본문 바로가기
읽기 · 학술 · 공개 라이선스 원문

Theory and classification of mass extinction causation

Algeo, Shen · 2023

공개 학술지 National Science Review 에 실린 총설 논문입니다(2023년). CC BY 4.0 으로 공개된 글이고, 그림 · 표 · 참고 문헌 표시를 뺀 본문을 실었습니다.

출처 Algeo & Shen (2023), National Science Review · 라이선스 CC BY 4.0 · 원문

장 5개 올림 이 장 2057낱말
다음 장 →

이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.

1장 · Theory and classification of mass extinction causation

Theory regarding the causation of mass extinctions is in need of systematization, which is the focus of this contribution. Every mass extinction has both an ultimate cause, i.e. the trigger that leads to various climato-environmental changes, and one or more proximate cause(s), i.e. the specific climato-environmental changes that result in elevated biotic mortality. With regard to ultimate causes, strong cases can be made that bolide (i.e. meteor) impacts, large igneous province (LIP) eruptions and bioevolutionary events have each triggered one or more of the Phanerozoic Big Five mass extinctions, and that tectono-oceanic changes have triggered some second-order extinction events. Apart from bolide impacts, other astronomical triggers (e.g. solar flares, gamma bursts and supernova explosions) remain entirely in the realm of speculation. With regard to proximate mechanisms, most extinctions are related to either carbon-release or carbon-burial processes, the former being associated with climatic warming, ocean acidification, reduced marine productivity and lower carbonate δ¹³C values, and the latter with climatic cooling, increased marine productivity and higher carbonate δ¹³C values. Environmental parameters such as marine redox conditions and terrestrial weathering intensity do not show consistent relationships with carbon-cycle changes.

In this context, mass extinction causation can be usefully classified using a matrix of ultimate and proximate factors. Among the Big Five mass extinctions, the end-Cretaceous biocrisis is an example of a bolide-triggered carbon-release event, the end-Permian and end-Triassic biocrises are examples of LIP-triggered carbon-release events, and the Late Ordovician and Late Devonian biocrises are examples of bioevolution-triggered carbon-burial events. Whereas the bolide-impact and LIP-eruption mechanisms appear to invariably cause carbon release, bioevolutionary triggers can result in variable carbon-cycle changes, e.g. carbon burial during the Late Ordovician and Late Devonian events, carbon release associated with modern anthropogenic climate warming, and little to no carbon-cycle impact due to certain types of ecosystem change (e.g. the advent of the first predators around the end-Ediacaran; the appearance of Paleolithic human hunters in Australasia and the Americas). Broadly speaking, studies of mass extinction causation have suffered from insufficiently critical thinking—an impartial survey of the extant evidence shows that (i) hypotheses of a common ultimate cause (e.g. bolide impacts or LIP eruptions) for all Big Five mass extinctions are suspect given manifest differences in patterns of environmental and biotic change among them; (ii) the Late Ordovician and Late Devonian events were associated with carbon burial and long-term climatic cooling, i.e. changes that are inconsistent with a bolide-impact or LIP-eruption mechanism; and (iii) claims of periodicity in Phanerozoic mass extinctions depended critically on the now-disproven idea that they shared a common extrinsic trigger (i.e. bolide impacts).

HISTORY OF MASS EXTINCTION RESEARCH

Recognition and naming of mass extinctions

Mass faunal extinctions in Earth history have been the focus of much recent research, stimulated in large measure by a fascination with the biotic impacts of catastrophes and what they might portend for the future. Yet the idea that a species could go extinct is a relatively new one, first proposed by anatomist Georges Cuvier in a 1796 lecture about mastodons. Research on extinctions was limited during the early 19th century owing to prevailing views guided by religious dogma (i.e. that Earth's biota had been created by a supreme being and was therefore immutable) or uniformitarian principles (i.e. species evolved and died out over geologically long intervals, e.g. Charles Lyell and Charles Darwin). In 1841, John Phillips formalized the division of the Phanerozoic into three eras separated by mass extinctions at the ends of the Permian and Cretaceous periods, representing a milestone in extinction research. Over the course of the 19th century, extinction events came to define the boundaries between most first- and second-order subdivisions (i.e. eras and periods) of the Phanerozoic portion of the geologic timescale.

It is now well-established that there have been numerous mass extinctions in the Earth's past, the most thoroughly studied of which are the so-called ‘Big Five’ Phanerozoic events, herein termed the Late Ordovician (LOME), Late Devonian (LDME), end-Permian (EPME), end-Triassic (ETME) and end-Cretaceous (ECME) mass extinctions. It should be noted that the LDME is conventionally regarded as two separate extinctions separated by ∼12 Myr, i.e. the end-Frasnian and end-Devonian events (which record similar environmental responses, although identical triggers should not be assumed), although the ∼30-Myr interval from the late Early Devonian to the Devonian-Carboniferous boundary encompasses both as well as ∼8–10 smaller bioevents. For the Phanerozoic as a whole, another ∼15 second-order biocrises might qualify as mass extinctions, among which the late Cambrian, Early Carboniferous, end-Guadalupian, Early Toarcian and end-Cenomanian are especially prominent. Note that, for the sake of systematization, several conventions are adopted in this review: (i) extinctions are named for the terminal geologic period or stage rather than for the boundary itself—thus, ‘ECME’ is adopted in place of ‘Cretaceous–Paleocene boundary (KPB)’, ‘end-Frasnian’ in place of ‘Frasnian–Famennian boundary (FFB)’ and so forth, and (ii) extinctions occurring <1 Myr and >1 Myr prior to the boundary of interest are termed ‘end-’ and ‘Late’, respectively [cf.]. Finally, most biologists and Earth scientists accept that a ‘Sixth Mass Extinction’ is presently underway, which we will refer to as the ‘Late Quaternary mass extinction’ (LQME).

Causation of mass extinctions

The earliest ideas concerning mass extinctions imputed biblical causation (e.g. Noachian floods, as propounded by Oxford don William Buckland), a cultural meme that lingers in creationist communities today. Throughout most of the 20th century (i.e. pre-1980), the prevailing scientific paradigms for mass extinctions invoked vaguely defined changes in ocean salinity, sea level or plate tectonics, and some of these mechanisms have continued to draw adherents even in more recent times (e.g. the sea-level advocacy of). From the modern perspective, however, these mechanisms are highly improbable as agents of biotic annihilation given that such changes have occurred almost continuously throughout Earth history and generally at rates far too slow to serve as the trigger of a biocrisis.

The modern phase of mass extinction research effectively began in 1980 with the seminal paper by Alvarez et al. on an extraterrestrial cause for the ECME, which was then known as the ‘Cretaceous–Tertiary boundary (KTB) mass extinction’. Although the concept of mass extinction by bolide (meteor) impact had been proposed earlier, the Alvarez et al. study was transformative in identifying for the first time the geochemical and petrographic signatures of such an event, validating the concept of ‘neocatastrophism’. These signatures, e.g. iridium anomalies, microspherule layers, quartz shock lamellae and fused breccia, are now standard features by which bolide impacts are recognized in the rock record. Although not diagnostic of a bolide impact, a negative carbon isotope excursion (NCIE) in marine carbonates during the earliest Paleocene was linked to a short-term productivity collapse, demonstrating the scale of ecosystem disruption potentially unleashed by a global catastrophe. The Alvarez et al. study also stimulated much later research on the ECME, an overwhelming share of which has served to further substantiate the bolide impact model, a crowning achievement being the discovery of the impact site at Chicxulub, Mexico.

Since 1980, research on the causation of mass extinctions has been characterized by a ‘bandwagon effect’, in which a model developed for one specific mass extinction is claimed to apply to many or all biocrises, reducing agency to a single cause. For example, in the decade following publication of the Alvarez et al. study, the bolide model dominated research on mass extinctions (Fig. 1), with all of the Big Five mass extinctions as well as some smaller biocrises being attributed to this mechanism (and many other studies). However, extensive hunts for impact-related features at other (i.e. non-ECME) mass extinction horizons yielded few affirmative results, with much of the putatively bolide-related evidence having a limited spatial distribution and/or not coinciding with the extinction horizon proper. For example, research on the LDME yielded various undiagnostic carbon-sulfur isotopic anomalies, minor Ir anomalies at some stratigraphic remove from the FFB and scattered microspherules of uncertain provenance, as well as identification of two impact craters (Siljan Ring, Sweden; Alamo Crater, Nevada, USA) that were later shown to substantially predate (by ≥5 Myr) the end-Frasnian biocrisis. Particularly troublesome is that, in the competition to find evidence of bolide impacts, insufficiently vetted research was published, e.g. the claim of extraterrestrial ³He/⁴He ratios at the Permian–Triassic boundary, a finding that later proved to be irreproducible. Although limited advocacy of the bolide impact mechanism for non-ECME events persists to the present, e.g., the paucity of evidence for impacts in conjunction with the end-Frasnian and other biocrises eventually became apparent, and the search for mechanisms of mass extinction moved on to new ideas.

The most recently proposed extinction mechanism to be given the ‘bandwagon’ treatment is large igneous province (LIP) eruptions. Interest in LIPs accelerated rapidly with the introduction of this term in the early 1990s, and it now represents the most popular hypothesis for mass extinction causation (Fig. 1). LIPs were quickly linked to the EPME and ETME biocrises, i.e. the Siberian Traps and the Central Atlantic Magmatic Province, respectively, and much subsequent work has substantiated their role in these biocrises (reviewed in). On the strength of these two well-documented examples, a general theory of LIP eruptions as the trigger for all major Phanerozoic biocrises has been advanced several times. Yet despite much subsequent research, evidence for LIP eruptions of sufficient magnitude to trigger a global biocrisis remains sparse for the other Big Five mass extinctions, and the role of LIPs in these events remains speculative and contentious (see below).

The LOME and LDME biocrises are fundamentally different from the ECME, EPME and ETME in ways that point to a completely different type of mechanism. In contrast to the complex short-term temperature changes of the ECME (Fig. 2A) and the long-term (hyper)warming associated with LIP eruptions (Fig. 2B–C), these mass extinctions were associated with long-term cooling trends that commenced tens of millions of years prior to the onset of mass mortality, and they both culminated in brief ice ages, i.e. the latest Ordovician Hirnantian and end-Devonian Hangenberg glaciations. Moreover, unlike the other three Big Five mass extinctions, these two biocrises were associated with large positive carbon-isotope excursions (PCIEs; Fig. 2D–E) indicating a fundamentally different response of the global carbon cycle (i.e. net carbon burial) from that of the ECME, EPME and ETME (whose NCIEs are indicative of net carbon release) (Fig. 2A–C). The LOME and LDME are also distinct in their ecological scope of operation (i.e. being limited mainly to tropical marine biotas) and their protracted, multistage character. Finally, both of these biocrises had manifest temporal links to the evolution of land plants—specifically, the appearance and spread of bryophyte-grade plants during the Middle to Late Ordovician and the rapid spread of vascular (especially seed) plants in the Late Devonian.

The principal alternative to an LIP mechanism as the trigger for the LOME and LDME is global climate change linked to the evolution of land plants, e.g. the ‘land-plant–weathering hypothesis’. This hypothesis links marine mass extinctions to the spread of land plants via their effects on continental weathering regimes. Specifically, as early plant clades spread across continents, they promoted chemical weathering via larger root systems, physical substrate disturbance via root penetration, and climate humidity via enhanced evapotranspiration. These weathering-related effects led to increased nutrient fluxes to marine environments, triggering massive algal blooms and water-column deoxygenation. Evidence in support of this hypothesis has been accumulating for decades (Fig. 1), with studies documenting the evolution of early bryophyte-grade and vascular plants, weathering rate intensification at the FFB, and increased terrestrial nutrient fluxes and climate-floral relationships throughout the Devonian. Significantly, the land-plant–weathering hypothesis satisfactorily accounts for nearly all observational data related to the LOME and LDME events, which the bolide and LIP models do not. Although unambiguous evidence of the appearance of a key new plant taxon or clade immediately preceding a biocrisis such as the FFB is lacking, temporal relationships between paleobotanical developments and marine mass extinctions can be difficult to establish owing to limited documentation of the land-plant fossil record, causing punctuated migrations to be overlooked. Thus, cause-and-effect sequences may be incorrectly inferred if a key plant taxon first appeared in a more poorly studied region and only later migrated into better-studied areas, an issue relevant to paleobotanical triggers but not to bolide and LIP mechanisms of mass extinction.

이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.