본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Factoring Origin of Life Hypotheses into the Search for Life in the Solar System and Beyond

Longo, Damer · 2020

공개 학술지 Life 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2020년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Longo & Damer (2020), Life · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 6개 올림 이 장 2163낱말 TOEFL® 읽기 문제 5문항
← 앞 장 다음 장 →

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

3장 · Factoring Origin of Life Hypotheses into the Search for Life in the Solar System and Beyond — The Hot Spring Origins of Life Hypothesis

색을 입힌 곳이 TOEFL® 읽기 문제에 실린 대목입니다. 그 앞뒤의 글을 이어 읽어 보세요. 대목으로 가기

Although much of the past three decades of research on life’s origins has been focused on submarine hydrothermal vents, terrestrial hot springs have recently emerged as a plausible alternative. Mulkidjanian speculated that cellular life may have begun in anoxic freshwater hot springs rather than in seawater, and that key chemical pathways to ribonucleotides could be facilitated by ultraviolet (UV) radiation exposure in a subaerial landscape. In recent years, Damer and Deamer have synthesized many previous findings with a model of combinatorial selection, which proposes an “end-to-end” pathway from simple, self-assembled protocells through an intermediate stage called the “progenote” to the emergence of the first primitive microbial communities. The crux of the hot spring origins of life hypothesis is that cycles of hydration and dehydration in hydrothermal fields could synthesize biologically relevant polymers from monomers delivered to subaerial landscapes on the early Earth, and encapsulate those polymers into membrane-bounded compartments to form protocells. These protocells could act as natural experiments, and could be subjected to a form of combinatorial selection that amplifies populations of functional polymers encapsulated within increasingly robust protocells. According to the hot spring hypothesis, this selection represented the initial step toward Darwinian evolution that ultimately gave rise to much more complex, living cells (Figure 2).

Two plausible sources could have provided organic material to feed an origin of life in hot springs. Chondritic asteroids and meteorites produced by accretion, impacts, and photochemical processing within the asteroid belt contain high concentrations of complex organics. The amino acid glycine was detected in Stardust mission samples from the comet Wild-2, and sugars such as ribose are present in carbon-rich meteorites. The influx of meteorites and interplanetary dust particles carrying organic compounds would have been thousands of times greater in the Hadean than it is today, and the organics delivered by these bodies could have survived on the surface of the early Earth for long periods of time due to a lack of atmospheric oxygen. These meteoritic organics falling onto land would be blown or washed into pools, which can concentrate them sufficiently to support chemical reactions. In addition, compounds containing amino acids produce pyrroles when they come in contact with water; these compounds could then be transported to hot spring pools and become oligomerized.

Hot springs and geochemical reactions in the underlying magma are also a potential source of organic compounds. For instance, Archean hot springs concentrated the primary CHNOPS biogenic elements in abundance. These have the potential to combine into simple organic molecules analogous to those produced in laboratory settings. Furthermore, hydrocarbon derivatives, such as long chain monocarboxylic acids and alcohols, can be abiotically produced in hot spring settings by Fischer–Tropsch synthesis. One caveat to these conclusions is that several promising hot spring experiments used water sourced from the Yellowstone National Park hydrothermal system, which is dominated by rhyolitic magmas. This chemistry was most likely absent during the Hadean and Archaean periods; it remains to be shown that andesitic and basaltic hot springs can synthesize the same organic compounds.

The exterior surfaces of sinter outcrops are ideal sheltered faces where organic molecules can accumulate and undergo diverse reactions as they become concentrated by evaporation. Mineral surfaces at the edge of hot spring pools, such as silica nodule faces, can support wet-dry cycling and, therefore, become kinetic traps where the rate of condensation of organic molecules exceeds the rate of hydrolysis. Milshteyn et al. recently demonstrated that lipid vesicles readily assemble in water samples from the hot springs of Yellowstone National Park. Outcrop faces can also serve as surfaces where amphiphilic lipids can self-assemble into multilamellar membranous structures during wet-dry cycles.

Regular cycling between wet and dry conditions has been proposed as a crucial driving factor in the origin of life, and it occurs ubiquitously in hot springs. Highly periodic fluctuating water levels are produced by the varying activity of hydrothermal springs, which ensures that mineral surfaces undergo numerous wet-dry cycles. Evaporation concentrates any organic compounds dissolved in the hydrothermal fluids into a thin film which coats mineral surfaces. The chemical energy made available by concentrating and organizing potential reactants promotes condensation reactions. For instance, if nucleotides are present, ester bonds link hydroxyl and phosphate groups into nucleic acid polymers. These can be encapsulated in lipid vesicles budding off from the outer layers to form protocells during the rehydration of the pool. During the interim phase of dehydration, protocells and other pool contents, including solutes, are concentrated in a moist “gel” phase. As the water level recedes, the aggregated protocells fuse together, forming multilamellar structures and depositing, or “coupling,” their cargoes of polymers back into the dry phase, where they can be re-synthesized, elongated, or possibly copied by templating processes.

Just as wet-dry cycles are able to produce populations of protocells through budding from dried films, they also are capable of disrupting them. Most of the vesicles produced in each cycle would be stressed and decomposed by wet-dry cycles, but a few might happen to contain polymers that stabilize their membranes, much as the cytoskeleton does in cells today. The stabilizing effect was probably the first function of polymers encapsulated in vesicles. Dehydration might also incorporate additional amphiphilic compounds and polymers into surviving vesicles, which could create increasingly complex and robust protocells. Like the submarine vent hypothesis, the hot spring origins of life hypothesis could support the proposal that RNA was the first hereditary molecule in early microbes. The synthesis of RNA nucleobases has not yet been demonstrated in hot spring conditions; however, Becker et al. has proposed a chemical pathway that might produce adenine, thymine, guanine, and uracil during wet-dry cycling. Photochemical reactions driven by high levels of ultraviolet radiation might have incorporated these nucleobases into nucleotides; radiation might then have linked nucleotides into longer chains of RNA. Given hereditary material, sets of interacting polymers could then be selected for the expression of primitive proteins and move beyond providing simple stability. Populations of protocells that survive initial wet-dry cycling may accumulate on mineral surfaces during the dehydration of hot spring pools, forming moist aggregates. Within these aggregates, increasingly concentrated solutes within the evaporating pool volume could enter the protocells and participate in metabolic reactions. These reactions have been theorized to enable the sharing of products across the aggregate, creating an interacting network effect. This process would gradually make the aggregate more robust; it would become capable of growth and evolution as it forms and re-forms during wet-dry cycles. Damer proposed that this aggregate would constitute a progenote, an ancestor of prokaryotic cells actively developing the relationship between genotype and phenotype. According to the hot spring hypothesis, the progenote is the key unit of selection and operation which enables the transition from simple protocells to living microbial communities.

A typical Hadean hot spring hosting a population of protocells would have been located on an elevated volcanic island, so a hydrothermal discharge channel could have carried self-assembled protocells and progenote aggregates downhill into increasingly saline bodies of water such as rivers, lakes, and eventually oceans. The downhill transport of protocells would subject these populations to an adaptation gradient, selecting for cells with stable membranes and the ability to transport nutrient solutes across membrane boundaries. In addition, protocell populations might develop a primitive form of photosynthesis to replace the chemical energy available in the hot spring environment but lacking in more dilute aqueous settings. These adaptations, and the continuous cross-distribution of innovations across landscapes, could create an evolutionary “network effect” which could drive the transition from protocellular pre-life to early microbes. Increasingly robust microbial communities would be able to colonize the sea shores and the bulk of the open ocean, and ultimately would obtain a global distribution.

Like submarine hydrothermal vents, hot springs on Earth host diverse microbial communities, including thermophilic archaea, photosynthetic bacteria, and diatoms. While hydrothermal fields have a global distribution, three of the most-studied systems are Rotorua in New Zealand, Dallol in Ethiopia, and El Tatio in Chile. Rotorua is one of several geothermal fields located in New Zealand’s Taupo volcanic zone, which gives rise to wide thermal, compositional, and pH variability in hot spring pools. Deamer et al. demonstrated the polymerization and encapsulation of RNA monomers during wet-dry cycling at the Hells Gate hydrothermal area in Rotorua. El Tatio and Dallol represent boundary cases for habitability; they are the world’s highest-elevation and most acidic hot springs, respectively. All three of these hot springs host thriving microbial ecosystems. The oldest known evidence for microbial communities occupying a hot spring environment is located in the Dresser Formation in the Pilbara, Australia. The opaline silica outcrops of the Dresser Formation are 3.48 billion years old, and they were originally deposited in a volcanic caldera fed by hydrothermal fluids. This ancient environment possessed the key characteristics of modern hot springs, including fluctuating water levels, compositional variability in pools, and a complete inventory of bioessential elements. Djokic et al. detected fossilized spherical gas bubbles within Dresser Formation sinter outcrops, and interpreted them to have been trapped by biofilms produced by archaea. This hypothesis was subsequently confirmed by deep drilling experiments, which discovered preserved biogenic organics within the protected lower layers of the formation. As of this writing, these biosignatures are among the oldest evidence of life on land. Although the Dresser Formation is the only known Archaean hot spring, hot springs are relatively common features associated with volcanic regions. Therefore, it is conceivable that ancient analogs could have been present on the rare volcanic land masses and islands which may have emerged from the global ocean on the early Earth.

Although the hot spring origins of life hypothesis can account for processes such as condensation reactions and membrane self-assembly which can be challenging in submarine vents, it has several key limitations of its own. The most serious may be what is known as “the phosphate problem”. While phosphorylation is an essential biochemical process, phosphorus has a low solubility in water. One potential solution to this quandary could be redox reactions powered by dissolved hydrogen and iron, but the reduction of phosphorus requires concentrations of these elements which are unrealistic for hot springs. Whereas life in a marine vent would most likely generate energy using a primitive form of the Wood–Ljungdahl pathway, reactions that lead to metabolism in a hot spring have not yet been demonstrated. Clay minerals are common in and near hydrothermal fields, and they may adsorb organic reactants; however, these reactants may be released in basic fluids. Most hot springs also lack the abundant trace metals found in submarine vents. The Hadean Earth may have been covered by a global ocean; in this case, hot springs would have been restricted to rare volcanic islands, significantly limiting the number of locations available for an origin of life on land. Finally, the prospects for surface habitability during the Hadean are uncertain at best due to frequent impacts and high levels of solar radiation. An origin of life on land may only have occurred after the cessation of frequent impacts 3.9 billion years ago. As with the submarine vent origins of life hypothesis, future research on the hot spring hypothesis is needed to resolve these obstacles.

Other Origins of Life Hypotheses

Hydrothermal environments such as marine vents and hot springs are currently favored for an origin of life due to their ability to supply microbes with thermal energy and concentrate prebiotic reactants. However, this review would be incomplete without mentioning other prominent origins of life hypotheses. Darwin formulated the first origins of life hypothesis, which stated that life began in a “warm little pond” on land. An updated version of this theory predicts an origin of life in carbonate-rich lakes or in tidal pools on Hadean beaches, which would concentrate water and organic molecules produced by photochemistry. However, the energy available in these locations may have been insufficient to power the prebiotic reactions necessary for the formation of complex polymers. Ebisuzaki and Maruyama proposed that life began in a natural nuclear fission reactor (a geyser powered by an underground source of uranium-235), where ionizing radiation can promote chemical reactions and where wet-dry cycling can also take place. One issue with this scenario is that the geologic record contains evidence of only one natural reactor, which is in Oklo, Gabon. Although additional nuclear geysers may have been active in the Hadean, no evidence for these environments exists. Dobson et al. suggested that atmospheric aerosols may have been precursors to life, as they concentrate organic material. Finally, some researchers have embraced the theory of Panspermia, which states that microbial life originated on either Mars or an exoplanet and travelled to Earth inside a piece of impact ejecta. This hypothesis is dependent upon life’s ability to survive an impact event and an interplanetary transit lasting tens of thousands of years. Although several of these hypotheses present intriguing conclusions and merit further research, they do not have the same extensive experimental support shared by the submarine vent and hot spring models. Therefore, they will not be considered in further detail in this paper.

TOEFL® 읽기 문제 5문항. 이 장의 한 대목을 그대로 옮기고 문항을 붙였습니다. 대목을 읽고 문제를 풉니다.

문제 풀기 이 장에서 대목 보기

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.