본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Hyperthermal-driven mass extinctions: killing models during the Permian–Triassic mass extinction

Benton · 2018

공개 학술지 Philosophical transactions. Series A, Mathematical, physical, and engineering sciences 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2018년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Benton (2018), Philosophical transactions. Series A, Mathematical, physical, and… · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 4개 올림 이 장 1887낱말
← 앞 장

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

4장 · Hyperthermal-driven mass extinctions: killing models during the Permian–Triassic mass extinction — Acid rain as a killer on land

There is evidence that acid rain was a key consequence of the release of sulfur, chlorine, fluorine and other gases by the Siberian Traps eruptions. This evidence comprises massive erosion of upland areas following the stripping of vegetation, mass wasting and supply of bursts of nutrient-rich soil and siliciclastic debris to circumcontinental shallow seas, expansion of the OMZ and boosts in shallow marine productivity. These acid rain crises were probably repeated multiple times through the PTME crisis and subsequent Early Triassic events. The famous ‘coal gap’, lasting for the first 10 Myr of the Triassic, indicating the absence of trees and forests, is surely a measure of the impact of acid rain on terrestrial ecosystems. Acid rain generated by the Siberian Traps eruptions likely reached pH = 4 globally, and pH = 2 or 3 during the eruptions, and the rate of change was rapid, corresponding to likely drastic effects on life on land.

Acid rain damages plants in two ways, by direct contact and through leaching essential ions from the soil. Acid rain reduces the chlorophyll content of leaves and hence the ability of plants to photosynthesize. Other direct effects include physiological impacts (reduction in photosynthetic rate, variation in stomatal conductance and decrease in chlorophyll content) and morphological damage (decrease in thickness of cuticle, reduction in leaf area, discoloration and occurrence of necrotic spots). Further, the excess nitrogen and sulfur slows growth and increases susceptibility to stressors such as drought, frost, pest damage, disease and ozone increases.

Soil leaching may be more significant. Today, anthropogenic sulfur dioxide, together with ozone and nitrogen oxides, the key constituents of acid rain, have a direct effect on soil chemistry and forest health. This acid cocktail leaches base cations (Ca, Mg, K), increases the availability of soil Al and drives the accumulation and transmission of acidity from forest soils to streams. These changes in soil chemistry produce direct impacts on plants. Ca is an essential plant nutrient, contributing to many cellular structures and physiological processes as well as overall forest function. Ca uptake by plants can be inhibited by Al in solution, and these Ca-dependent metabolic and physiological processes are then disrupted. The ratio of Ca to Al in soil solution is used as a key indicator of forest health, especially in acid soils, and Ca loss points to acidification. Calcium reduction has profound effects on trees. Labile Ca, moving among cellular compartments, acts as a signal mediating physiological responses to environmental stresses such as drought, cold, heat, salinity, fungal pathogens, and oxidative and mechanical stresses. Ca deficiency caused by acid rain can affect the ability of plants to sense and respond adaptively to their environment in several ways: it diminishes photosystem function by reducing leaf area; it reduces carbohydrate metabolism by reducing the storage of sugars; it reduces the cold tolerance of leaves, and so increases the risk of winter injury and crown deterioration; it impairs the function of the leaf stomata, essential for correct water balance; and it affects seed germination and seedling growth.

Whereas today much of total global biodiversity resides on land and in angiosperm forests, the balance of biodiversity was probably different in the Permian and Triassic, with less life on land. Nonetheless, trees then must have harboured considerable biodiversity, and so the stripping of vegetation from the land, including forests, would have removed specialized habitats for many arthropods and vertebrates. The arrival of acid rain during the PTME was fast and likely repeated during each major eruption event, and the stripping of forests and mass wasting by the most extreme acid rain events would have had devastating effects on all life on land.

Wildfires as killers on land

There is considerable evidence for prevalent wildfires at the time of the PTME. These would have looked spectacular, like the lava flows around the Siberian Traps eruptions, but their role in causing global extinction might have been modest. Forest fires happen all the time, and may devastate ecosystems locally or regionally, but life soon recovers and heals the scars.

In fact, wildfires were common throughout the Permian and right through to the PTB, and then there is a long gap during the Early Triassic and much of the Middle Triassic, when fossil charcoal is not reported, or was at least very rare, as were other indicators of fire, including inertinites and pyrogenic polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Wildfire has been posited at the PTB at Meishan in South China, based on abundant charcoal, black carbon and carbon spherules. Wildfire can kill directly as forests were burnt down, but most animals would have been able to flee. Wildfires contribute to extinction also by releasing trace gases and particulates into the atmosphere that can in turn influence atmospheric chemistry and climate. Further, wildfires remove forests and so enable mass wasting and wash-off of sediments down rivers and into lakes and marginal seas.

Today, many ecosystems are beset by frequent wildfires, and yet they recover. Australia today is perhaps the most fire-affected continent, and large proportions of the northern tropical savannah landscapes are burnt. Yet, much of the savannah biota is remarkably resilient to fire, even high-intensity fire. Fires make little difference to the relative abundances of plants and animals, except for riverbank plants and animals, and small mammals. The 2-yearly cycle of managed burning appears to be too frequent for small mammals, which have undergone significant declines. Overall, however, life recovers from such major fires, and fire seems to be a natural process in such areas.

Counterintuitively perhaps, fire can increase biodiversity. Fires can act as a disturbance, preventing species of late successional stages from excluding those of earlier stages. Fires can therefore increase biodiversity by preventing any single species from dominating. In experimental field studies, observing either natural or artificial fires, the frequency of fires can increase the richness of species that live deep within forests and at forest edges, but species of open landscapes, open forests and interior forests were not influenced by fire frequency. Fire also had a positive impact on animal diversity for most subclades of insects and spiders, but reduced biodiversity of isopods and weevils, some of which prefer damp habitats in dead wood. Flying arthropods proved to be most resilient to fire, then pollen-feeders and foragers, and ground-litter scavengers were least able to recover following major fires.

There are three reasons that wildfires, although they may have been prevalent at the time of the PTME, were probably minor killers: (i) wildfires had been common throughout the Permian, and there is limited evidence they were larger or more devastating at the PTB than earlier; (ii) effects of wildfires can be quickly repaired; and (iii) fire can in fact increase biodiversity, rather than simply reduce it.

Ozone destruction as a killer on land

The ozone shield around the atmosphere may have been destroyed at the end of the Permian by one of three atmospheric gases: halogens, hydrogen sulfide or organohalogens. The initial suggestion was injection of chlorine and fluorine into the atmosphere from the Siberian Traps eruptions. Alternatively, or in addition, hydrogen sulfide and methane generated in the euxinic oceans might have leaked into the atmosphere and had the same effect, although that has been questioned. Another possible cause of breakdown of the ozone layer was the postulated release of large quantities of organohalogens from the heating of organic-rich rocks and hydrothermal fluids, particularly by the passage of molten lavas of the Siberian Traps through thick coal deposits. The ozone layer would have been penetrated at high latitudes, but not around the Equator because of its ‘self-healing’ properties. Modelling results suggest that methane and methyl chloride fluxes triggered by the Siberian Traps eruptions could have reduced ozone production by 60–70% globally, leading to short-term increases in UV light flux of 400% around the Equator and up to 5000% at the poles.

The key evidence for destruction of the ozone layer during the PTME is the appearance of mutated spores and pollen in some rock sections. These were interpreted as having been affected by increased UV-B radiation reaching the Earth from the Sun through an ozone hole, and disrupting normal meiotic (cell division) processes. However, if such mutations are not solely the product of UV-B radiation, and modern experiments show that such effects can be induced by high levels of sulfur dioxide, then it is less certain that the ozone layer did break down during the PTME.

An analysis of malformed spores and pollen grains, unseparated tetrads and darkened walls of spores and pollen (sporoderm) from Permian–Triassic sediments of the Finnmark Platform of offshore Norway concluded that the damage might have been caused by a breakdown in the ozone layer, but more likely by increased heavy-metal ions, arsenic, organohalogens and acid rain (SO2). Perhaps the ozone layer did not break down, or perhaps it did not drive terrestrial extinctions in any major way.

Conclusion

Hyperthermal events, such as at the PTME and the PETM, and many others through the Permian to Jurassic interval, when massive volcanic eruptions triggered sharp global warming, produce a series of perhaps predictable effects. For organisms in the sea, killers were the combined effects of extreme warming acting from above and euxinia from below to produce a narrow to absent habitable depth zone. On land, the killing cocktail was rather different, with an emphasis on acid rain destroying habitats, associated with drought and extreme warming, which halved the habitable area. Wildfires and breakdown of the ozone layer might have contributed to the terrestrial extinctions, or might have had negligible effects. In both cases, hypoxia may have been less of a stressor than had been suggested because of the likely slow rates of change of atmospheric and oceanic oxygen levels.

Hyperthermals have been identified as killers during many Phanerozoic events, especially from the Permian, Mesozoic and Palaeogene. It is important, however, to consider each event in the context of longer-term conditions. The fact that the Permian–Triassic was already a hothouse world may have been significant. In fact, the PTME events exacerbated certain long-term processes, as noted, including increasing temperatures, increasing aridification and reducing atmospheric oxygen throughout the Permian, and continuing into the Triassic. When hyperthermals strike during ice-house conditions, the effects and impacts on life might be different.

Further, some of the consequences of major eruption at the PTB, including global warming, acid rain, mass wasting and marine anoxia, may have been repeated two or three times during the Early Triassic when comparable isotopic perturbations occurred. Certainly, there is evidence for repeated episodes of mass wasting and input of siliciclastic debris into the sea during the Early Triassic, so suggesting repeated episodes of acid rain.

If acid rain, mass wasting and aridity were killers of life on land during the PTME, it ought to be possible to distinguish differences in survival rates between those species that were most likely to have been drought-resistant compared to those that were not. In broad terms, insects and bryophytes might then be expected to have shown higher survival than vertebrates and vascular plants. The difficulty in carrying out a satisfactory meta-analysis of this kind is that many desiccation-tolerant clades, such as rotifers, tardigrades and bryophytes, have poor fossil records, and there is no evidence for measurable differences in drought resistance between major clades of plants, insects and vertebrates that were either victims or survivors of the PTME.

Data accessibility

This article has no additional data.

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.