본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Hyperthermal-driven mass extinctions: killing models during the Permian–Triassic mass extinction

Benton · 2018

공개 학술지 Philosophical transactions. Series A, Mathematical, physical, and engineering sciences 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2018년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Benton (2018), Philosophical transactions. Series A, Mathematical, physical, and… · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 4개 올림 이 장 2722낱말
← 앞 장 다음 장 →

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

3장 · Hyperthermal-driven mass extinctions: killing models during the Permian–Triassic mass extinction — Hyperthermals as killers on land

Killers on land

Hypoxia and global warming have been cited as killers of life on land at the PTME. However, the hyperthermal event triggered many other physical environmental catastrophes that might have played as important a role, including aridity, acid rain and mass wasting, wildfires and opening of an ozone hole. Establishing which of these might have been important is hard because there have been no meta-analytical studies of terrestrial victims and survivors through the PTME analogous to the comparisons of well- and poorly buffered marine taxa. The arguments then revert to the circumstantial, namely considering what happens in modern plants and animals, issues concerning rates of change and whether any anecdotal fossil evidence can be identified to support a particular case.

Hypoxia as a killer on land

Of the marine killers, hypoxia has been cited most often as having been important also on land. The focus has been on insects and vertebrates, whose existence was supposedly curtailed by the reduced oxygen levels coincident with the PTME. For plants, the effects of low oxygen are complex; experiments show that hypoxia generally reduces vegetative growth in C3 plants, but not in C4 plants, and it can decrease seed growth.

Physiological experiments on modern insects show that they can escape ill effects of hypoxia by moving to areas of higher oxygen, or by opening spiracles and pumping, so more oxygen reaches their tissues. Further, many insects can tolerate a wide range of oxygen partial pressures in their muscles. Hypoxia causes physical adaptation, such as increasing tracheal diameter or the penetration of trachea into tissues, or increasing haemoglobin levels in the blood, all of which enable them to extract more oxygen. Insects can also switch to anaerobic pathways for ATP production, and reduce oxygen demand by reducing body size by reducing development time, growth rate and fecundity. Modern insects encounter hypoxia in aquatic habitats (evaporating pools), in soils and flooded burrows, and at high altitudes.

Similarly, vertebrates can adapt to hypoxia by reducing growth rates and body size, and by improving lung and gill structures and haemoglobin volumes to improve oxygen extraction efficiency. Ectothermic fishes, amphibians and reptiles are generally better able to adapt to hypoxia than endotherms such as mammals and birds, because of their very different metabolic demands. The degrees of tolerance to hypoxia can vary enormously, with some reports of almost miraculous feats of survival by carp, crocodiles and turtles in frozen ponds. More usually, modern ectothermic vertebrates can tolerate hypoxia by making long-term physiological adaptations by suppressing their metabolism, being able to tolerate metabolite accumulation, and in establishing free-radical defences during reoxygenation. In all these cases, however, the insects or vertebrates are responding to relatively short-term experimental stimuli, and so the effects of a longer-term fall in oxygen levels are harder to predict. If the level was low, but not unsustainable, then some taxa would be driven to extinction by the stress, and others might adapt by modifying their respiratory anatomy and biochemistry, and by reducing body size.

In the case of the PTME, some palaeontologists have pointed to real physical changes in the reptiles of the day. For example, they noted that the anomodont Lystrosaurus, which was a famous survivor, had a barrel-like chest to accommodate expanded lungs, perhaps a muscular diaphragm to force air in and out of the lungs more speedily, and a possible four-chambered heart to improve the efficiency of blood circulation. In addition, late Permian and Triassic therapsids had nasal turbinates, thin bone lamellae within the nasal cavity that substantially increase the area of nasal mucous membranes, possibly to enhance oxygen uptake, to assist with countercurrent heat exchange or both. It has also been noted that, in anomodonts, the secondary palate and the internal nostrils were enlarged, both supposedly to improve oxygen uptake. These are all ingenious observations, but they could all have other explanations, such as a switch in physiology from ectothermic to endothermic, or changing body size. Further, the rate of change in oxygen levels in the atmosphere was likely exceptionally slow, and quite inadequate to cause serious levels of extinction.

Global warming as a killer on land

There is evidence for substantial temperature change through the PTME and Early Triassic crises. The first effect on life on land was surely migration, as plants and animals fled the tropics to more congenial locations. In a study based on both skeletal and footprint data, details of these migrations were detected, with a clear geographical disjunction through the PTME, with tetrapod distribution shifting 10–15° poleward. There was then a rapid expansion phase across the whole of Pangaea following the PTME. These changes support a model of generalized migration of tetrapods to higher latitudinal, cooler regions, to escape from the superhot equatorial climate in the earliest Triassic, but the effect was shorter in duration, and not as pronounced as had been proposed.

For those plants and animals that did not move, high temperatures of 35–40°C would be lethal for most. In C3 plants, photorespiration replaces photosynthesis at temperatures over 35°C and few plants can survive above 40°C. In trees, heat stress reduces photosynthesis, increases photo-oxidative stress, causes leaves to burn and fall and reduces overall growth rates. In some species, stomatal conductance increases at high temperatures, which may be a mechanism for leaf cooling. Heat tolerance in trees varies enormously depending on species, and even between individuals of a species. Elevated atmospheric CO2 can mitigate heat stress in certain cases. For most animals, temperatures of 40°C or higher can cause protein damage that can be countered only for short heat shocks by the production of heat-shock proteins.

The combined effects of extreme high temperatures and drought were studied in the European drought of summer 2003. For three months, leaf temperatures commonly exceeded 40°C, and, during these times, photosynthesis was reduced, mainly by biochemical limitations rather than closure of stomata. Concentrations of carotenoids increased in leaves to improve protection against photo-oxidative damage. Other changes included reduction in cholorophyll concentration, closure of stomata and early senescence of leaves, presumably to protect the tree's hydraulic system by reducing transpiration. Many species of trees readily survived several months of extreme high temperatures and drought by ceasing growth, but it is not clear how long they could suspend their normal systems under prolonged heat stress.

For many animals, there is a critical temperature limit beyond which their physiological systems are compromised. From 35 to 40°C, most animals become uncomfortable, and seek to remove themselves from those high temperatures. For most metazoans, the absolute upper lethal temperature limit is said to be 47°C, and responses of animals on land can be observed today in desert studies. In Saudi Arabia, for example, the ambient temperature often reaches 45°C, and in summer, soil surface temperatures can even exceed 60°C. At temperatures above 35–40°C, respiratory evaporative water loss increases markedly, and yet this physiological cooling mechanism is full of danger as high environmental temperatures are usually associated with low water availability.

Aridity as a killer on land

Today, extreme high temperatures on land are often associated with drought, which generally exacerbates the challenge for trees. A normal response to high temperature would be to open the stomata and increase transpiration and physical cooling of leaves; drought prevents this response.

Permian–Triassic climates were generally warm. The supercontinent Pangaea extended from pole to pole, and a deep oceanic gulf, Tethys, split the supercontinent around the Equator (figure 3). Climate modelling of this unusual continental and oceanic configuration highlights the broad tropical belt with a strong monsoonal regime. Extreme continental conditions prevailed, with hot summers and cold winters. The poles were ice-free, and polar sediments include coals, plants and spoils typical of cool temperate latitudes.

In the Late Permian, Pangaea was characterized by high average temperatures, and a very broad semiarid belt around the more humid Equator. In many regions, aridity increased across the PTB and into the Early Triassic, with the northward and southward expansion of low-latitude arid belts into the vast formerly humid basins of European Russia and South Africa (figure 3). Primary sedimentological evidence of aeolian sediments, such as the preservation of ancient dunes, suggests an expansion through the PTB. Extensive areas of aeolian dune sandstones are reported from the Late Permian of the Paraná Basin of eastern South America, and then at the PTB from new locations, including the rift basins of Iberia, the south Urals and central Europe, in areas that had formerly been humid during the Late Permian. This expansion of the arid belt was countered by increases in precipitation in other regions to balance the hydrological cycle.

Unusually, drought-killed associations of skeletons have been reported from the earliest Triassic of the Karoo Basin in South Africa. The jumbled skeletons were interpreted as killed by drought around a shrinking water hole, and then aggregated by subsequent rainfall and transport. The drought interpretation is supported by the sedimentology of the sites, which shows lowering of water tables, the onset of drying through the loss of vegetation, the spread of vast playa lakes and accumulation of thin wind-blown laminae of loess dust.

Desiccation is an obvious stressor for plants and animals on land, frequently associated with high temperatures. All life depends on abundant water, so organisms show many adaptations to conserve water and minimize loss in adverse conditions. Anti-desiccation adaptations are physiological, and behavioural for animals, which always seek to avoid extreme drying by moving to shade or foraging at night. Physiological adaptations include, in insects, for example, their impermeable cuticle with waxy components, tracheae with spiracles that can close and means to limit water excretion. Some insects pass into a dormant phase in desiccating conditions, where they choose a cool spot, reduce their body water content, decrease cuticular permeability, absorb water vapour and tolerate low body water levels. The chironomid midge Polypedilum vanderplanki is the largest multi-cellular animal known to survive almost complete dehydration without ill effect. Its larvae can tolerate an astonishing range of environmental temperatures, from −270 to +106°C, and it can recover after prolonged dehydration of up to 17 years. Part of the explanation seems to involve the rapid accumulation of the disaccharide sugar trehalose, which vitrifies, or forms an amorphous phase on desiccation, and so locks in water and other macromolecules.

Water loss through the skin is a crucial problem for animals. In insects, the biochemistry of their cuticle sets a critical limit beyond which water loss cannot be controlled. The same is true for vertebrates. During normal conditions, birds lose about 70% of water through their skin, but from 35 to 40°C, this breaks down and the rate of respiratory water loss increases exponentially (figure 4). In reptiles and birds, water loss through the skin is controlled by waterproofing lipids in the outer layer of the skin, the stratum corneum. At normal skin temperatures, lipids form a dynamic mosaic in different phases, but primarily the orthorhombic phase, in which lipid molecules are packed close together and provide good waterproofing. As temperature rises above 40°C, lipids switch to the gel or liquid crystalline phase, and they are spaced further apart, providing holes in the lamellae through which water molecules can pass.

Simple organisms may be remarkably desiccation-tolerant, most notably certain bacteria and cyanobacteria, some of which can survive nearly complete removal of water, when the water content is less than 0.1 g H2O g⁻¹ of dry mass. Such prokaryotes can sometimes survive complete drying for months or years, until water becomes available again. Desiccation tolerance is also shown by some metazoans, famously brine shrimp, tardigrades, rotifers and some insects. The brine shrimp Artemia franciscana produces embryonic cysts that can survive for 2 years in dry conditions, without oxygen, or even at temperatures below freezing or up to 80°C. In this species, the outermost envelope of the cyst is essential for its remarkable tolerance to stress. Tardigrades, or ‘water bears’, are arthropod-like microscopic animals that can survive in extreme environments, including temperatures close to absolute zero and as high as 151°C, massive doses of radiation and spans of up to 10 years without water. Tardigrades have even survived the vacuum of outer space for a few days. Tardigrades resist desiccation by shrinking, infolding their cuticle, reducing transpiration and forming an inert cyst. They possess ‘intrinsically disordered proteins’ that form non-crystalline amorphous solids upon desiccation; in other words they vitrify, or form a glass-like substance, that locks in macromolecules and prevents damage under all kinds of physical environmental pressures. Finally, rotifers, small (less than 2 mm) aquatic animals, are adapted to desiccation. Many live in temporary freshwater pools or terrestrial mosses or lichens, and when these habitats dry up, they can alter their morphology and physiology, assuming a compact dormant phase called a ‘tun’. Rotifers can survive annual cycles of drought, and the longest reported survival is 9 years. They then recover in minutes or hours when exposed to water. Rotifers, tardigrades and most other desiccation-resistant animals and plants possess the disaccharide sugar trehalose, as in certain insects.

As noted earlier, high temperatures and drought often go together, and adaptation to both stressors is commonplace in desert plants. Seeds are famous plant adaptations for surviving droughts, and many can remain viable for 5–10 years, and there are some credible records of 200-year-old seeds germinating. Desiccation tolerance in seeds is promoted by mechanisms that prevent lethal damage to cellular components, including membranes, proteins and cytoplasm. There are three main protective systems: the accumulation of non-reducing sugars such as trehalose, which stabilize membranes and proteins in dry conditions and lock in water in a glass phase in the cytoplasm; the ability to prevent, tolerate or repair a free-radical attack during desiccation; and the occurrence of protective proteins in late embryogenesis.

Among plants, bryophytes (mosses and liverworts) include many extreme survivors of desiccation; as an example, a dried herbarium specimen was reported to have regrown after 23 years of storage in entirely dry conditions. Bryophytes differ from vascular plants in being smaller, having leafy shoots that equilibrate rapidly with the water potential in their surroundings and having shoots that tend to be either fully hydrated or desiccated and metabolically inactive. Bryophytes can suspend normal physiological processes when dried, and then respiration, photosynthesis and protein synthesis can recover in minutes or hours; recovery of the cell cycle, food transport and the cytoskeleton may take a day or more.

Vascular plants, including ferns, conifers and flowering plants, do not show such extremes of adaptation to desiccation. Indeed, the 300 species of angiosperms that can recover after severe desiccation are so unusual that they are termed ‘resurrection plants’; these belong to some 10 angiosperm families, and evolved their special properties convergently. Adaptations to desiccation include modifications to the cell membranes and macromolecules, especially the production of large amounts of desiccation-induced protective proteins. These have different roles in cellular protection, by conserving the structures of macromolecules and membranes, by stabilizing membrane structures and proteins, by avoiding mechanical damage from vacuole shrinkage in dehydrating cells and by minimizing oxidative stress from the enhanced production of reactive oxygen. Resurrection plants can survive for months or years without water, and then regrow at full vigour when watered, but they do not survive for years.

From the fact that high temperatures and drought occurred through the time of the PTME, and knowledge about desiccation tolerance in modern organisms, it should be possible to explore how far drought contributed to the PTME killings. Studies of the physiology of modern microbes, plants and animals have shown that some clades are extremely desiccation-tolerant, and evidence could be sought whether the extinctions were selective. This would apply especially to some invertebrate and plant groups, if the stress lasted no more than 1–10 years, and where seeds or resting cysts could preserve the species long enough. Such desiccation tolerance might be restricted to small plants and animals, for example, plants less than 3 m and animals less than 5 mm, and particularly those animals with rigid skeletons. Many desiccation-tolerant organisms share biochemical and cellular mechanisms, such as sugars that replace water and form glasses, proteins that stabilize macromolecules and membranes, and anti-oxidants that counter damage by reactive oxygen species. These systems are often triggered by drying, and some of the genes involved may be homologous in microbes, plants and animals. In that the drought was likely not worldwide during the PTME, this can have been only a regional killer, contributing to driving many plants and animals into smaller geographical areas that were free of excessive warmth and drought.

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.