Hyperthermal-driven mass extinctions: killing models during the Permian–Triassic mass extinction
Benton · 2018
공개 학술지 Philosophical transactions. Series A, Mathematical, physical, and engineering sciences 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2018년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.
출처 Benton (2018), Philosophical transactions. Series A, Mathematical, physical, and… · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문
이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.
2장 · Hyperthermal-driven mass extinctions: killing models during the Permian–Triassic mass extinction — Hyperthermals as killers in the sea
Killers in the sea
Numerous hyperthermal episodes in the history of the Earth have been associated with extinction, most notably the Palaeocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM; although extinction levels were minor, limited to pelagic benthic foraminifera), several ocean anoxic events through the Mesozoic, and the PTME. The scaling and selectivity of such events have been explored, but it is difficult in all cases to identify the exact loss of biodiversity. Palaeontologists can estimate rates of species loss at either local or regional scale, where they document every fossil specimen through a measured rock section, and attempt to track the fate of each species. Such studies are not easy, as absence of a fossil lineage could mean extinction or could simply mean a failure in preservation or collection. On all scales, but especially the global scale, preservation and collection failures may bias the measurements of extinction magnitudes. Multiple sections worldwide through the same event can provide some corroboration of general trends. These studies show that for a truly major event such as the PTME, the rate of species extinction can be greater than 90%, and for smaller events such as the PETM, the rate of loss regionally can be much smaller, with turnovers of 1–20% of species.
Selectivity of taxa during extinction events can indicate causality. If, for example, most of the victims share certain physiological properties, then that might identify the killing stresses. The most convincing such efforts have been done around the PTME, for which meta-analytical studies of marine animals suggested that physiologically poorly buffered species suffered statistically significantly more through the event than well-buffered species. Poorly buffered species include corals, sponges, brachiopods, bryozoans and crinoids, whereas well-buffered groups include bivalves, gastropods, cephalopods, ostracods and trilobites. The classification of survivors and victims is not perfect, however, as gastropods and ostracods, while ‘poorly buffered’ actually were great survivors during the PTME, and the ‘well-buffered’ ammonoids suffered severe extinctions.
The argument was that well-buffered animals are adapted to withstand the stresses of increased pCO2 and temperature and reduced pO2 and carbonate saturation, all associated with marine anoxia and ocean acidification. Marine animals with weakly buffered respiratory physiology are less able to control their intracellular pH and so maintain respiratory efficiency under elevated CO2 levels than well-buffered organisms, which means they are more susceptible to extinction from hypercapnia or ocean acidification. Skeleton chemistry was important also: species with phosphatic or siliceous skeletons (linguliform brachiopods, conulariids, and hexactinellid and non-hypercalcified demosponges) were significantly more likely to survive the PTME than those with calcareous skeletons, whether aragonite or calcite, even when accounting for differences in physiology, geographical range and other traits. An alternative model includes the role of acidification, but also the idea that the habitable zone in the oceans was substantially reduced by warming from above and anoxia from below, and that there was no single key driver such as hypercapnia.
Hypoxia as a killer in the sea
In a physiological context, hypoxia is ‘deficiency in the amount of oxygen reaching the tissues’, and this is a well-known stressor of modern organisms. Oxygen levels in the atmosphere and surface ocean waters have varied substantially through the Phanerozoic, ranging from 13% to 31%, compared to a modern value of 21%. Atmospheric oxygen levels fell from a high point of 28% in the Late Permian to 20% at the PTB, and 16% in the Early Triassic.
In experimental situations, many marine organisms exhibit tolerance to hypoxia when compared with terrestrial organisms. Oxygen content of seawaters varies enormously in modern oceans, with oxygen minimum zones (OMZs) in warmer surface waters, sometimes linked with eutrophication, and at depth in upwelling zones, sometimes with less than 10% of surface oxygen content in permanent oxygen-deficient layers. When oxygen conditions are insufficient to support life, animals move up and down in the water column to layers with sufficient oxygen, or laterally and even latitudinally to water bodies at the correct depth but with sufficient oxygen.
At times of climate change, hypoxia-intolerant species move away from waters that develop low oxygen levels, and their overall distributions can be compressed, so leading to competition for food or shelter, or a net loss in species diversity and ecosystem function. In modern examples, hypoxia-tolerant species can survive at the expense of those that require higher oxygen levels. Larval life-history stages tend to be intolerant to hypoxia, and hypoxia can also select for smaller adult individuals and lower overall biomass. At ecosystem scale, there may be a marked shift in energetics with continued oxygen loss as the overall metabolism of the system reduces; alternative electron receptors replace oxygen in the system and these yield less energy at the base of the food web. In studies of modern fisheries, sustained reduction in oxygen over many decades reduces the overall biomass of fishes retrieved from the seabed as a result of switching carbon transfer to secondary production. On geological time scales, it is likely that the same phenomenon would readily occur.
Marine biologists and fisheries experts define several hypoxia thresholds that mark important shifts in ecosystem function. Compared to normal levels of oceanic oxygenation (greater than 1.4 ml l⁻¹), hypoxia is defined as anything less than this (less than 1.4 ml l⁻¹), and severe hypoxia at much lower levels (less than 0.5 ml l⁻¹). These concepts, and the whole-ecosystem approach in fisheries research, are useful for ecologists and palaeontologists because all species show different responses to hypoxia, and some even show different responses at different developmental stages, and further, these responses depend on other conditions, such as salinity, productivity and especially water temperature. Therefore, it would be hard to predict a general response of any species or clade to hypoxia at different intensities. In addition, most physiological experiments have been under controlled laboratory conditions, where responses might not reflect the complexities of Nature.
In the end, it seems unlikely that hypoxia could have driven the PTME because the rate of change in oxygen levels, reflecting the huge volume of oxygen in the atmosphere, is inevitably slow, lasting millions or tens of millions of years, and so allowing organisms plenty of time to adapt. Further, the fluctuations during the Late Permian and Early Triassic were not outside the scope of modern oxygen levels at different altitudes, to which life has adapted. Therefore, although hypoxia has been cited as a key killer during the PTME crisis, further evidence for rapid fluctuations would be required to make a case.
Hypercapnia and ocean acidification as killers in the sea
Hypercapnia is the physiological condition of retaining too much carbon dioxide in the blood, and it can be induced by medical problems or by an inappropriate external environment. It has been argued that the main killer in the PTME oceans was hypercapnia associated with acidification, hypoxia and toxic sulfide levels, but this has been queried. Excess CO2 in seawater can have severe physiological effects on organisms, suppressing their metabolism, disrupting acid–base homeostasis and impairing calcification through reduced mineral saturation. However, predicted outcomes of these effects are not as clear as might have been expected through the PTME.
It has been suggested that much of the relative survivorship of major marine animal groups through the PTME can be explained by the impact of hypercapnia on their ability or need to construct a carbonate skeleton. Worst affected (86% generic extinction rate) were the poorly buffered forms with a high need for carbonate ions, such as rugose corals, rhynchonelliform brachiopods and crinoids. Next worst affected (54% generic extinction rate) were the well-buffered forms that needed lower amounts of carbonate for their shells, such as gastropods, bivalves, nautiloids, ammonoids, ostracods and echinoids. Finally, the physiologically well-buffered forms that required little or no carbonate (5% generic extinction rate) were the ctenostome bryozoans, lingulid brachiopods, holothurians, conodonts and chondrichthyan fishes.
In a test based on fish evolution through the Permian and Triassic, fewer chondrichthyan fishes suffered extinction than marine invertebrates, which was interpreted as evidence that sharks and their allies are active aerobic organisms with high aerobic scope for thermal tolerance and well-developed acid–base regulation, traits that gave them resilience to oceanic hypercapnia at the PTME. By contrast, bony fishes (osteichthyans) seemingly underwent extinctions comparable to those of marine invertebrates, perhaps reflecting their differing physiologies. The validity of such studies on fish evolution through the PTME is uncertain, however, as the record is poor around the PTB, and others see little evidence of extinction among fish groups.
The role of hypercapnia as a PTME killer has been seriously questioned. The argument is that hypercapnia resistance should be seen best in burrowing taxa, which would regularly encounter high levels of CO2 in the sediment, but it is not. Comparisons of extinction likelihoods had shown that infaunal bivalves were especially likely to go extinct, whereas they should be best adapted to survive hypercapnia. These authors note also that the survival of poorly buffered gastropods and ostracods, and extinction of well-buffered ammonoids, as well as the sponges and radiolarians with silicified skeletons, also speaks against the importance of hypercapnia as a killer.
Global warming as a killer in the sea
The third component of environmental change that would have acted as a killer during the PTME is increased global temperature. As noted, oxygen isotopes show rises of 8–10°C at the PTB, and during repeated warming episodes through the Early Triassic. Today, organisms all have preferred temperature ranges. Further, many features of biology and ecology relate to temperature, such as body size and total diversity and productivity of ecosystems. As with hypoxia and hypercapnia, organisms move away from unfavourable conditions. In recent times, it is well documented how species of animals and plants migrate to maintain themselves in favourable conditions even with temperature changes of as little as ±1°C. The nature and timing of temperature change can be as important as the magnitude of the change. For example, some corals can increase their thermal tolerance by 1–1.5°C, and this adaptation might reduce their vulnerability to bleaching events by some 30–50 years.
The rate of warming is also crucial. Experiments with various species show that a reduction in the rate of temperature rise can reduce the upper temperature tolerance limit. This might seem counterintuitive, that the rate of warming is proportional to temperature tolerance: higher temperature tolerances are achieved in experiments when the rate of warming is fast. This is because there are two factors in play, the critical maximum temperature at which cellular and biochemical processes fail, and the maximum temperature to which a species can become acclimatized. During a rapid pulse of heating, an organism might survive for a short time, whereas longer-term warming involves acclimatization and adaptation of physiological processes. During fast warming, species can survive at higher temperatures before anaerobic end-product accumulation overcomes resistance capacity, a process termed hardening. At slow rates of warming, over months or years, and where the upper limits are well below the critical oxygen limits, acclimatization and adaptation effects become important. Long-term thermal limits are significantly lower than medium-term survival values. This suggests that many organisms might survive a very short, but acute, episode of global warming, lasting for days or weeks at most, but would succumb if the elevated temperature was maintained for months or years, as in ancient examples such as the PTME.
Interactions of multiple stressors
It is well known in physiological studies that stressors can interact in complex ways. For example, in experimental studies on marine organisms, elevated CO2 can reduce the upper thermal limits for a species, and exacerbate the effects of low pH on lowering metabolic rate. Likewise, ocean acidification can affect the ability of organisms to survive elevated temperatures. In other cases, changing temperature or pH can have measurable deleterious effects, which can then be multiplied when they act together. These synergistic effects mean that the lethal temperature for most animals is 35°C, because oxygen demand increases with temperature. This causes hypoxaemia and the onset of anaerobic mitochondrial metabolism that is only sustainable for short periods.
Reactions to different stressors may be similar in terms of cellular protection, and so adaptation to one stressor, such as acute heat stress, can mean the organism responds better to a subsequent osmotic, chemical or acidification stress. Such interactions of stressors can either improve or reduce tolerance for other stressors. In four possible scenarios (figure 2), an initial stress, such as a sharp increase in temperature or reduction in oxygen, can occur so long before a second stress that the organism recovers to normal, and so responds as if unprepared to a second stress (scenario 1). In the other scenarios, the stresses occur close enough together temporally that the organism is primed to resist stress, and the effect of the second stressor is reduced (scenario 2). If the second stressor follows too rapidly, however, the organism may not yet have adapted to the first stressor, and so the two stressors interact as if they are a single external forcing agent (scenario 3) or they even interact synergistically to produce an overall increased response (scenario 4).
Adaptation to stress and the development of cross-tolerance, where one stress enhances the response to a second, later stress, are often mediated by heat shock proteins (HSPs). The time scale of HSP expression is rapid, with significant HSP upregulation occurring within 0.5–6 h, and with peak expression typically within 15 h of the initial exposure. Usually, HSP expression dwindles after that, if the stressor has been removed, and returns to control levels by 24–48 h after the stimulus. These timings suggest the likely nature of responses to multiple stressors in the models (figure 2). If sharp changes in temperature, hypercapnia or hypoxia occur over short time scales (from hours to days), then cross-tolerance may develop; this applies, for example, to cases of daily heat and hypoxia stress in tidal pools. If the changes are on longer time scales, such as monthly or annual changes in seasonal conditions, then cross-tolerance is unlikely, and effects of stressors will be additive. In the case of a hyperthermal event, where heat stress, hypoxia and hypercapnia might all occur together, synergies such as interaction and cross-tolerance would have occurred.
The ‘double whammy’
Song et al., in arguing against the idea that marine survivors were well buffered against hypercapnia and ocean acidification, presented their ‘double whammy’ model in which marine life was not only driven from the tropical seas by extreme warming, but then the liveable zone was massively restricted by lethal warming from above and anoxia/euxinia from below. The ‘double whammy’ consists of these two drivers, which resulted in a habitable zone of nothing at all in shallow tropical waters, and a habitable refuge zone of as little as 10% of the normal depth range elsewhere. Further, benthic organisms would have been killed worldwide by anoxic–euxinic seabed conditions, and plankton and surface nekton by heating from above.
TOEFL® 읽기 문제 5문항. 이 장의 한 대목을 그대로 옮기고 문항을 붙였습니다. 대목을 읽고 문제를 풉니다.
이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.
