본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Anticipating sea‐level rise and human migration: A review of empirical evidence and avenues for future research

Duijndam, Botzen, Hagedoorn, Aerts · 2021

공개 학술지 Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews. Climate Change 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2021년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Duijndam et al. (2021), Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews. Climate Change · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 3개 올림 이 장 2804낱말
← 앞 장

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

3장 · Anticipating sea‐level rise and human migration: A review of empirical evidence and avenues for future research — A RESEARCH AGENDA FOR FUTURE EMPIRICAL RESEARCH ON SLR AND MIGRATION

The previous section presented the results of a systematic literature review concerning empirical research on the impact of SLR-related hazards on human migration. Based on these results, the following section proposes a research agenda by discussing the main gaps that still exist in the literature and fruitful avenues for future research. With this research agenda, we aim to help bring the science forward and promote research that provides policymakers and other stakeholders with the information they need to anticipate and manage SLR-related migration. The research agenda discusses seven main themes, identifying research avenues for: (a) empirical research for varying geographical contexts and SLR risks, (b) studying a broader set of explanatory variables, (c) utilizing behavioral experiments and risk perception data, (d) differentiating impacts of SLR for subpopulations, (r) defining migration specifics, (f) researching migration together with other adaptation options, and (g) making empirical research complementary to dynamic migration modeling. Consistent with our systematic literature review, this research agenda focuses on quantitative research. Although not discussed in detail here, we acknowledge the importance of qualitative research. Qualitative research allows for a more in-depth and nuanced understanding of migration motives, and is of high value in identifying the role of non-environmental factors like gender and culture, and how these factors interact with environmental change such as SLR (Gioli & Milan, 2018; McLeman & Gemenne, 2018; Zickgraf, 2019). In addition, qualitative work offers important insights and experiences from marginalized and indigenous people (Albert et al., 2018; Farbotko, 2018), whose specific views are not reflected in our review study.

• Empirical research for varying geographical contexts and SLR risks. Despite the wealth of knowledge gained from the 15 articles included in the systematic literature review, our understanding of the issue is still limited. One major limitation is the geographical scope of the current literature. Only seven country contexts are included in our review. Quantitative empirical research is lacking in some of the countries expected to be among the hardest hit by SLR, including China, India, Vietnam, and the African countries of Egypt and Nigeria (Hauer et al., 2020). Studies are also lacking in several developed countries with considerable population numbers in the low-elevation coastal zone, such as the Netherlands and the United Kingdom (Neumann et al., 2015). Migration is generally a less pressing issue in these contexts because coastal protection is put in place and planned for, and is often economically feasible under future SLR scenarios (Lincke & Hinkel, 2018; McEvoy et al., 2021). For instance, in the Netherlands coastal protection currently insulates the population from SLR changes and flood risk perceptions are generally very low (Kellens et al., 2013; Mol et al., 2020). Such case study locations would only become of substantial relevance for SLR migration research would protection fail or risk perceptions increase for other reasons like public awareness programs. Another limitation of present research is the uneven distribution of SLR-related hazards that are studied, with erosion and salinization being understudied compared with flooding. This balance should be improved as worldwide many countries already experience the impacts of salinization as well as coastal and riverbank erosion, which will increase under future SLR (Das et al., 2014; Mentaschi et al., 2018; Smajgl et al., 2015). Future studies focusing on flooding should differentiate between the type of flood event, as the impacts of coastal compared with riverine flooding may be different, sometimes interacting in coastal zones, but are often not accounted for in current studies. These studies could also help to validate and clarify the multidirectional relationship between flooding and migration suggested from the findings of our review, disentangling the role of possibly decisive factors such as flood type and financial constraints. Finally, when studying the impacts of SLR-related hazards on migration, studies should consider not only the role of climate-induced SLR but also that of other (non-climatic) factors driving these hazards, including subsidence (Nicholls, Lincke, et al., 2021).

• Broadening of the set of explanatory variables. The conceptual framework portrayed in Figure 1 theorizes the factors that can be important in explaining migration in the context of SLR. However, many of these factors are not or barely analyzed in the empirical literature. Macrolevel drivers, including economic, social, demographic, and political drivers, are especially understudied. Of particular importance is the impact of government policies on migration decisions, such as adaptation or disaster insurance policies (Wrathall et al., 2019). As these are important tools that governments could use to steer migration, research is needed to provide insights into their effectiveness. Besides using data from available datasets, the effects of macrolevel variables can also be tested in behavioral field experiments or by collecting survey data on people's perceptions, which could be necessary if the geographical scope of the study does not include variation in macrolevel context. Future research could also focus more on the influence of intervening obstacles or facilitators of migration. This includes the costs of migration, which is considered to be of high importance in the migration decision. However, in the literature its impact is often only gauged indirectly by looking at household wealth measures (Kaczan & Orgill-Meyer, 2020). The effect of pull, compared with push, factors also deserves more scholarly attention.

• Utilization of behavioral experiments and risk perception data. Many of the studies included in the literature review presented in this article have analyzed how SLR-related hazards (i.e., flooding, salinization, and erosion) in the past have influenced migration. Although learning from the past gives us important insights, the dynamics of these hazards under future SLR will be markedly different and so will be their impact on migration. When flooding becomes more frequent and severe, and erosion and salinization increases, migration thresholds may be reached that have not been reached in the past. Currently, knowledge about migration thresholds for people under climate change and SLR is increasing but still limited, and more research is needed on what levels and manifestations of SLR trigger (inevitable) migration (Hauer et al., 2020; McLeman, 2018). To circumvent the drawbacks of using data on past migration, behavioral experiments and risk perception studies can be utilized. However, these studies are currently underrepresented in the literature. Research on risk perceptions can help us better understand how SLR already influences migration also beyond hazard exposure or impacts, for instance by studying if people who understand or are worried about SLR are more likely to migrate from vulnerable areas. This also allows for the incorporation of local knowledge in addition to scientific measures of SLR risk (McMichael et al., 2021). This can also improve our understanding of anticipatory migration patterns, instead of reactive migration where most studies so far have focused on. Behavioral experiments, on the other hand, can be utilized to identify when thresholds are reached and people start to migrate. This can be done by presenting respondents with migration and adaptation choices under realistic future SLR scenarios for permanent inundation, flooding, salinization, and/or erosion and analyzing the choices they make. Choice experiments are an example of behavioral experiments that could be used for such purposes (Dachary-Bernard et al., 2019; Train, 2009). Results of behavioral experiments could provide pivotal information on when thresholds are reached for people to migrate, and consequently on when to anticipate migration under different SLR scenarios. Longitudinal, in addition to cross-sectional, studies could help identify if results differ before and after experience with SLR-related events such as flooding, or whether people actually migrate when they experience the SLR-related hazards they were presented with in hypothetical experiments (Bubeck et al., 2012).

• Differentiation of the impacts of SLR for subpopulations. The impacts of SLR on migration are not expected to be uniform across populations. For instance, vulnerable population groups like women, the elderly, the poor, and minorities, tend to be less capable of acting on climate risks, especially in developing countries (Gioli & Milan, 2018; Otto et al., 2017; Rahman, 2013). However, this heterogeneity is not properly accounted for in the analytical strategies of most of the quantitative empirical literature, which is characterized by the use of linear regressions on the full sample. Better accounting for population heterogeneity is imperative, and prevents oversimplification of the environment-migration relationship. To do this, future studies could estimate separate regressions for different population groups, such as is done by Mueller et al. (2014) for gender, or include interaction effects between SLR and socio-demographic indicators (e.g., interacting soil salinity with income). It should be taken into account that for reliable results these analyses might require large sample sizes.

• Defining migration specifics. Migration specifics, including when, where and for how long people migrate, are often not well defined, whereas this is pivotal in properly understanding migration dynamics and their causal factors. For instance, only 6 out of the 15 studies in our review specify the migration destination or whether migration is temporary or permanent. Especially migration intention research tends to ignore migration specifics, where often broad dichotomous questions are analyzed on whether respondents plan to migrate in the future, but without considering its particularities. Migration intention research can help identify migration thresholds under future SLR, but loses much of its value when we do not know what this migration will look like. Another important aspect in this domain is that of migrant agency, which is about the agency or freedom an individual/household has in the migration decision-making process (Bakewell, 2010; McLeman, 2014). Migrant agency represents a continuum with fully voluntary and involuntary (forced) migration as the two extremes. The degree of migrant agency in the context of SLR risk may vary (McLeman, 2014), and is important to examine in future research.

• Researching migration as part of a broader array of adaptation options. Most studies research migration as the only outcome, whereas people can adapt to SLR in many other ways than migration, such as by flood proofing their houses or by cultivating saline-tolerant crops (Jamero et al., 2017; McLeman, 2014). Therefore, one of the greatest challenges for future research is to break the silos of the migration and mainstream adaptation literature, and to bundle strengths to explain how people respond to SLR risk. Compared with the migration literature, the literature on in-situ adaptation to SLR-related hazards is much larger and further developed, with most attention being focused on flood adaptation (Bubeck et al., 2012; Koerth et al., 2017; Paik et al., 2020). Combining both strands of literature could provide important insights into the circumstances under which people will implement private adaptation measures to protect themselves against SLR, when people will decide to migrate, how these relate to each other, and which response will be more likely under future SLR scenarios. A choice experiment analysis in the United States by Buchanan et al. (2019) where respondents under different flood scenarios choose whether to take up insurance, elevate their homes, or migrate, provides a good example of such an integrative approach.

• Making empirical research complementary to migration modeling research. It is of high policy relevance to obtain reliable forecasts on the key dimensions of human migration under future SLR: how many people will migrate, where they will migrate to, the timing of their migration, and their socio-economic situation before and after migration (McLeman & Gemenne, 2018; Wrathall et al., 2019). Dynamic migration modeling approaches can be employed to obtain such forecasts, and examples include gravity models (Afifi & Warner, 2008), radiation models (Davis et al., 2018), machine learning models (Robinson et al., 2020), and agent-based models (Bell et al., 2021). Although all these model types have their merits, in the remainder our focus will be on agent-based models (ABMs) because of their unique capability to model complex individual decision-making processes while incorporating socio-ecological interactions at the individual/household level (Klabunde & Willekens, 2016). ABMs can take into account heterogeneity in the characteristics of individuals/households, and aggregate micro-level results to population-level migration outcomes (Klabunde & Willekens, 2016; Kniveton et al., 2011; Thober et al., 2018; Wrathall et al., 2019). The use of ABMs has become increasingly popular among migration scholars, and a few ABM studies have simulated migration under future SLR (e.g., Bell et al., 2021; Hassani-Mahmooei & Parris, 2012). Empirical studies, like the studies included in our review, have an important role to play in developing realistic ABMs, and as a result in making their outcomes useful for policymakers (Gray et al., 2017; Schlüter et al., 2017; Williams et al., 2017). We highlight two ways in which empirical research can contribute, both reflecting key decisions that have to be made by ABM modelers. First, ABM modelers select and parametrize a set of variables that influence migration behavior in the model. Quantitative survey-based research can facilitate this by providing insights into the main factors that influence migration and their effect sizes. Second, ABM modelers decide about the behavioral decision-rules that agents follow (i.e., how individuals/households make decisions in the model), which are preferably guided by behavioral decision theory (Groeneveld et al., 2017). The choice and formalization of a theory can determine to a large extent the outcomes of the model, and it is therefore important that a theory is chosen that is most appropriate for the specific research context (Klabunde & Willekens, 2016; Schlüter et al., 2017; Wens et al., 2020). Some of the most commonly used behavioral theories in social-ecological ABMs include economic theories such as Subjective Expected Utility Theory and Prospect Theory and psycho-sociological theories such as the Theory of Planned Behavior and Protection Motivation Theory (Aerts, 2020; Schlüter et al., 2017). Empirical survey-based research can aid in the choice and the subsequent calibration of a behavioral theory. For instance, our review of the empirical literature illustrates that economic wealth can play an important role in whether someone migrates after SLR disasters. This seems to indicate that people's (economic) capability to migrate is an important factor in the migration decision, which is one of the key elements in the Theory of Planned Behavior and Protection Motivation Theory, and can be incorporated in economic decision models as budget constraints. Applying behavioral theories that approach the true complexity of human behavior would be an important step in designing realistic ABMs, as at present still much of the ABM literature is not firmly grounded in behavioral theory or assumes rational agent behavior (Gray et al., 2017; Groeneveld et al., 2017; Schlüter et al., 2017). There is also potential in integrating the migration and adaptation literature in ABM modeling, so that future pathways of both SLR-induced adaptation and migration can be simulated. Indeed, much ABM development is already going on in the flood adaptation literature (Haer et al., 2019; Zhuo & Han, 2020), and we encourage exploring cross-fertilizations between both strands of research.

CONCLUSION

SLR presents a substantial threat to hundreds of millions of people living in coastal areas. Migration is one way for people to adapt, and may increasingly become the preferred option when SLR impacts intensify in the future. Knowledge about migration dynamics under SLR is important to allow for anticipatory policymaking and to better understand the welfare impacts of climate change. In this article, we present the results of a systematic review of the empirical literature and bring together existing knowledge on the relationship between migration behavior and SLR-related hazards including flooding, salinization, and erosion. This review adds to existing reviews on climate change and human migration by focusing specifically on SLR-related hazards, which is valuable given the growth in empirical studies on this topic in recent years. Findings from our review indicate no clear association between flooding and higher levels of migration. Severe flooding is often even associated with decreased levels of long-term migration in developing countries, although the underpinnings of this finding remain unclear from present research. Salinization and erosion have been investigated in fewer studies, in which they tend to be associated with increased levels of migration. Important factors that influence migration alongside SLR-related hazards include income, homeownership, place attachment, race, social networks, and risk attitudes.

Despite an increase in scholarly attention in recent years, the number of studies on SLR-related hazards and migration is still limited and there are promising ways to improve upon existing findings. Therefore, we also presented a research agenda outlining knowledge gaps in the literature and fruitful avenues for future research. We highlight that dynamics of SLR-related hazards such as flooding will be markedly different under future SLR than they were in the past. As a result, we encourage research to investigate how people will likely respond to future SLR scenarios, for instance by utilizing behavioral experiments. We also encourage scholars to clearly define migration specifics, expand the geographic contexts and explanatory variables that are investigated, differentiate impacts of SLR for subpopulation groups, and study migration as part of a broader array of adaptation strategies that people can choose. Finally, we discuss how empirical research can aid agent-based modeling, which is a promising approach to forecast migration flows under future SLR scenarios. What is clear is that more empirical research is needed if we want to properly understand the complex dynamics of migration under SLR and anticipate it in a timely manner. We hope that our work can give directions for such endeavors.

RELATED WIREs ARTICLES

A mobilities perspective on migration in the context of environmental change

Spatial and temporal ways of knowing sea level rise: Bringing together multiple perspectives

Integrating new sea-level scenarios into coastal risk and adaptation assessments: An ongoing process

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.