이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.
2장 · From fossils to mind — Unresolved questions
Theories about brain evolution center around these questions: What are big brains for? Could an increase in brain size serve different functions in different species? Could changes in the way brains function occur independently of changes in brain size? Could the development of large brains relate to plasticity, and in particular, culture? We need to know what big brains do. Humans claim the largest brain size (in weight and neuron number) relative to body size, with some aspects (e.g., surface area of association cortex) being particularly pronounced. To enrich our understanding of human brain size, it is important to consider how brain size is interpreted in distantly related species. We can gain insight into how large brains work by looking at convergent mechanisms of evolution in brain weight, neuron number, neuron density, energetics, and organization. Humans belong to one of only three groups of species that have brains over 700 g, along with whales and elephants. Birds also provide opportunities to study convergent mechanisms, and have much higher neuronal densities than mammals, with total neuron numbers that fall within primate range. While the hominin fossil record provides the only direct evidence about encephalization in humans, a more thorough understanding of brain size changes could come from studying other vertebrates such as large-brained mammals, neuron-dense birds and their closest relatives (dinosaurs and crocodiles), as well as early synapsids, which allow us to draw deep comparisons between these groups.
The brain’s function as a “mind” depends on the whole body in which it is integrated. Sensory, motor, and physiological processes depend on the brain and the body together. Brain activity impacts the body beyond conducting mental functions, most obviously by consuming energy and producing heat. As such the paleoneurological evidence is best understood in the context of evidence from diverse research areas including comparative physiology and experimental archeology, among others.
Energetics
Average endocranial volume increased during the evolution of the genus Homo from approximately 600 cm³ in Homo habilis to 1350 cm³ in present day Homo sapiens. However, some later species, Homo naledi and Homo floresiensis, had less than half the brain mass of Homo sapiens. Besides the advantages of having a larger brain with more neurons providing more processing power, increase in brain size comes at a cost. Brain tissue is one of the most energetically demanding tissues in the mammalian body. For example, in Homo sapiens, the adult brain requires 20% of the daily energy intake, even though it makes up only about 2% of the body mass, and cerebral blood flow estimations based on the size of cranial foramina for some related mammalian species indicate that their brains are similarly expensive. Remarkably, human children’s brains, at the time of peak formation of neuronal connections, consume more than 60% of the body’s resting metabolism. Most of the energy funneled into the brain is claimed by its approximately 90 billion neurons, mostly for signaling processes and maintenance of resting potentials. Notably, although roughly 80% of the human brain’s neurons are located in the cerebellum, this structure consumes only about 10% of the brain’s total energy. In contrast, the cerebral cortex contains roughly 20% of neurons and takes up nearly 60% of its energy. This is due to the large, branched structure of many cortical neurons which have numerous synapses for integrating inputs and a large number of small unmyelinated axons with high conduction costs. The number of synapses per neuron increases in association with brain size enlargement across primates, with humans predictably having cortical neurons with the greatest number of synapses. Due to the lack of brain material from extinct hominin species, we can only speculate on neuronal numbers and associated energy costs. However, based on cranial foramen data from extant primates and fossil hominins, it has been estimated that blood flow increased steeply during the last 3 million years of human evolution, which is estimated to have seen a six-fold increase in total cerebral blood flow rate. Additionally, neuron number in extant primates (including humans) scales almost linearly with brain mass, which would mean that the number of neurons might have more than doubled during evolution of the hominin lineage.
How could humans afford such an increase in brain size and the corresponding increase in neuronal number while meeting the required energy budget? It was recently shown that avian species with similar or even higher neuron densities than primates show lower energy demands per neuron. The modern human brain appears to achieve higher computational efficiency with a reduced energy budget due to reduction of voltage-gated potassium conductance in specific cortical neurons. Direct measurements of whole-body metabolism indicate that Homo sapiens have a larger total energy expenditure and higher basic metabolic rates compared to other great apes, possibly indicating an overall increase of energy demands in hominin evolution. This could be partly attributed to larger brains with more, and larger neurons. However, it should be noted that we are only beginning to understand how these species differ in brain cellular composition (including glia) and the molecular mechanisms that guide metabolic activity. To meet the increasing energy demands of both body and brain, humans have adapted through both physiological and behavioral mechanisms to increase energetic turnover compared to great apes and this could potentially be related to brain size enlargement. For example, data indicate an increase in body fat in modern humans combined with altered foraging strategies, more food sharing among individuals, and a less cost-intensive locomotion type. The invention of fire, cooking, and other food preparation techniques might have made more calories available, but see. It has been suggested that these adaptations co-evolved with the increase of brain volume, and that they influence each other – for example, the higher processing capacities of larger brains allowed for more sophisticated foraging strategies and more cooperative social interactions which made more energy available to further promote brain growth. However, large and expensive brains could potentially pay for themselves in ways other than through increases in cognitive abilities. In fact, it has been suggested that large brains with increased numbers of glial cells might have evolved for thermoregulation in whales. As discussed above, we have much yet to learn about how brain size relates to cognitive abilities.
How do brains operate on a different budget in humans compared to other species? It has been suggested that changes in metabolic rates reflect changes in cell composition and microstructure. To answer this question, we need more information about brain energetics in different species. We need to relate evidence from the archeological and paleoecological records of fossil hominids, such as how they extracted foods, to various changes in their brains. We can triangulate that information to further model aspects of cerebral metabolism for fossil species.
Behavior and cognition
We do not have direct access to the behaviors of humans of the past, nor to the cognitive processes that underlie them, since these do not fossilize. It is, therefore, up to archeologists to infer their emergence and presence from the archeological record. The material culture of Paleolithic hominins includes tools, graphic productions such as engravings and paintings, objects of personal adornment, non-utilitarian objects transported over long-distances, and burials, among others. Neuroscientific experiments conducted on modern participants have been used to infer the neural basis of the cognitive abilities needed by Paleolithic hominins to produce the artifacts that archeologists have discovered. Although these studies are valuable and informative, they necessarily involve present-day human subjects with present-day human brains performing replications of ancient behaviors. For example, it remains unclear which brain activity patterns in a Homo erectus individual corresponded to the production of hand axes. Pioneering studies have used functional neuroimaging to explore the neural basis of stone toolmaking and its potential co-evolution with language. Other research has focused on the incremental working memory requirements for the successful knapping of stone tools from successive lithic industries.
To date, we know very little about how our brains process potentially symbolic aspects of material culture such as ornaments, body paintings, and engravings which appeared in the archeological record long after the earliest stone tools. Functional MRI (fMRI) was recently used to investigate human brain activity while visually perceiving the earliest abstract engravings. A follow-up study addressed the neural correlates of visually perceiving these abstract engravings when they have been attributed to a human maker. Characterizing the cerebral bases of the cognitive processes implemented by modern participants to produce or perceive archeological material reveals information on the probable cognitive capacities and neural functions of earlier hominins. Nevertheless, this approach has some limitations. The strategies used by Paleolithic hominins and those used by modern participants may differ due to differences in environment and culture. To limit this bias, researchers have, for instance, controlled for the effect of using language to give task instructions or included a group of archeologists who are experts in Paleolithic engravings to mimic the familiarity fossil hominins had with this type of material.
Paleolithic hominin brains depend on comparisons with other primate species as well. Unfortunately, there are few studies comparing functional brain organization across humans and other species using the same methods. Further, brain organization seems to differ between humans and other primates in regions relevant to understanding the neural bases of fossil hominin cognition. Thus far, it has been proposed that the early visual areas (V1, V2 and V3) show fewer differences between humans and rhesus macaques compared to intraparietal association areas that integrate multisensory information and function in the representation of tool use. It has been suggested that species differences relate to developmental timing, and that more rostral areas, and in particular the prefrontal cortex which matures later ontogenetically, differ more between humans and other primates. Understanding brain function in Homo sapiens and other extant species helps us to propose hypotheses on the evolution of hominin brain organization, and how it may relate to cognition and behavior.
Fossil hominins’ behavioral repertoires also depend on their postcranial anatomy. Fossil hand function is understood through the analysis of bone shape and musculoskeletal modeling and this is related to stone toolmaking ability through biomechanical studies. For example, Neanderthal thumb morphology appears to be better suited for power “squeeze” grips than precision hand postures (although there is high interindividual variability; Fig. 4). Experimental studies involving present-day human participants could further reveal how the brains and bodies of fossil hominins relate to the archeological record.
Are human brains specialized for toolmaking and other behaviors represented in the archeological record? How are their behavioral repertoires linked to brain organization, and are they independent of brain size? To answer this question, we need to know how brain structure relates to behavior in humans and other species. We can use that information to further model how fossil hominins could produce the artifacts they did, provided the brains they had.
Development and plasticity
One of the aims of evolutionary developmental biology (known as Evo-Devo) is identifying developmental processes that support conservation and variation in structure and behavior. Much research in the field of human brain evolution has focused on identifying developmental processes specific to humans. One insight emerging from comparisons of ontogenetic trajectories across extant and extinct species is that the human brain grows in utero and during the first two years of postnatal life at a rapid rate for an extended period compared to chimpanzees. The extended duration in brain growth accounts for the relative enlargement of the adult human brain. Another insight is that the human frontal cortex grows at a faster rate during the last trimester than it does in chimpanzees, and this cortical growth may be linked to differences in frontal lobe morphology. While ontogenetic comparisons have yielded much insight into the evolution of the human brain, the paucity of fetal and postnatal brain samples available to study human and great apes has hindered progress in identifying developmental mechanisms accounting for structural and behavioral modifications in the human lineage.
Some new strategies have been developed to overcome the issue of small samples with the goal of providing a more complete characterization of the developmental mechanisms generating variation across human and non-human primates. The integration of information across scales of organization (e.g., behavior, anatomy, gene expression) is instrumental in finding corresponding ages across the lifespan of humans and chimpanzees, as well as other species. This is because the sequence in behavior and biological maturation and aging are sufficiently similar across the two species that we can translate ages across their lifespan. Age alignments are possible throughout development to the end of life in chimpanzees. Importantly, most chimpanzees do not live past their forties, which equates to fifties to sixties in humans and subsequently there is a phase of life in humans (beyond fifties) with no clear counterpart in chimpanzees. Accordingly, chimpanzees should suffer from less cognitive decline towards the end of their lives than humans, and chimpanzee offspring may not benefit from the care of aged females as is evident in humans. The evolution of lifespan has a range of consequences for species-specific cognition and social structures. As already mentioned, ontogenetic series of chimpanzee and human brains are difficult to obtain and hence limited, but a direct comparison of these series indicates that certain aspects of brain development, such as neocortical myelination, are protracted in humans compared to chimpanzees. Other aspects of brain development, such as the timing of neocortical synaptogenesis, are shared by both species.
Another way to overcome the very limited availability of ontogenetic series is by comparing patterns of variation observed in adult brains to infer certain aspects of development. For example, quantitative genetic analyses of large samples of chimpanzee and human adult brains indicate that human brain anatomy is more strongly influenced by environmental factors than chimpanzee brain anatomy, which is indicative of a higher level of developmental plasticity in humans. While increased brain plasticity must have evolved in hominins, it is often considered to be associated with the evolution of secondary altriciality in humans. Inferring levels of plasticity in fossil hominin species based on their patterns of anatomical variation is particularly challenging. There is, however, increasing evidence indicating that brain plasticity is influenced by genetic factors that can be identified and traced in hominin species through paleogenetic studies. DNA methylation is an epigenetic mark that has been reconstructed in hominin ancient DNA (aDNA) samples which is highly correlated with gene expression and heritable through multiple cell divisions. A better understanding of the molecular mechanisms in human-specific neuroplasticity could come from fossil hominins, since humans show substantial differential DNA methylation of genes involved in neurodevelopment and synaptic plasticity in comparison to great apes.
Are human brains specialized for plasticity and an unusual propensity to be shaped by environmental variables? To answer this question, we need more information about brain development in different species. A better representation of neonatal fossil hominins could help us to better model how brain shape develops.
이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.
