본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Conservation of biodiversity in the genomics era

Supple, Shapiro · 2018

공개 학술지 Genome Biology 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2018년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Supple & Shapiro (2018), Genome Biology · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 3개 올림 이 장 1863낱말
← 앞 장

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

3장 · Conservation of biodiversity in the genomics era — Genomic inbreeding and genetic rescue

Genetic rescue is a conservation tool used to increase the fitness of at-risk populations by introducing new genetic variation into the population. This is usually accomplished by translocating individuals from a closely related population (assuming that such a population exists) into an at-risk population. Genetic rescue is expected to be most useful for small, isolated populations that suffer from inbreeding. Theoretical models suggest that such populations have lower fitness because they carry an increased genetic load: the reduced efficiency of selection and the increased action of drift is predicted to allow mildly deleterious alleles to drift to high frequency. The goal of genetic rescue is to introduce new genetic variants that contain more favorable alleles, thereby reducing the genetic load. This potentially powerful conservation tool is rarely used, in part because of concerns over outbreeding depression and the difficulty in predicting the outcomes of planned genetic rescue programs.

To make decisions regarding genetic rescue, it is important to understand the level of inbreeding in the population, which depends on the size of the population and its demographic history. A common way to estimate the level of inbreeding is to calculate a genome-wide estimate using either genetic markers or a pedigree. Because genetic markers estimate realized inbreeding but pedigrees estimate expected inbreeding (including a large variation due to stochastic processes), estimates from genetic markers are more accurate. Additionally, pedigrees often lack sufficient depth to capture inbreeding events that occurred more than a few generations previously. Recently, whole-genome sequencing has enabled a transition from focusing on genome-wide estimates of inbreeding to examining patterns of inbreeding across the genome. Homozygous genomic regions within an individual, which are a result of inbreeding, are broken down over time by recombination. Therefore, the lengths of runs of homozygosity can be used to estimate the timing of inbreeding events.

In addition to estimating the timing and the level of inbreeding, it is useful to estimate the deleterious fitness effects that result from an increase in homozygosity. The fitness effects of a particular genetic variant in a protein-coding sequence can be predicted from models of protein structure and by comparing the level of sequence conservation across species. Predicting the fitness effects of these variants across the genome allows the estimation of the genomic load of deleterious alleles carried by a population. Combining this information with patterns of inbreeding across the genome can identify candidate loci underlying inbreeding depression, as predicted deleterious alleles that occur in homozygous regions may be causing phenotypic defects. Conversely, regions of consistently high heterozygosity in otherwise homozygous genomes may be harboring recessive lethal alleles, with individuals not surviving if they are homozygous for the deleterious allele.

Genomic information about inbreeding and deleterious alleles can be valuable for managers who are considering a genetic rescue program. First, researchers should determine whether the population has reduced genetic diversity and a substantial amount of inbreeding. If so, they should then determine whether the inbreeding is predicted to have negative consequences on the fitness of the population and whether genetic rescue is predicted to increase fitness. If managers decide to establish a genetic rescue program, they should then decide which populations and which individuals will be used as the source of translocations into the at-risk population. All of these decisions, including the decision not to initiate a rescue program, rely on being able to predict the genomic consequences of the different available options.

One classic example of a successful genetic rescue is the Florida panther, a subspecies of mountain lion. By the early 1990s, Florida panthers were critically endangered, with only 20–25 adult panthers living in the wild. Severely reduced genetic variation and high levels of inbreeding were causing phenotypic defects, including poor sperm quality and cardiac abnormalities. Given the high likelihood of extinction, the decision was made to translocate eight wild mountain lions from the Texas subspecies, reopening historical gene flow between these two populations. As a result of the genetic rescue combined with other management actions phenotypic defects decreased and the population size increased.

Genetic rescue, however, is not always successful, as seen with the wolves of Isle Royale National Park. It was hoped that a natural migration of a single wolf in 1997 might genetically rescue this small and isolated island population. Initially, the influx of new genetic material seemed to increase the fitness of the wolf population. But as the migrant’s genotype swept to high frequency, the population began to decline, until a population low of two highly related adult wolves in 2016. Researchers hypothesize that the migrant carried recessive deleterious alleles, the nature of which were masked by heterozygosity in the early generations but were revealed with increasing homozygosity in subsequent generations. Genomic analyses, particularly the identification of deleterious alleles, may have been able to predict the failure of this genetic rescue. The USFWS has approved a plan to reintroduce 20–30 wolves to Isle Royale over a 3-year period, so the ability to predict the genomic consequences of reintroductions may help to select individuals that will support a healthy population. However, in most non-model systems with limited genomic resources, the accuracy of predictions of the fitness effects of particular genotypes are similarly limited.

Even in systems that are able to leverage the genomic resources of model systems, it has proved difficult to connect predicted high deleterious loads to decreased population fitness. The Channel Island fox, for example, occurs in only very small and isolated populations. Genomic analyses using genomic resources developed for domestic dogs revealed extremely low levels of genomic diversity and an increased load of deleterious mutations in Channel Island fox populations. These genome characteristics suggest that the populations should have low fitness and should be at risk of extinction; however, Channel Island fox populations seem to be healthy, perhaps because of their ecologically stable and low-stress environment in which they lack competitors and predators. Another species in which deleterious mutational load has been estimated is the critically endangered mountain gorilla, which shows similar genomic patterns of low genome-wide diversity, long runs of homozygosity, and a predicted high load of deleterious alleles. It is unclear whether the decline in genetic diversity in mountain gorillas is causing a decline in fitness, but researchers have observed phenotypic signs of inbreeding.

Increasing genomic resources in model and non-model systems, combined with improved prediction algorithms, should help researchers and managers to better identify at-risk populations and to understand the genomic and fitness consequences of different proposed management actions.

Future prospects

Genomic sequencing is helping to inform conservation decisions by providing critical information regarding species of conservation concern. Although the current focus of conservation genomics is on monitoring and managing existing genomes of species, new genomic technologies will allow researchers to manipulate genomes to help achieve conservation goals. Genome-editing technologies such as CRISPR–Cas9 allow precise genome editing at relatively low cost. Using a guide RNA to identify a specific region of the genome, the CRISPR complex binds to the target DNA and cleaves it. The DNA repair mechanism fixes the double-stranded DNA break, resulting in a sequence modification that is likely to knock out the function of the gene. Alternatively, a template sequence can be added to the CRISPR complex and used for repair, allowing the insertion of a specific sequence with desired genome edits.

The ability to use genome editing to replace alleles might enable researchers to assist the evolution of species by improving disease resistance or by enhancing adaptation to changing climates. For example, an older gene transfer technology, Agrobacterium-mediated transformation, has been used to incorporate fungal blight-resistant genes from wheat into the American chestnut tree, which is nearly extinct as a result of an introduced fungal pathogen. This modified strain is being outcrossed with the existing American chestnut gene pool via natural stump sprouts that remain after the trees have succumbed to the blight. This method incorporates blight resistance into the existing genome-wide diversity with the hope of producing blight-resistant American chestnut trees in their native range.

A similar plan has been proposed to save the critically endangered black-footed ferret. The black-footed ferret was once widespread across the Great Plains, but a combination of factors, including habitat loss and disease, caused its extinction in the wild. A successful captive breeding program was initiated, but reintroduction has been hampered by the susceptibility of black-footed ferrets to sylvatic plague. A proposal has been submitted to the USFWS to use genetic engineering to induce plague immunity in captive-bred black-footed ferrets using DNA sequences from plague immunity alleles from the domestic ferret.

Similarly, genetic-engineering techniques could be applied to help corals become more resistant to rising water temperatures. Heat-resistant alleles could be engineered from heat-tolerant corals and introduced into susceptible corals. To this end, work has already begun to develop CRISPR techniques in coral symbionts to increase the resilience of coral reefs to climate change-related stressors.

Other applications of genome-editing technologies with potential use in conservation are gene drives. Genetically engineered gene drives increase the inheritance of the engineered allele to spread the desired trait through the population. Gene drives are currently being tested in mosquitos with the goal of controlling malaria in human populations, but this technology could be transferred to control avian malaria, which has been introduced to Hawaii and is a major cause of bird population declines. Gene drives are also a promising method of eradicating invasive rodents from islands by using methods to alter sex determination, resulting in reduced reproduction until the invasive species is extirpated from the island.

New technologies also allow us to move beyond making small changes to the genome. For instance, cloning by somatic cell nuclear transfer has been proposed as an approach to reintroduce lost genetic material into the black-footed ferret using preserved cell lines from an extinct lineage. In the future, genomic technologies may even allow us to resurrect important ecological traits that disappeared when species became extinct, potentially redressing past effects that humans have had on ecosystems.

Whether using traditional conservation genetics or cutting-edge genomic engineering, any action taken—or not taken—comes with practical, legal, and ethical issues that need to be discussed with researchers, managers, and the public. With emerging technologies in mind, seed banks and frozen zoos can ensure that existing genetic variation is preserved. These archives are not intended to replace traditional conservation measures, but rather they should act as insurance policies. Genetic material that is saved now may be able to be used for the currently unimaginable genomic technologies of the future.

Conclusions

As human activities drive our planet into its sixth mass extinction event, genomic technologies will be an important tool for conservation researchers, helping to provide valuable scientific information to managers and policy makers. Genetic approaches have a long history of use in conservation, but the transition to genomic technologies is only just beginning. By expanding available data sets to the genomic scale, researchers can ask and answer different questions and can thus gain valuable insights that will be applicable to conservation. As genomic technologies continue to advance, the potential for these technologies to impact conservation decisions increases. The knowledge we gain will hopefully enable us to mitigate our impact on the earth’s biota.

Authors’ contributions

Both authors wrote the manuscript and approved the final version.

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.