for multiple Mars rovers. Mars Exploration Rover Spirit explored Gusev Crater, Mars Science Laboratory Curiosity explored Gale Crater, and Mars 2020 Perseverance will explore Jezero Crater. However, for lakes and seas to be relevant in the search for biosignatures, life must have spread there from the hydrothermal site where it originated. The likelihood of microbial transport taking place depended on the climate of Noachian Mars. Early Mars may have been “warm and wet,” with frequent precipitation and clement surface temperatures. This hypothesis is supported by geomorphologic features indicative of an extensive Martian hydrosphere. If it is correct, microbes that developed the ability to thrive beyond their host hydrothermal system could have been distributed across hundreds of kilometers by runoff, impact events, groundwater flow, and/or atmospheric transport. Under a warm climate, lacustrine systems could have been promising sites for microbial life and biosignature preservation. Alternatively, multiple climate models suggest that Noachian Mars was “cold and icy,” with a contiguous ice sheet covering the southern highlands. Southern hemisphere seas such as the Eridania Basin could have been covered by this ice sheet, isolating deep-sea hydrothermal systems from the rest of the planet. Microbial transport from hot springs to lakes would also be challenging under such conditions, as precipitation would be infrequent and the areas beyond the hydrothermal site would be parched and irradiated.

Venus

The surface of Venus is inhospitable to life as we know it, with a constant surface temperature of 750 degrees Kelvin and an atmospheric pressure of 9.3 × 10⁶ pascals. The leading theory on Venus’ climatic history is that it left surface habitability early in its history during a runaway greenhouse period. However, some recent climate models suggest that Venus may have harbored liquid water on its surface for up to three billion years after the formation of the Solar System. In these scenarios, the onset of a strong greenhouse effect was delayed by Venus’ slow rotational period. Like Earth, Venus has highlands and lowlands; these could be potential analogs to submarine and continental crust. Way et al. predicted that 60% of the surface of Venus was once covered by a liquid water ocean 300 m deep. Venus also has an extensive volcanic rock record, including some evidence for modern activity. As Venus is similar in mass, diameter, and composition to Earth, it is reasonable to propose that both planets had similar levels of volcanic activity during the early history of the Solar System. In fact, surface water and volcanic activity could have persisted longer on Venus than they did on Mars. If extensive oceans and volcanic provinces were present on ancient Venus, the planet could have supported an origin of life in submarine hydrothermal vents. Likewise, life could have originated in hot springs located on highstanding continental crust. However, current radar and spectroscopic datasets are insufficient to detect evidence of any ancient Venusian hydrothermal systems.

Ocean Worlds

One of the most surprising discoveries of NASA’s planetary science program is the sheer abundance of water in the outer Solar System. Subsurface oceans have been confirmed on Jupiter’s moons Europa and Ganymede and on Saturn’s moons Enceladus and Titan. Over a dozen candidate ocean worlds orbit Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune, or independently orbit the Sun as dwarf planets (Figure 4). Europa and Enceladus in particular have been denoted as astrobiologically-relevant environments. Europa’s surface is crisscrossed by hundreds of intersecting linear ridges, which likely formed when its thin water-ice crust was fractured by tidal forces. The uneven distribution of these features can only be explained by a liquid water ocean separating its crust from its core. Volumetric calculations suggest that Europa’s global ocean contains twice as much water as all of Earth’s oceans combined. Enceladus’ south polar region features hundreds of plumes which vent out water-ice crystals; these jets are also fed by a global subsurface ocean.

To produce a deep-sea hydrothermal system, a heated planetary core or mantle must be in contact with an ocean. Many large outer Solar System moons, such as Jupiter’s Callisto, have oceans sandwiched between two layers of ice. These moons therefore lack traditional submarine vents, although hydrothermal fluids might still percolate into their oceans via magma plume-generated conduits. The oceans of Europa and Enceladus, in contrast, are likely in contact with cores heated by tidal forces. Indirect evidence suggests that hydrothermal vents on both worlds are actively producing the compounds necessary for microbial life. Sodium chloride on the surface of Europa could have been produced in submarine vents, while molecular hydrogen detected in the plumes of Enceladus was produced by inferred marine hydrothermal systems. Given the presence of such ecosystems, the oceans of Europa, Enceladus, and other ocean worlds could be conducive to an origin of life in hydrothermal vents. Marine hydrothermal systems in the outer Solar System could be broadly similar to those on Earth; compositional analyses of surface of Europa and the plumes of Enceladus suggest that the seawater on both moons carries the same salts. Giant planets provide a ready source of heat for their moons in the form of tidal forces. Therefore, stable conditions in the oceans of Europa and Enceladus could have persisted for hundreds of millions, if not billions, of years. If polymers can be synthesized in the chimneys of hydrothermal vents, as the submarine vent hypothesis states, then microbial life could be thriving on the seafloors of multiple ocean worlds.

However, if life can only begin on land in hot springs, the ocean worlds of the outer Solar System might be habitable but lifeless. Hydrothermal systems on ocean worlds are constantly immersed in water, and therefore must take the form of submarine vents without wet-dry cycling. Unlike hot springs or submarine vents on Earth, a hydrothermal system deep within the ocean of Europa would be completely isolated from meteoritic infall. Therefore, it would need to continuously form the necessary organic building blocks of life from simpler starting reactants such as CO2. Phosphorus availability would also be significantly reduced on ocean worlds. On Earth, phosphorus enters the hydrosphere through the fluvial erosion of continental crust; runoff makes this key element for biochemistry available to both submarine vents and hot springs. Without landmasses to supply them, hydrothermal vents on Europa or Enceladus might have access to several orders of magnitude less phosphorus than similar systems on Earth. Enceladus has a moderately saline ocean with dissolved sodium, chlorine, and carbonate ions, which could potentially inhibit the assembly of protocells if bilayer lipid membranes are unable to self-assemble in seawater. Finally, it is important to note that the high ocean floor pressures on the planet-sized moons Europa, Ganymede, and Titan could inhibit faulting, which is a prerequisite for the formation of hydrothermal systems. While Mars could have supported an origin of life in submarine vents or hot springs, the prospects for life on ocean worlds are highly dependent on which hypothesis proves to be correct.

Titan

Titan is the only planetary body in the Solar System besides the Earth with large bodies of liquid on its surface. Its polar regions feature lakes of liquid methane and ethane which are over 100 m deep and cover a total surface area of 1.6 million square kilometers. The surface temperature of Titan is approximately equal to the triple point of methane, and its lakes are sustained by a complex hydrologic cycle involving all three phases of matter. Seasonal precipitation of liquid methane in the equatorial regions sculpts canyons which empty into low-lying areas. The longest of these canyons, Vid Flumina, is 570 m deep and 412 km long. In addition to its methane hydrosphere, Titan also has a subsurface ocean of liquid water, which could facilitate an origin of life in deep-sea hydrothermal vents (see Section 3.3).

Life on the surface of Titan would depend on methane-based cryochemistry rather than liquid water. Therefore, any discussion of life on Titan must first consider whether or not complex organic compounds can form cellular components under such conditions. Laboratory experiments have identified azotosomes, nitrogen-based equivalents of lipids, as potential components of membranes in a cryogenic environment such as the surface of Titan. The organelles and structural components of cells on Earth are composed of proteins, and one can imagine that various carbon and nitrogen compounds could fulfill these functions on Titan. Multiple hereditary molecules have been create under controlled conditions, so four-base DNA is not a prerequisite for the transmission of genetic information. The ingredients for a methane-based biochemistry are certainly present on Titan, although they have only been predicted in theory rather than proven through experimentation.

The fluctuating hot springs proposed for an origin of life on land have no direct equivalent on Titan due to the moon’s frigid climate and thick crust of ice. It is notable that several regions near Titan’s equator display a bright absorption feature at 5 microns, which could be indicative of methane-based evaporitic deposits. These same regions are inundated by methane floods during the spring season on Titan. One mechanism for the formation of these sediments is that they could accumulate gradually through the evaporation of ephemeral equatorial lakes. Although the cyclic dissipation of these lakes could conceivably concentrate complex organics and encourage protocell self-assembly, the extremely low temperatures and lack of activation energy make it doubtful that a methane-based biochemistry on Titan could be established.

Multiple cryovolcanic complexes have been identified with Cassini radar data, and it is therefore possible that Titan could harbor cryogenic hot springs in its volcanic regions (Figure 5). A fluctuating water level due to varying rates of cryovolcanic activity could enable wet-dry cycling in these low-temperature geothermal springs. Cryogenic hydrothermal fields on Titan would have access to abundant complex organics synthesized by photochemistry in the moon’s atmosphere. One obstacle facing an origin of life in these environments is the salinity of the water. As the cryovolcanoes on Titan are most likely fed by a subsurface ocean, any water would be highly saline, similar to the water underneath the crust of Europa. Without freshwater or catalytic structures such as the pores in hydrothermal vent chimneys, it is unclear whether complex polymers or bilayered lipid membranes could be synthesized.

Exoplanets

To date, more than 4000 planets have been discovered orbiting stars other than the Sun. The majority of these were detected by the Kepler Space Telescope, which confirmed 2327 exoplanets—including about 30 potentially habitable worlds. These numbers are likely to rise precipitously with the advent of next-generation instruments such as the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS). The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) will have the required sensitivity to detect trace gases and biosignatures, including methane, water vapor, carbon dioxide, and molecular oxygen, in planetary atmospheres; the Hubble Space Telescope has already discovered water vapor in the atmosphere of a super-earth-sized planet in its star’s habitable zone. However, creating a complete atmospheric profile for Proxima Centauri b, the nearest potentially habitable exoplanet, will take upwards of 60 hours; as JWST observing time will be distributed among multiple scientific disciplines, the telescope will only be able to analyze a small subset of exoplanet atmospheres. Origins of life hypotheses can therefore be employed to optimize the use of JWST observing time by predicting which exoplanets are most likely to be inhabited based on their properties.

If a habitable zone exoplanet has a substantial atmosphere, moderate temperatures and pressures will allow liquid water to persist on its surface. However, the amount of water can vary based on the planet’s distance from its star at formation. Terrestrial exoplanets that accrete in their stars’ habitable zones most likely form with continents and oceans, similar to those of Earth, Mars, and Venus. Earth-sized planets hypothesized to have landmasses include Kepler 458b and Kepler 62f. However, planets that form beyond the outer edge of the habitable zone would contain large quantities of water ice; if they migrate inwards, this ice would melt into a global ocean of liquid water. Infrared observations reveal that the three habitable planets of the TRAPPIST-1 system, for example, contain up to 5% water by mass (Figure 6). In contrast, the Earth contains 0.05% water by mass.

Exoplanets with Earth-like water mass fractions could be conducive to an origin of life in either submarine hydrothermal vents or terrestrial hydrothermal fields. Environmental considerations for these planets are similar to those described for Mars and Venus in Section 3.1 and Section 3.2. However, there are no analogs for ocean planets in our Solar System, so a discussion of these worlds is warranted here. As they do not have solid surfaces, ocean planets cannot support an origin of life in hot springs. Therefore, microbial life on these worlds must either start in submarine vents, or in tide pools on circumpolar ice caps. Tide pools seem to lack the energy required to catalyze polymerization reactions, and it is unclear whether or not the oceans of these planets are in contact with their mantles–a prerequisite for the presence of marine hydrothermal systems. On an ocean planet such as TRAPPIST-1e with 5% water by mass, the immense pressure at depth will turn the water above the mantle into ice. This ice layer may separate seawater from thermal sources, preventing the formation of submarine hydrothermal vents. Like on Europa and Enceladus, phosphorus availability on ocean planets is also a concern. Other than the erosion of continental crust, which is not present on ocean planets, there is no known method to produce the large amounts of phosphorus needed for biochemistry. An anticipated lack of hydrothermal systems and phosphorus on ocean planets suggests that exoplanets with moderate surface water fractions are most favorable for an origin of life.

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.