본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Theory and classification of mass extinction causation

Algeo, Shen · 2023

공개 학술지 National Science Review 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2023년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Algeo & Shen (2023), National Science Review · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 5개 올림 이 장 1314낱말
← 앞 장 다음 장 →

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

2장 · Theory and classification of mass extinction causation — TOWARDS A GENERAL THEORY OF MASS EXTINCTION CAUSATION

In many studies of mass extinctions, it is conventional to include a laundry list of possible causes and then assert that, in view of such a diverse set of possible mechanisms, the origin of the biocrisis of interest is not well understood and is, therefore, worthy of further study. More often than not, this approach is self-serving, disingenuous and problematic. It is self-serving in presenting a facile and weak rationale for a study. It is disingenuous in treating all published hypotheses as having equal merit when, for nearly all mass extinctions, existing research has narrowed the range of likely mechanisms and would permit more nuanced judgments concerning the relative merits of the remaining candidates. And it is problematic in that it almost invariably conflates proximate causation with ultimate causation, clouding the discussion of extinction mechanisms rather than providing clarity. This last issue, in particular, has long been a major impediment in developing a general theory of mass extinction causation.

‘Proximate causation’ refers to the immediate cause of death—it is akin to saying that a person died as a result of pulmonary congestion. ‘Ultimate causation’ refers to the initial cause (or ‘trigger’) in a chain of events leading to death—it is akin to saying that a person died as a result of Covid infection. With regard to extinctions, commonly cited proximate causes include a wide range of climato-environmental factors such as temperature change, oceanic anoxia and environmental acidification, either singly or in combination. These factors can trigger hyperthermia, suffocation, ionic imbalances and other adverse physiological effects in individual organisms, and, as individuals succumb, diminish the vitality and viability of populations of a species and of entire ecological communities. However, all such proximate causes are driven by some other, more remote (i.e. ultimate) cause. In this regard, it should be noted that similar collages of proximate climato-environmental changes can potentially develop from different ultimate causes, complicating determination of the latter. Unfortunately, many studies have cited proximate causes as the mechanism for a mass extinction seemingly without any awareness that such attributions provide little insight into the ultimate cause of a biocrisis. Yet the distinction between proximate and ultimate causation, which has been clearly articulated in relatively few studies, is absolutely critical to a systemic and holistic understanding of the phenomenon of mass extinction.

In the following, we will discuss proximate causation from the perspective of carbon-cycle controls, review evidence for the established types of ultimate causes (‘triggers’) of mass extinctions, examine mass extinction events with probable bioevolutionary triggers and tectono-oceanic triggers, and finally, consider other issues relevant to an understanding of mass extinction causation.

Proximate causation

Proximate climato-environmental causes of biotic mortality are varied, with changes in temperature and ocean-redox conditions being among the most commonly cited in mass extinction studies. The importance of temperature is manifest in that all biotic species are adapted to a specific optimal temperature range, with shifts toward higher or lower temperatures having various, mostly harmful physiological effects. Large temperature changes can trigger wholesale biotic migrations, with the migrations themselves contributing to mortality and extinction through disruption of ecological relationships. Redox conditions are critical in all aqueous systems in that any environment characterized by intermittent or long-term de-oxygenation will experience the loss of most or all animal life. Apart from temperature and redox changes, biotic stresses can result from various other proximate climato-environmental factors, including abrupt salinity changes (aqueous), soil loss (terrestrial), siltation (aqueous) and environmental acidification (aqueous or terrestrial), although these factors are rarely regarded as the dominant influence on biotic changes.

Temperature and redox changes are generally related to perturbations of the global carbon cycle, making the latter a key player in most biocrises. The tangled web of proximate causation typical of many biocrises can be usefully dichotomized as related to either carbon release or carbon burial (Fig. 3). Specifically, climate change typically involves either cooling, which is associated with organic carbon burial and atmospheric CO2 drawdown, or warming, which is associated with organic carbon release and atmospheric CO2 buildup. Indeed, these patterns are standard interpretations of changes in marine carbonate carbon isotope records, with PCIEs indicative of organic carbon burial and commonly linked to evidence of cooling and/or glaciation, and NCIEs indicative of organic carbon release and linked to evidence of hyperwarming.

Carbon-release events generally represent ‘temperature-driven biocrises’, in which greenhouse gas buildup in the atmosphere causes climatic (hyper)warming and attendant environmental effects (Fig. 3). Release of carbon from the Earth's crust, rhizosphere and biosphere (in order of relative importance) can be triggered by bolide impacts (e.g. ECME; Fig. 2A), LIP eruptions (e.g. EPME or ETME; Fig. 2B–C) or biological activity (e.g. LQME). Although both bolide impacts and LIP eruptions may have short-term cooling effects linked to aerosol injection into the atmosphere, most proxy records at geological timescales show warming trends in their aftermath as a consequence of greenhouse gas release (Fig. 2A–C), which generally occurs over longer intervals and at a larger geographic scale than aerosol release. The degree of warming associated with massive LIPs such as the Siberian Traps can be extreme (>10°C) (Fig. 2B), with warming being the principal driver of longer-term (>1 Myr) environmental changes such as stagnation of oceanic circulation and intensification of the hydrological cycle, reduced marine productivity (reflected in NCIEs), increased continental erosion, and seawater acidification (the latter being linked to volcanic or evaporite sulfate emissions; e.g.). This suite of features characterizes the ECME, EPME and ETME (Fig. 3).

In contrast, carbon-burial events are commonly ‘productivity-driven biocrises’, in which increases in terrestrial and/or marine productivity result in enhanced organic carbon burial, leading to global cooling and attendant environmental effects (Fig. 2). The best-studied productivity-driven biocrises are the LOME, e.g. (Fig. 2D) and the end-Frasnian event, e.g. (Fig. 2E), both of which were associated with enhanced marine productivity and organic carbon burial (reflected in PCIEs) as well as with productivity-driven expansion of oceanic anoxia (Fig. 3). Both of these biocrises were preceded by long-term cooling trends and culminated in abrupt short-term cooling episodes coincident with the main mass mortality events.

One environmental parameter that has proven ineffective in distinguishing temperature-driven from productivity-driven biocrises is oceanic redox conditions. In essence, most types of marine environmental perturbations promote ocean-redox shifts toward more reducing conditions (Fig. 3). Expanded anoxia during temperature-driven biocrises such as the EPME is the product of reduced overturning circulation and stronger water-column stratification rather than increased marine productivity. In contrast, expanded anoxia during productivity-driven biocrises such as the LOME, LDME and end-Smithian is largely a product of cooling-driven invigoration of global-ocean circulation, leading to intensified upwelling and productivity rates along continental margins. Consequently, the distribution of oceanic anoxia tends to be weighted toward continent-margin upwelling zones during productivity-driven events, which differs from the pattern of whole-basin anoxia associated with temperature-driven events (Fig. 3). Although short-term cause-and-effect relationships generally cannot be resolved in deep-time records, the association of oceanic anoxia with PCIEs and cooling is the signature of a productivity-driven biocrisis, in contrast to the NCIEs and climatic warming that characterize temperature-driven biocrises.

A second environmental parameter that has proven non-diagnostic of carbon-cycle perturbations is continental weathering. As with ocean-redox shifts, most types of terrestrial environmental perturbations lead to enhanced continental erosion and weathering fluxes. Increased weathering fluxes were associated with both temperature-driven biocrises such as the EPME and productivity-driven biocrises such as the LOME, in the first case due to massive destruction of terrestrial vegetation and in the second to widespread glaciation (Fig. 3). On the other hand, the end-Frasnian crisis is associated with variable indicators of continental weathering changes, some studies documenting little change and others strong change. Several factors may be responsible for a lack of systematic relationships between weathering proxies and carbon-cycle perturbations during major biocrises: (i) local weathering intensity varies considerably at a broader scale; and (ii) weathering intensity can vary inversely to globally integrated weathering fluxes due to landscape armoring effects.

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.