본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

From fossils to mind

de Sousa, Beaudet, Calvey, Bardo, Benoit, Charvet et al. · 2023

공개 학술지 Communications Biology 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2023년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 de Sousa et al. (2023), Communications Biology · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 5개 올림 이 장 2663낱말
← 앞 장 다음 장 →

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

4장 · From fossils to mind — Paleoanthropological discoveries

As in all the sub-disciplines of paleontology, paleoneurology will benefit from the discovery of new specimens preserving either complete crania or natural endocasts. While they are relatively scarce, from time to time such specimens are unearthed and contribute to a better understanding of brain evolution. In parallel, cutting-edge methods, for example in virtual paleontology, provide exciting new data even from older finds.

Recent fossil discoveries have been used to investigate long-standing questions about the growth, organization, and shape of fossil hominin brains. Comparing the endocranial volumes of two Australopithecus afarensis infants dated to around 3.3 Ma to adult endocranial volumes of the same species, Gunz et al. suggested that these early hominins had a prolonged brain growth compared to chimpanzees after birth. Accordingly, the pattern of brain development that characterizes our species today may have emerged early within our lineage. Another breakthrough came from the discovery and comparative analysis of the endocasts of the earliest Homo sapiens including specimens from Morocco dated to 300,000 years, which revealed a recent origin of the globular shape of the human brain. Indeed, only fossils dated to less than 35,000 years fall within the range of shape variation observed in present-day humans. Future discoveries of fossil crania representing the early ontogenetic stages of brain development will continue to shed light on when patterns of modern human brain development arose. Additional perinatal specimens will shed light on whether cranial shape features can be attributed to prenatal development versus childbirth, and on whether cranial shape of Homo sapiens is a result of facial gracilization.

A recent study investigated a digitized sample of Homo endocasts from Africa and Eurasia using geometric morphometric methods to identify which brain regions had undergone differential expansions. The new analysis suggests reorganization of the inferior frontal gyrus (where Broca’s area is located) probably occurred after 1.8 Ma. Broca’s area is of particular interest due to its role in language, and it is also involved in tasks requiring complex hand movements such as toolmaking. Such fossil findings could be further interpreted in the context of archeological evidence for the emergence of modern human behavior. The timing of this neuroanatomical change could be compared to changes in technology, hand anatomy, and other paleobiological factors. Using the archeological record as a guide, ancient behaviors that arose around 1.8 Ma could be replicated in laboratory studies that use physiological measures of brain and postcranial activity to determine the correspondence between Broca’s area and the behavior of fossil Homo.

The archeological record is a key marker of hominin brain and cognitive evolution. Recent archeological findings have indicated that the earliest use of stone tools was around 3.4 Ma, and the intentional production of stone tools occurred by 3.3 Ma. There is morphological evidence of human-like manipulation dated to around 3 Ma. All of these predate the appearance of the genus Homo by at least 200,000 years ago (Homo sp. remains from an unknown species have been dated to 2.8 Ma). This implies that other hominins also had the ability to use and make stone tools. This includes australopiths, whose hand morphology is close to that of non-human great apes. The recent discovery of Oldowan tools associated with Paranthropus remains also supports the idea that non-Homo hominin species may have had the cognitive abilities for using and making tools. Furthermore, archeological studies that applied recently available techniques, such as microwear analysis and spatial analysis, have contributed to a new appreciation of the Neanderthals’ role in the production of bone tools and symbolic structures. Future discoveries about fossil hominin material culture, functional anatomy, and neurobiology will continue to shed light on their technological and socio-cultural abilities.

Sharing data and tools

Investigations of complex phenomena, such as brain evolution, benefit from holistic, integrative approaches that synthesize diverse data from multiple sources, allowing researchers to address questions beyond the capabilities of any one group (Fig. 5). Research consortia are one solution to this challenge. ManyPrimates is an open grassroots consortium that collects comparative experimental psychological data about diverse primate species to address questions about the origin of the human mind using phylogenetic models. In completing its first study, it has built a reproducible infrastructure for conducting broad-scale collaborative comparative research. Despite this success, however, such big team science approaches face funding challenges and are not always free and openly available.

More expansive approaches draw from open science principles, reproducible research and FAIR data management practices, alongside the CARE principles for indigenous data governance. As we enter “the decade of digital brain”, the neuroscientific community is developing a concept to work with data to obtain new knowledge and model the brain. The COVID-19 pandemic provided a case study on the scientific success achievable through collaborative as opposed to competitive knowledge generation emphasized by open science. It follows that improvements in data integration accelerate progress through greater efficiencies, and more powerful analyses with greater dimensionality.

The transition to open science and integration represents a major shift in our epistemic culture (sensu Cetina) and comprises two sets of challenges. First are the difficulties posed by social, political, and economic hurdles to open sharing. Across scientific fields, researchers are often reluctant to share data in order to maintain priority in publishing and commercial pursuits. However, new generations are bringing fresh expectations regarding information sharing. Progress can be seen in revisions to the education of researchers, where preregistration, data management planning, and information science are increasingly incorporated into basic scientific training. Similarly, journals, funding agencies, and academic societies are shifting their policies to encourage good practice in data sharing. The challenges facing paleoneurology are further exacerbated by the fact that much of the primary fossil, archeological and comparative primatological data are distributed across institutions and cannot physically travel because of safety concerns, intellectual property issues, as well as international regulations pertaining to the export/import of biomaterials from endangered species and cultural artifacts. The COVID–19 pandemic has forced museums to rely more heavily on technology than they previously used to and has stressed the need to create and curate digital data as well as platforms that allow for remote accessibility. Creating digital replicas or proxies for the primary data, including microCT scans of fossils and artifacts, brain MRI scans and digitized histological sections, genetic sequences, and video captures of behavior, all make data more mobile and facilitate sharing. However, curating digital data in a museum comes with advantages as well as disadvantages that need to be addressed, especially if the process is to be carried on in a manner that most benefits local researchers and the custodians of the fossils in developing countries. Efforts at data sharing often run up against ethical issues emanating from the global power imbalances between developed and developing countries, imbalances that echo historic colonization and exploitation. The CARE principles provide a foundation for developing mutually beneficial systems of scientific exchange that respects the rights and authority of indigenous groups living and working with researchers in the field as well as local stakeholders such as the national museums, and cultural heritage authorities responsible for maintaining fossil and archeological collections.

The second major hurdle is technical. Once we can agree to share, how can we integrate the diverse types of data necessary for evolutionary studies of the mind, provided that the data originate from a multitude of sources, teams and domains of interest each with differing research praxes? Technical implementation of open science principles depends on a suite of interrelated best practices, standards and collaborative scientific infrastructure that provide open access to validated primary data. Data that are documented with standardized metadata and indexed can be easily located on the Web. The National Center for Biotechnology Information was established by the USA government to develop automated systems for storing molecular biology data and also provides tools to study them. In another compelling example, the Global Biodiversity Information Framework, developed by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development aggregates primary species occurrence data based largely on databases maintained by the world’s museums and other research institutes. Each institution maintains its records independently, and shares them collaboratively using common data standards such as Darwin Core. Similar systems are available for smaller academic research communities that can serve as model implementations for a collaborative paleoneurology community. These include efforts to systematize data collection protocols in primatology. In paleoanthropology, Paleo Core maintains a data standard derived from Darwin Core, provides tools for field data collection, and an online platform for research teams to collaboratively manage their data. Despite these examples, no overarching infrastructure exists for integrating the diverse neurobiological, molecular, anatomical, fossil, archeological, and behavioral data essential for studying the origin of the human mind. Establishing the necessary infrastructure will require better funding and resources.

Recently, much progress has been made in making digital resources in neuroscience and paleontology freely available to the public. Here we highlight a selection of relevant resources that could be used in paleoneurology. Although we describe these and provide their URLs (Table 1), this is not an exhaustive list, and we also refer the reader to the curated and open Awesome Public Datasets, a repository that covers topics including Neuroscience, Museums, and Biology. All of the atlases, databases, tools, brain collections, resources, and software described here are listed in the webpages of the European Network for Brain Evolution Research, which also links to a mailing list on relevant topics.

Sharing of digital endocast models is available through the digital repositories MorphoMuseum, with endocasts from extant and extinct species (e.g., humans, cercopithecoids, ungulates, cynodonts, dinosaurs, sloths, turtles), and MorphoSource (e.g., bats, rodents, primates, birds). Digitized museum collections, such as paleontological and anthropological 3D models that are available online from the Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences, not only facilitate access to resources, but also allow for new morphometric statistical approaches to be more readily applied to endocasts. In line with this, the digital recognition of sulci using mathematical curvature and automated comparison is becoming more common. Density maps that represent the probability of finding a specific sulcus in a human endocast can be viewed and downloaded from EndoMap. Endocasts can be automatically reconstructed from 3D models of dry crania using the software Endex and an algorithm for labeling detected sulci is freely available online.

As endocasts become increasingly available in digital form, they benefit from comparison to the brains of extant species. An advantage of digital resources is that they can easily be combined in analyses, providing an opportunity for investigations to transcend disciplinary boundaries. Online brain collections allow for the comparison of structures in multiple species, and can be developed into algorithms to improve parcellations. Many of the brain collections are presented along with filters and search functions, and often include tools to annotate and measure them. Significant samples of chimpanzee, human, and other primate brain MRIs, covering the lifespan, have become available. For example, the Brain Analysis Library of Spatial maps and Atlases, an adjunct of the Human Connectome Project, includes MRI and fMRI data from humans and macaques. The National Chimpanzee Brain Resource includes a searchable directory of chimpanzee brain MRIs and physical specimens, with information about rearing, handedness, availability of cognitive test performance, and age. The Primate Data and Resource Exchange (Prime-DRE) is a growing resource for structural, diffusion-weighted and functional MRI data from primates, mainly macaques, and tools to work with these data. Many physical brain collections also feature online inventories and websites. The Primate Brain Bank provides brains for researchers. The Brain Catalogue allows users to interactively view MRI data and surface reconstructions, provides tools for collaborative segmentation, and gives open access to MRI data from a large number of vertebrate species. The Digital Brain Zoo allows users to preview and request structural MRI and diffusion MRI outputs for diverse mammalian species. The Allen Institute shares high-resolution histological and transcriptomic data from humans and mice as adults and in development. PsychENCODE provides human, macaque, and chimpanzee gene expression data in brain tissues over development.

Tools are publicly available to precisely map and measure brain structures from digital brain images. For example, BrainVisa is downloadable free software useful for functions such as mapping sulci. More recently, tools have been developed for online collaborative use. The Web app BrainBox enables researchers to collaborate in real-time on the segmentation of challenging datasets, such as developmental or cross species MRI data, to measure structures of interest and render 3D reconstructions on the fly in the browser. The collection of structural MRI data from 34 primate species used to reconstruct surfaces in Heuer et al. is available on the BrainBox website together with their cerebral masks for easy access and community driven projects.

Histological collections are more demanding to create than MRIs, and require more storage space at high resolutions. Still, some histological collections are available online. Flatbed scans and photos of brains from the Comparative Mammalian Brain Collections spanning over 100 different species of mammals are available online. BrainMaps has comparative neurohistology for several species at microscopic resolution. MicroDraw enables collaborative annotation of digitized histological images. It is available online and supports large histological files, thus enabling researchers to work collaboratively on labor-intensive projects to annotate brain regions of interest on the basis of cellular organization. It has recently been used to provide a layer of collaboration to the Comparative Mammalian Brain Collection. MicroDraw can also be used to work with BigBrain, the first openly accessible, microscopic resolution, 3D model of the human brain. Finally, algorithms utilizing multi-omic datasets are becoming available to facilitate comparison between different species brains and behaviors, with the potential to make life history predictions for fossil species as well. Translating Time is a free Web tool that incorporates the timing of abrupt transformations to translate ages across species. It can also be used to identify biological programs that vary in their timing in humans relative to most other species, including chimpanzees.

Likewise, new computational techniques could address limitations in the study of endocasts. A limitation with understanding species from fossils alone is that their identifications and classifications are uncertain. Recently, artificial intelligence (AI) has been used to classify fossil specimens and develop taxonomies. Also, labeling anatomical data is time consuming and subject to observer error. An efficient pipeline for processing large and complex anatomical image datasets currently used in the biomedical sciences is to crowdsource annotations using citizen science initiatives, and use these data to train deep learning models for human-level performance. Automated taxonomic classifications and anatomical annotations could gain even more robust support from 3D geometric morphometry, and could be compared to vertebrate molecular evidence in the context of phylogeny. Reciprocally, paleoneurology can also inspire the development of AI itself by “reverse engineering” the minds of humans, as well as other species, by documenting the changes that occurred during their natural histories.

We propose a set of guidelines to move the field forward (Box 2). Progress could be made for data sharing and availability by borrowing the advantages from one repository and extending them to others. We need to develop more dynamic data repositories which allow users to input data themselves. There are challenges with species uncertainty in fossil and historical collections that could benefit from more extensive annotations. Another challenge to overcome is how to manage files of very large sizes, such as microscopic resolution histological images. Interdisciplinary dialogues and collaborations are essential to moving the field ahead.

Researchers interested in the origin of the human mind can do the following to accelerate discovery:

• Contribute data and rich metadata in standardized formats to online databases that are open, FAIR, and CARE.

• Where lacking, create new online databases, and provide a way for others in the community to continuously contribute relevant data.

• Acquire long-term government and industry sponsorship for databases and large collaborations.

• Develop comparative resources alongside applications (biomedical, and potentially ecological and cultural) to receive greater funding priority.

• Collaborate in diverse teams to pool resources, data, and expertise about the species studied.

• Collaborate inclusively with stakeholders, museums, local institutions, and local researchers in developed and developing countries.

• Integrate open, FAIR, and CARE data sharing with university teaching and public outreach.

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.