본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Theory and classification of mass extinction causation

Algeo, Shen · 2023

공개 학술지 National Science Review 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2023년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Algeo & Shen (2023), National Science Review · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 5개 올림 이 장 1697낱말
← 앞 장 다음 장 →

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

3장 · Theory and classification of mass extinction causation — Ultimate causation

The current status of research on mass extinction causation is that each of the Big Five biocrises has been robustly linked to one of three different ultimate mechanisms. In addition, there is some evidence to support a fourth mechanism, i.e. tectono-oceanic events such as the opening/closing of oceanic gateways, for certain second-order biocrises (see below). Based on the foregoing discussion, we propose that mass extinction causation is best considered from the joint perspective of both proximate and ultimate mechanisms. In this context, we propose a classification system of mass extinction events based on a combination of (i) the ultimate trigger and (ii) the pattern of carbon-cycle change (i.e. carbon release vs. carbon burial) (Fig. 4). In this scheme, biocrises known to have been triggered by a bolide impact or LIP eruption are exclusively carbon-release events owing to their fundamentally destructive natures, whereas biocrises triggered by bioevolutionary or tectono-oceanic processes can be variably carbon-release, carbon-burial or carbon-neutral events, depending on the specific relationships of each trigger to the global carbon cycle (Fig. 4). This classification accommodates all biocrises with well-established or tentatively known causations at present, although if the viability of another ultimate mechanism were demonstrated in the future, it could readily be accommodated through an expansion of this scheme.

Here, we consider four types of ultimate causes, or triggers, of mass extinctions: (i) bolide impacts, (ii) LIP eruptions, (iii) bioevolutionary events and (iv) tectono-oceanic events. In this survey, we offer relatively limited coverage of the bolide impact and LIP eruption mechanisms, which have been the subject of earlier in-depth reviews (e.g. and, respectively). On the other hand, the roles of bioevolutionary and tectono-oceanic triggers in causing biocrises remain seriously understudied despite their probable importance through Earth history (especially the former), and thus they will be considered in greater detail. Although various extraterrestrial causes other than bolide impacts have been proposed (e.g. solar flares, gamma bursts and supernova explosions) and some of them have an extensive literature (e.g. supernovas; Fig. 1), there is little to no evidence that any of these mechanisms have actually caused a terrestrial biocrisis, and thus they will not be considered here.

Evidence for bolide impacts

There are ∼200 confirmed bolide impact craters on Earth (http://passc.net/EarthImpactDatabase/New%20website_05-2018/Index.html). However, craters are subject to destruction over time through erosion and subduction processes, and comparison with the impact records of the Moon, Mars and Mercury makes clear that only a small fraction of terrestrial impact events have a preserved record. Bolide craters, and thus the impactors that generated them, vary widely in size, from small to immense, and only the latter can be expected to have had global biotic effects. Of all the known terrestrial impact events, the only one for which there is unequivocal evidence of a concurrent biocrisis is the ECME. One other possible candidate is the ∼34-Ma end-Eocene biocrisis, which resulted in modest extinctions among forams, mollusks and mammals. The proximate cause of that event was unambiguously climate change (i.e. initial growth of the Antarctic icesheet and Southern Hemisphere cooling), but whether the trigger was a bolide impact or merely a non-linear, threshold climate response to a long-term, tectonically driven decline of atmospheric CO2 (cf) remains unclear. With regard to the former possibility, the 35.7-Ma Popigai crater is probably too old to have played a role, but the 34.86-Ma Chesapeake Bay impact, which produced the widespread North American tektite strewn field (i.e. an impact ejecta layer), may fit the bill. It is also possible that a combination of long-term CO2 fall and short-term impact-related cooling were responsible for triggering the end-Eocene biocrisis (see below).

Although an impact crater remains the sine qua non for a bolide strike, various types of sedimentological and geochemical features have proven highly useful in recognizing ancient meteorite strikes, a number of such events being known exclusively from diagnostic signatures in stratigraphic successions. Key sedimentological and geochemical features of bolide impacts include iridium anomalies, microspherule layers, quartz shock lamellae and fused breccia. Of these proxies, iridium anomalies have proven somewhat problematic owing to microbial processes that concentrate that metal and that may account for the majority of iridium anomalies in the rock record [e.g.]. Given the direct line that can be drawn between bolide impacts and these types of uniquely diagnostic mineralogic and geochemical features, it is unsurprising that the impact mechanism was the first to be thoroughly documented and widely accepted in the Earth sciences community.

Evidence for LIP eruptions

LIP eruptions have been numerous through Earth history, with >300 cataloged to date (http://www.largeigneousprovinces.org/record). As with impact craters, the known LIPs vary widely in size, from small to supermassive eruptions, among which only the largest can be expected to have had global biotic effects. Among the Big Five mass extinctions, both the EPME and ETME were unambiguously associated with large LIPS, i.e. the Siberian Traps and the Central Atlantic Magmatic Province, respectively. However, more than a few second-order mass extinctions are suspected to have been caused by LIP eruptions, including the end-Guadalupian event (linked to the ∼259-Ma Emeishan LIP), the Early Toarcian event (linked to the ∼183-Ma Karoo-Ferrar LIP) and the end-Cenomanian event (linked to the ∼94-Ma Caribbean LIP). The end-Smithian biocrisis of the mid-Early Triassic, which was preceded by climatic hyperwarming, may also have had an LIP trigger (i.e. late-stage Siberian Traps eruptions), although it is unclear whether the Late Smithian warming or the subsequent strong cooling across the Smithian–Spathian boundary was primarily responsible for this biocrisis. In any case, the relationship between LIP eruptions and biocrises is firmly established, and an LIP origin must be considered a possibility for all mass extinctions.

In the case of LIP eruptions, Hg concentration anomalies and isotopes have recently been developed as an indicator of volcanogenic inputs to sedimentary successions, potentially providing a direct fingerprint. As recently recognized, however, Hg anomalies can be produced by non-volcanogenic mechanisms, and caution must therefore be exercised in the interpretation of this proxy. It should be noted that the case for LIPs as a mechanism of mass extinction was not based on the Hg proxy and, even today, does not depend primarily upon it. Rather, the case for LIPs was based largely on identification and dating of massive flood basalt deposits, demonstrating their coevality with certain biocrises.

Despite much research, an LIP mechanism for three of the Big Five mass extinctions (i.e. the ECME, LOME and LDME) remains speculative and contentious. Although the ECME event is known to have been approximately coeval with the Deccan Traps LIP, recent high-resolution dating has demonstrated that flood basalt eruptions in India commenced ∼250 kyr prior to the end-Cretaceous biocrisis, rendering cause-and-effect relationships uncertain. Imputation of an LIP trigger for the LOME and LDME is even more problematic. Despite much effort to identify contemporaneous LIPs, the evidence presented to date is underwhelming. Several LIPs of Late Devonian age have been reported, e.g. the Yakutsk–Viluyi, Kola–Dnieper and Pripyat–Dnieper–Donets LIPs, but the size of each is modest and all of them lack precise dating, casting doubt on their coevality with the end-Frasnian and end-Devonian biocrises. Furthermore, Hg anomalies in LOME and end-Frasnian sections offered as evidence of volcanic causation have been interpreted uncritically and are likely not products of LIP-related Hg fluxes at all. Most importantly, the LOME and LDME events show patterns of climato-environmental change that are incompatible with an LIP or bolide mechanism (see above).

Evidence for bioevolutionary triggers

Bioevolutionary triggers are likely to have played a much larger role in causing biocrises through time than generally realized. Nearly every major milestone in the history of the evolution of life, including both metabolic (e.g. oxygenic photosynthesis; multicellular heterotrophy) and biostructural innovations (e.g. adaptation of plants to life on land), is likely to have led to a mass extinction as a result of attendant changes in environmental conditions and/or ecosystem organization. With regard to their carbon-cycle effects, bioevolutionary triggers may lead to net carbon burial, net carbon release or a carbon-neutral outcome, depending on the nature of the specific event (Fig. 3). Some bioevolutionary events resulted in a massive increase in carbon storage in the Earth's crust, e.g. the proliferation of oxygenic cyanobacteria during the Paleoproterozoic Great Oxidation Event (GOE), as recorded by the Lomagundi-Jatuli PCIE, whereas others have led to massive carbon release (e.g. the LQME) or no significant net change in carbon fluxes (e.g. the end-Ediacaran Event). The general underappreciation of the role of bioevolutionary triggers is due in no small part to the record of biocrises among microbial biotas in deep-time (i.e. pre-Phanerozoic) systems being poorly preserved and difficult to study.

The evidence for bioevolutionary triggers is typically even less direct than that for LIPs. Clues must be sought in extinction patterns (see below) and the identification of a plausible bioevolutionary trigger. A prime example of this approach is the Late Quaternary extinction of American megafauna, an event that exhibits biotic, geographic and temporal patterns that can be reasonably explained only as the result of the arrival of Paleolithic hunters in central North America around 15–13 ka. Hypotheses for this biocrisis that invoke rapid climate change (or more exotic mechanisms like gamma bursts) fail to account for observations of spatial (limited to the Americas) and ecological selectivity (limited to megafauna), the lack of similar extinctions during multiple earlier Quaternary deglaciations, and the temporal relationship of this event to human migration into the Americas. With regard to other biocrises, a major environmental or ecosystem change can be a tip-off that a bioevolutionary trigger was responsible. For example, the sharp rise in atmospheric oxygen levels during the Paleoproterozoic GOE is highly likely to have precipitated a mass extinction among the obligate anaerobe microbial community that was dominant at that time. In the case of the disappearance of the Ediacaran Biota around the Ediacaran–Cambrian boundary, the rapid appearance of hard parts among many unrelated marine invertebrate clades, a sudden increase in burrowing activity, and the appearance of bite marks/drillholes are all clues pointing to the advent of the first active predators as an important agent of biotic turnover at that time.

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.