이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.
3장 · From fossils to mind — Emerging directions
New directions are emerging for future research involving paleoneurological collections that incorporate neuroimaging, phylogenetic comparative methods, molecular biology, paleoanthropological discoveries, and sharing data and tools. These offer the potential to integrate information across different scales of organization from in vivo as well as in vitro systems to investigate biological mechanisms. New integrative frameworks allow for synergies and opportunities to answer unresolved questions about human brain evolution (Box 1).
Neuroimaging
Integrating endocast data with neuroimaging has opened an avenue to examine the evolution of the hominin brain in the context of the brain structure and function of present day humans. Neuroimaging techniques, such as MRI, are widely used to reconstruct and segment the human brain in three dimensions (3D). Combining data from neuroimaging and endocasts thus can be beneficial for examining the extent to which fossil endocast-derived features reflect aspects of brain structure. Early examples of such a combination include adapting metrics traditionally used on endocasts to MRI data. For example, craniometric ratios of the LB1 (Homo floresiensis) endocast were compared to the normative distribution of the craniometric ratios of Homo sapiens derived from a large sample of MRI data, providing quantitative evidence of how LB1 deviates from Homo sapiens. In another illustrative example, Fournier et al. used brain MRI data from present day humans to reconstruct both the brain hull and the endocast, where consistent asymmetry patterns were observed. These findings suggest the feasibility of using endocasts to infer the evolution of brain asymmetry patterns.
Other studies further suggest that combining endocasts with neuroimaging makes it possible to investigate more comprehensive and localized morphometric characteristics of the brain, such as gyrification. A recent study used endocasts and MRI data from the same sample of extant human subjects and revealed a close relationship between MRI-derived brain sulci patterns and the endocast-derived sulcal imprints in frontal, temporoparietal, and occipital regions. These findings show a great potential to study the evolutionary process of structural reorganization in these cognitive-critical regions through comparisons of endocasts across species. A major aim of comparative studies is to infer the functional consequences of evolutionary changes in the hominin brain. In an exploratory study toward this goal, Kochiyama et al. reconstructed the Neanderthal ‘brain’ by deforming MRI-derived 3D human brain to the Neanderthal endocasts, to estimate the volume of distinct brain regions in both species. A prominent enlargement of the cerebellum was revealed in humans compared to Neanderthals (confirming earlier estimates using a different method). They suggested that the enlarged cerebellum in Homo sapiens could relate to its function in cognitive abilities such as cognitive flexibility, attention, language processing, and episodic and working memory in present day humans. Cerebellar functions have been emphasized in light of recent findings supporting structural, size, and molecular changes in the cerebellum in humans.
There are some caveats concerning the correspondence between endocasts and brains, such that information inferred from the endocast does not always parallel the organization of the brain. A recent study combining MRI and endocast data from humans and chimpanzees argued that evolutionary changes between the brains of humans and chimpanzees are disassociated with changes of neurocranial organization of the two species. These findings seem to indicate that some aspects of brain organization are better reflected by endocranial anatomy than others. We thus advise verifying the examined characteristics using comparative endocast and neuroimaging data from primates before drawing a conclusion on brain evolution from the evidence of endocasts solely.
Phylogenetic comparative methods
Phylogenies are hypotheses about the evolutionary relationships between species constructed from data such as genomes and fossil morphology (Fig 1). Species are more similar when they are closely related, a concept known as phylogenetic non-independence. Phylogenetic comparative methods comprise a statistical toolset that explicitly tackles this problem and, more generally, have the potential to improve inferences when different species are compared. Although widely applied in evolutionary biology, phylogenetic comparative approaches have been used to a more limited extent in the study of fossil hominins. Previous use of such approaches to understand brain evolution in fossil hominins concerns mainly brain size and encephalization, but some aspects of variation in brain shape have been explored under this framework as well. These approaches have the potential to help us infer ancestral states in the evolution of the hominin brain, as well as to reveal differences in evolutionary rates for different branches of the hominin phylogeny, which has been done for some cranial and dental traits, and for some behavioral traits. Fossil species can be included in ancestral state estimations even if their evolutionary relationships are not fully resolved, and make it possible to test models of evolution. The inclusion of fossil data improves ancestral state estimations, as it calibrates values at nodes. Hominin paleoneurology can also gain insight from studies of brain and body size scaling which use phylogenetic comparative methods to measure the convergence and divergence of traits across species, reconstruct ancestral states, and impute missing values. These approaches, however, are undeniably hampered by the uncertainty associated with the hominin phylogeny. Previous Bayesian analyses of the hominin phylogeny can be used to carry out these analyses, but they are not free of controversy. This phylogenetic framework, however, is likely to be improved and refined as more fossils are found and described in the future. In addition, the uncertainty associated with particular phylogenetic scenarios can be measured and included in calculations.
Phylogenetic comparative approaches can be combined with other kinds of evidence to provide a more nuanced understanding of how traits are related. For example, quantitative methods of shape analysis (geometric morphometrics or other quantitative approaches) can provide a more nuanced description of endocranial shape variation over the hominin phylogeny, in a similar way as it has been done to describe the evolution of endocranial shape in platyrrhine primates. This approach, however, is still limited to the types of information that can be obtained from the endocranial evidence. Critical aspects of the microstructural, macrostructural and biochemical organization of the brain that are not preserved in endocasts cannot be reconstructed in fossil hominins through this strategy. Nonetheless, broader mammalian comparative contexts, may still be useful to infer certain aspects of neurodevelopment in fossil hominins, as well as the level of covariation between brain size and body size, and other size- and shape-related variables.
For example, hypothetical fossil brain structural connectivity could potentially be modeled from endocasts, even in the absence of any direct evidence. White matter tracts were reconstructed in the 100-year-old brain of the extinct Tasmanian tiger (Thylacinus cynocephalus) based on comparison with one other species, the Tasmanian devil (Sarcophilus harrisii). Structural brain connectomes have now been investigated in 125 mammalian species in comparison to phylogenetic distances. Phylogenetic comparative methods could be used to improve predictions about brain structure in extinct hominins.
Molecular and cellular biology
Inferences that have a direct genetic basis or that leave a record in individuals’ proteomes, may be testable in the future as more aDNA and paleoproteomic data become available. Indeed, aDNA analyses have revealed that Homo sapiens, Neanderthals and Denisovans shared coding changes in the FOXP2 gene that can be related with certain forms of brain plasticity in these species. Even when aDNA is not available, it is possible to ‘rebuild’ fossil genomes from the genomes of extant species using phylogenetic comparative methods, as has recently been done for the hypothetical mammalian common ancestor. Such analyses present testable hypotheses about ancestors against which to compare future aDNA and paleoproteomic data derived from the fossil record.
New methodological advances based on the use of mouse models and brain organoids are now allowing researchers to test the functional significance of modern human-specific gene variants, including aspects of neurodevelopment. Organoids, which are clusters of proliferating cells, open new possibilities for comparative work across extant and extinct species, for which the primary brain tissue cannot be accessed. Organoids are generated from pluripotent stem cells (embryonic stem cells or induced pluripotent stem cells) and spun at high speed. These clusters of stem cells self-assemble into a collection of progenitor cells giving rise to various cell types. Pluripotent stem cells can be induced from mature cells (e.g., skin cells) making organoids amenable for study in virtually any species. Crucially, the spatial patterns of gene expression in brain organoids are reminiscent of the brain’s spatial layout, thus facilitating species comparisons. Cells from organoids also form connections. Based on these observations, it has been argued that organoids bear sufficient resemblance to nervous systems that they can be used to capture cross-species differences in developmental pathways.
Organoids have been instrumental in studying extinct species and extant species. Neanderthal alleles have been inserted into human pluripotent stem cell genomes to reveal how they impact brain development, opening up new ways to study genetic variation across extinct populations. Organoids also permit studying developmental processes in extant nonhuman primates, including the most endangered species (e.g., orangutans, gorillas). Many, but not all, of recent studies have found that brain organoid maturation is slower in humans relative to extant great apes and monkeys. The slower speed of human organoid maturation in vitro mirrors the extended duration of human brain growth relative to chimpanzees and other great apes observed in vivo. Yet, an unresolved question is how observations made from brain organoids translate to ground truth in primary tissue of the full organism. For example, it is unclear whether the media used to amplify pluripotent stem cells into organoids can impact observed species differences in gene expression, and rate of neuronal differentiation. We can now probe the maturation of the human brain at the single-cell level with single-cell RNA sequencing. Accordingly, we know that brain organoids resemble but do not fully recapitulate the cell populations that are evident in human brain development. It is crucial to elucidate how well in vitro biological programs reflect in vivo biological programs. Once those relationships are clarified, the integration of information from individuals, organoids, and scales of biological organization will provide exciting avenues to a better characterization of the mechanisms giving rise to characteristic features of the human brain.
A recent study used organoids to compare the role of the gene Transketolase-like 1 (TKTL1) in corticogenesis of Neanderthals and Homo sapiens. The findings point to differences in corticogenesis between Neanderthals and Homo sapiens, suggested to affect the frontal lobe, since there is high expression of the enzyme TKTL1 in the progenitors of the modern human frontal lobe. TKTL1 in Homo sapiens has a single amino-acid substitution (arginine) while the archaic form in Neanderthals, Denisovans, and other primates harbors a lysine. TKTL1 in Homo sapiens specifically promotes the generation of basal radial glia progenitors that are key to primate cortical expansion via their increased capacity to generate neurons. Since Neanderthals and Homo sapiens share similarly sized brains at adulthood, future research about development by molecular biologists, neuroscientists, and paleontologists could elucidate specific mechanisms that differ in their brain development.
New methods allow for inferences to be made about present-day human genetic variants derived from admixture with archaic humans. Such variants can be interpreted in the context of modern human brain and endocranial phenotypes. A globularity metric was established to describe the difference in endocranial globularity that has been observed based on the comparison of endocasts of Homo sapiens and Neanderthals. The globularity metric was further examined using a large sample of MRI data from extant human subjects, suggesting a potential genotype-phenotype association of Neanderthal DNA alleles in the human genome to play a key role in variations in brain globularity. This approach to understand gene function could be extended to incorporate phenotypic data about brains, bodies, and behaviors, and potentially even take into account what we know about Neanderthal behavior from the archeological record.
이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.
