본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Drivers of Microbiome Biodiversity: A Review of General Rules, Feces, and Ignorance

Reese, Dunn · 2018

공개 학술지 mBio 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2018년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Reese & Dunn (2018), mBio · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 2개 올림 이 장 1673낱말 TOEFL® 읽기 문제 5문항
← 앞 장

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

2장 · Drivers of Microbiome Biodiversity: A Review of General Rules, Feces, and Ignorance — DOES VARIATION MATTER, THOUGH?

In order to address the issue of when microbial community diversity is important to hosts will require an understanding of diversity-function relationships in host-associated systems. Insofar as descriptions of ecosystem processes represent a human construct, they typically describe processes of value to humans. But it is also imaginable that diversity could be related to functions that are features of the microbial community which are independent of the host or even at odds with the fitness of the host. Both types of function (those of value to the host and those not) will need to be assayed to understand the role of diversity in and on hosts.

While it is clear that hosting microbial communities can be functionally beneficial or even necessary to an animal, the extent to which hosting a diverse microbial community is necessary for this phenomenon is still uncertain. To ensure specific, mutualistic interactions, hosts can just select for low-diversity, high-fidelity microbial partners such as those in the light organs of bobtail squid. Indeed, a host may wish to limit diversity because not all microbes are beneficial, whether because they are pathogens or because they are just cheating strains that avoid providing function to the host. Furthermore, increasing diversity has been shown to actually reduce stability in gut communities. As such, evolution has selected for many pathways for use by hosts to control their microbiota through the immune and digestive systems, which may be equally likely to be employed to select for high-diversity and low-diversity gut microbial communities. It may be that in many cases, hosts would prefer to maintain their microbial communities as humans keep farms—as low-diversity but high-function systems—but the long-term ecologic and evolutionary implications of this remain unclear.

Preliminary assessments of the role of diversity in the gut have focused on studying cases where diversity changes over time. As infants grow, the diversity of their fecal microbiota increases both within the first 6 months and over the first few years. How much of this trend is merely due to the increase in body size is not clear. Seasonal variation in diversity has been documented both in animals whose diets vary and in those which hibernate, with lower diversity during hibernation. In all these cases, changes in diversity are assumed to be associated with changes in function, specifically, with shifts in metabolism, but functional measurements are rarely explicitly included. One alternative possibility is that variable environments experienced over time or space produce changes in the available species pool dispersing into hosts that manifest as variations in the community. In the absence of data on variations in functioning, it is impossible to interpret changes in microbial community diversity over time.

More generally, diversity is expected to decrease in disturbed systems. For example, treatment with antibiotics is often tied to a reduction in gut microbial community diversity. More generally, illness, which can trigger the use of antibiotics, is also assumed to reduce diversity or to even be the result of a loss of diversity. In fact, while the definition of dysbiosis continues to be debated, the inclusion of “loss of diversity” is one constant across all definitions. A recent meta-analysis of case-control studies of human disease calls this definition into question, however —across 28 studies, there was no consistent reduction in diversity for sick patients relative to healthy individuals. In 13 cases, disease was accompanied by a loss in Shannon diversity, but the results were not always consistent across multiple studies of the same disease. A further 14 cases did not show a significant response in Shannon diversity, while one study of HIV found an increase in diversity in patients. Only in diarrheal illnesses (Clostridium difficile infection and enteric diarrheal disease) was there a consistent decrease in diversity, perhaps attributable to the decrease in transit time. In light of this result, it may be necessary to reconsider the definition of dysbiosis as well as more generally reconsider when and why we might expect variation in diversity to be tied to changes in function or vice versa.

Future directions

To the best of our knowledge, experiments to test for diversity-function relationships have not actually been carried out in host-associated systems. The impact of parasites on ecosystem functioning has been considered but only insofar as they impact overall diversity through numeric and behavioral effects on host species and not as constituent members of the community. Nevertheless, such experiments can conceivably be designed, and researchers can learn from and build on more-traditional ecologic work. As has been done for plant and animal communities, the impact of diversity can be tested either by removing community members to reduce diversity or by artificially assembling communities of increasing diversity (reference).

(i) Experiments increasing diversity

The majority of diversity-ecosystem functioning experiments, including foundational studies by Naeem et al. and Tilman et al., were carried out in artificially assembled communities. In such studies, individual plots are assigned a diversity level and then taxa are randomly selected from a regional species pool to colonize those plots (Fig. 4). Function data can be compared between treatment groups or on the basis of the presence of specific taxa.

Faith et al. demonstrated an appropriate methodology using donor culture collections and germfree mice to assemble various microbial communities in the gut. Phenotypes were measured in mice colonized with randomly assembled communities. The work used communities with a consistent diversity level (17 strains), but the approach could be extended to build and test communities of various diversity levels. The automated processes involved allow studies of high-diversity communities that are not typically possible when the studies are carried out manually, overcoming a frequent criticism of synthetic community studies such as this.

For animals which do not have germfree lines, synthetic community functioning can be measured in vitro or in a host different from the donor species. It is common to colonize mice with communities from nonmouse donors, and such communities can mostly persist in the absence of dispersal of conventional community members. The context dependency of taxon-specific host-microbe interactions would be missed in such setups, however.

(ii) Experiments decreasing diversity

Because many studies of disturbances to host-associated systems have been performed on the basis of an interest in loss of diversity, removal of taxa may more accurately reflect the target processes than the building of artificial communities with culture collections drawn from donor communities.

Instead, whole donor communities can be diluted to produce communities with reduced diversity (see, for example, the analysis of lake bacteria in reference). These reduced communities can then be used to colonize animal donors or studied in vitro alongside the whole donor community to assess how functioning is altered and whether the alteration is due to loss of specific taxa or to loss of diversity overall (Fig. 4). While dilution randomly removes individuals, it disproportionally affects rare taxa and therefore is not appropriate for studying their importance.

An alternate approach is that of performing removal experiments in vivo, which can test the influence of diversity in naturally assembled communities. This approach benefits from the fact it does not rely on germfree organisms, thereby ensuring that the host and microbiota experience a more conventional developmental process and that the experiments can be performed on a broader set of host animals.

Methods for targeted removal of microbial taxa represent an area of focused research and are becoming increasingly common. In addition to narrow-spectrum antibiotics, phage cocktails and gene editing technologies can be used to selectively alter community composition and diversity levels.

Broader measurements

In addition to devising new experimental designs, to properly assess biodiversity-ecosystem functioning in host-associated microbial communities, researchers will need to think more broadly about how they define functioning and how they define diversity. Multiple functions will need to be assayed in a range of organisms to validate the generalizability of the relationship, but the initial focus should be on testing the foundational metrics, including productivity, stability, and the invasibility of the community, as well as on measures of host fitness which do not have corollaries in the environmental literature.

Explorations of diversity-function relationships in host-associated systems will likely require measurements beyond microbiome profiling. Microbial biomass or concentration is rarely quantified but has been shown to provide a better interpretation of community changes than relative abundance data alone. A conventional measurement of activity or productivity could also help researchers to better estimate the functional contingent of a diverse microbial community. While some functional measurements (e.g., survival of infection or severity of disease state) will be idiosyncratic, general protocols will be necessary to build a comprehensive theory of diversity-function relationships in host-associated systems that encompasses many hosts and many body sites.

Assessments of multiple taxonomic levels of diversity will also be necessary. Most studies have focused on species-level or OTU-level diversity (typically defined by 97% sequence similarity), but meaningful functional differences can exist at much higher or lower taxonomic levels. Horizontal gene transfer and lysogenic phage infection, for instance, can lead to single-gene differences or copy number variation between otherwise identical strains that may be functionally important for ecosystem functioning in the gut but remain uncaptured by typical amplicon sequencing-based analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

As we have come to study an increasingly broad swath of the tree of life, it has become clear that animals can get by and often have high fitness with low-diversity microbiota. Therefore, the framework for understanding diversity in host-associated microbial communities will not be as simple as “more diversity is better.” In addition to experimental tests in model organisms, further comparative work between organisms with consistent methodology will be necessary to determine the drivers of diversity in hosts. Additional comparisons between body sites could highlight other relevant factors such as the method of transmission or specific environmental conditions. The focus of ecologic studies has recently turned toward assessments of multifunctionality in diversity-function relationships (see, for example, references and), and these relationships will ultimately need to be understood for host-associated microbial communities as well. Selection for maintaining a community that can provide multiple functions while preventing negative consequences of hosting microbial communities is an ongoing process driving evolution of both hosts and their commensal microbes.

TOEFL® 읽기 문제 5문항. 이 장의 한 대목을 그대로 옮기고 문항을 붙였습니다. 대목을 읽고 문제를 풉니다.

문제 풀기 이 장에서 대목 보기

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.