이 장은 원문만 있습니다. 문장별 해석은 앞 장부터 차례로 붙입니다.
1장 · From fossils to mind
색을 입힌 곳이 TOEFL® 읽기 문제에 실린 대목입니다. 그 앞뒤의 글을 이어 읽어 보세요. 대목으로 가기
Fossil endocasts record features of brains from the past: size, shape, vasculature, and gyrification. These data, alongside experimental and comparative evidence, are needed to resolve questions about brain energetics, cognitive specializations, and developmental plasticity. Through the application of interdisciplinary techniques to the fossil record, paleoneurology has been leading major innovations. Neuroimaging is shedding light on fossil brain organization and behaviors. Inferences about the development and physiology of the brains of extinct species can be experimentally investigated through brain organoids and transgenic models based on ancient DNA. Phylogenetic comparative methods integrate data across species and associate genotypes to phenotypes, and brains to behaviors. Meanwhile, fossil and archeological discoveries continuously contribute new knowledge. Through cooperation, the scientific community can accelerate knowledge acquisition. Sharing digitized museum collections improves the availability of rare fossils and artifacts. Comparative neuroanatomical data are available through online databases, along with tools for their measurement and analysis. In the context of these advances, the paleoneurological record provides ample opportunity for future research. Biomedical and ecological sciences can benefit from paleoneurology’s approach to understanding the mind as well as its novel research pipelines that establish connections between neuroanatomy, genes and behavior.
Introduction
What, if anything, can fossils tell us about the mind? Paleontologists draw links between anatomical details that are preserved in the fossil record (e.g., the dimensions of a bone) and functions (e.g., locomotion). We start from the premise that “minds are simply what brains do”, but understanding minds through fossils has proven to be a tortuous task at the center of a very contentious topic. Brain tissue does not fossilize like teeth and bones do, so it is only possible to observe the internal cavity of the skull’s braincase – called the endocranium – to understand external brain anatomy of extinct species. Endocasts – naturally occurring or artificially manufactured internal casts of the endocranium that look a lot like brains – only provide information about a few gross anatomical features, whereas a comprehensive understanding of brain function needs to incorporate microstructure, gene expression, connectivity, biochemistry, physiology, and behavior, among others. Furthermore, the structural and functional bases of the cognitive abilities that differentiate humans from other species are not fully understood even in present day humans and primates.
The evolutionary history of the human brain is fundamental to understanding the modern human mind. As the field of brain evolution has drawn increasingly from biomedical methods such as neuroimaging and genomic analyses, it has also become clear that the field can contribute to human health and well-being. Aspects of brain structure and function that are particular to humans may be linked to our susceptibilities to neurodegeneration and mental health disorders. Evolutionary history forms a foundation for translating animal models of human conditions.
The evolutionary history of the species we discuss is represented in a phylogenetic tree (Fig. 1). The human brain is best understood through comparisons with closely related species of primates and other mammals, and also more distantly related species, which share both ancestral and convergent features with humans. The study of birdsong, for example, has provided essential insight into the neural mechanisms of vocal learning in birds, and its convergence with human language. Early amniotes, including dinosaurs (early relatives of birds) and early synapsids (early relatives of mammals), provide a broader evolutionary perspective. Our own species (Homo sapiens) is a member of the great ape clade, also called hominids, along with three other great ape genera: Pan (Pan troglodytes - chimpanzees and Pan paniscus - bonobos), Gorilla (Gorilla gorilla - Western gorillas and Gorilla beringei - Eastern gorillas), and Pongo (Pongo pygmaeus - Bornean orangutans and Pongo abelii - Sumatran orangutans). The term “humans” refers to both fossil and present day Homo sapiens, and where relevant it can also include closely related archaic human species who have been shown to have made recent contributions to our genome. Hominids have among the largest brains of all animal species, except for the most massive ones – proboscideans (elephants) and cetaceans (whales and dolphins). Within hominids, our closest extant relatives are the chimpanzees and bonobos, with whom we shared our most recent common ancestor approximately 7–10 million years ago (Ma). Hominins include Homo sapiens and those fossil species that are more closely related to them than to chimpanzees and bonobos. There are numerous hominin species which evolved and became extinct over the past 6-7 million years, including species of the genus Australopithecus, from which the genus Homo likely arose approximately 2.8 Ma, as well as at least one other now extinct genus called Paranthropus (Fig. 2). In this review, we primarily focus on hominins, but also cover aspects of brain evolution in other species.
First, we review what we know about brain anatomy from the fossil record, and the state of the art in paleoneurology. Second, we discuss the gaps in our knowledge about brain evolution and highlight the need for more comparative research concerning energetics, function, and development. We seek to address big theoretical questions about what makes the modern human brain different not just from all other extant species, but even from the Neanderthals (Homo neanderthalensis), which are closely related archaic humans with whom Homo sapiens interbred for thousands of years. These questions may have been asked for centuries, but answering them requires more comparative investigation of biological mechanisms. Third, we point to emerging directions in the field. We provide guidance to researchers to move the field forward. We indicate how mechanistic evidence from molecular and evolutionary biology can now be used to triangulate findings from studies of endocasts. We highlight the potential of new fossil and archeological discoveries and discuss how to best use neuroimaging methods to interpret anatomy from endocasts. Finally, we point to the possibilities that can arise from better data sharing and provide a link to an online list of tools and resources in neuroscience and paleontology.
Data we can obtain from endocasts
The study of brain evolution in extinct animals based on their fossil remains was made possible by the introduction of endocasting techniques in paleoneurology. The soft tissues of the nervous system rarely fossilize (with some exceptions). As the brain grows and expands during ontogeny, its surrounding structures leave an imprint in the cranial bone. Endocranial imprints in fossil crania can therefore provide evidence about brain size, vasculature of the meninges, and aspects of brain morphology, including overall shape, sulcal patterns, and lateralization. It is notable that adult brains do not fill the entire cranial cavity, and that the space between the brain and the braincase is filled with cerebrospinal fluid, meninges, and blood vessels.
Size
Brain size is mainly assessed indirectly through studies of endocranial volume, and thus depends on assumptions about the relationship of the brain to the braincase. Early on, greater brain size was assumed to represent higher intellectual capacities like memory or problem-solving abilities, and it was used to infer possible behaviors like sociality, complexity of the hierarchical system, the nutrient richness of the diet, and behavioral flexibility. Brain size has long been a central consideration in understanding human evolution, especially because the human brain is large. The human brain is 3-4 times larger in volume than that of other hominids and appreciably larger than would be predicted by allometric scaling for a primate of similar body size. Parallel to this, the archeological record provides evidence for increasing technological sophistication. However, the association between archeological artifacts and their makers is not always certain, and is constantly revised in light of new paleontological and archeological discoveries. Members of the genus Australopithecus lived approximately 4.2–2 Ma and had adult endocranial volumes on average 20% larger than chimpanzees. Historically, inclusion in the genus Homo required an arbitrary minimum brain size, as well as association with stone tools, but this has since been updated due to evidence for toolmaking that predates the appearance of Homo (see discussion further on in the review). Also, two relatively recent species of Homo, Homo floresiensis and Homo naledi, had unexpectedly small endocranial volumes. Trends in brain size increase have also been hypothesized in other mammalian lineages. According to Marsh, during the Paleogene, all mammals had a small brain and there was a gradual increase in the size of the brain over evolutionary time, yet this was not the case in all clades. Likewise, reductions in brain size have been hypothesized in other vertebrate lineages. It is currently accepted that some species have smaller brains than their ancestors, including some primates and sauropod dinosaurs. The ratio between brain size and body size is under dynamic developmental constraint and evolves independently, in terms of direction and rate, in different vertebrate taxonomic groups.
As absolute brain volume was shown not to be a reliable proxy of intelligence and/or cognitive ability across animals, Jerison proposed the use of an Encephalization Quotient (EQ) – the ratio between actual brain size and expected brain size (as derived from regression with body size among different reference species). The aim was to control for the allometric relationship between brain and body size, for relevant cross-species comparison of brain size variability. Comparisons between different clades have established that some groups display a mean EQ above 1, like carnivorans, cetaceans, primates, and birds. In dinosaurs, a modified measure of encephalization developed by Hurlburt, the Reptile Encephalization Quotient (REQ), shows disparity between various clades. Sauropod and ceratopsian dinosaurs have values under 1, whereas ornithopod and theropod dinosaurs display higher values.
Although relative brain size has been proposed to be an index of cognitive ability, the relationship between brain size and behavioral repertoire is hotly debated. Even after accounting for body size, some proboscideans and some cetaceans do have or have had brain sizes comparable to some representatives of the genus Homo (EQ of about 5), which should be considered when discussing the relevance of brain size to intelligence. Furthermore, decades of research in primates have stressed a relationship between brain size and ecological factors. However, social factors could be under explored due to greater difficulty in defining and obtaining relevant ethological data, which could have more localized effects on brain organization. These disparities can also be seen in examples from the vertebrate paleontological record. For example, the dwarf elephant of Sicily (Palaeoloxodon falconeri) reached an EQ of 5 and up to 7 on a purely herbivorous (low quality) diet. Thus, the use of EQ as a proxy of intelligence is contentious, and other constructs have been proposed to better represent the mechanisms linking brain size and cognition.
Vasculature
Cerebral blood flow is an indication of brain activity, including cognitive and other physiological processes. Blood flow to and within the brain in fossil specimens can be estimated from depressions made by blood vessels on the inner surface of the endocast, called valleculae, as well as from bony canals. Valleculae appear when the brain is in close contact with the bone surface, being more pronounced when the meninges are thin. The observation of valleculae suggests a close apposition between brain surface and endocranial surface, indicating that the endocranium can be used to assess the size and shape of the brain in extinct vertebrate species. The space between the brain and skull is particularly noticeable in reptiles with smaller brains, including some extant lepidosauromorph reptiles such as sphenodons and iguanas. However, in most mammals and archosaurs (birds, dinosaurs, and alligators), the brain takes up a larger portion of the endocranial cavity and endocasts can serve as a reliable proxy for brain size and shape. Although it had previously been assumed that dinosaur brains only occupy half of the endocranial cavity, the discovery of valleculae has shown that some dinosaur brains were larger than previously estimated. Among dinosaurs, Osmólska and Evans, and later Godefroit et al. and Lauters et al., showed the presence of valleculae in Oviraptoridae, Pachycephalosauridae and Hadrosauridae (Fig. 3). Within hominins, a close correspondence between brain and endocranial sizes has long been assumed. However, the degree to which the brain fills the cranial cavity varies among mammalian groups, with notable exceptions such as proboscideans.
Vascular imprints in hominin endocasts and foramina through the cranial base have featured in discussions about taxonomy, thermoregulation and blood flow rate. Studies of the vascular imprints in fossil hominin endocasts identified specific patterns in early hominins, with Paranthropus being characterized by an enlarged occipital-marginal sinus, while the middle branch of the middle meningeal vessels cannot be found in Australopithecus, but see. The reorganization of the vascular system in early hominins has been interpreted by some as evidence for the emergence of a thermoregulation system for cooling down the brain under conditions of hyperthermia (the “radiator” theory). Indeed, thermal stress might represent a severe biological and evolutionary constraint, especially if we consider the increase in brain size within the hominin lineage and the role of brain volume in heat production. Additionally, the size of the arteries, inferred from the size of the foramina in the cranial base, gives us an idea about blood flow and brain glucose utilization, a relationship which has been examined across mammals. A study taking advantage of this correlation to infer brain metabolism reported a disproportionate increase of blood flow rate to the brain in fossil hominins.
Shape
All adult vertebrate brains have three major portions: a forebrain (prosencephalon), a midbrain (mesencephalon), and a hindbrain (rhombencephalon). In recent years, comparisons between vertebrate brains have benefitted from an updated nomenclature that reflects homology between structures (i.e., similarity due to evolutionary relationship). New methods, such as profiling neurons on the basis of transcriptomes, have provided new tests of homology. However, differences in the relative size and shape of these portions and their components can make it difficult to directly compare the brains of distantly related species from fossils alone, since only the outer shape of the brain is preserved.
In most amniote species, such as dinosaurs, the forebrain, midbrain, and hindbrain are discernable on fossil endocasts. The cephalic and pontine flexures of the brain can be summarized as the angles between the forebrain and midbrain, and midbrain and hindbrain, respectively, and can be determined from endocranial surfaces. Such brain endocast flexure is known to vary substantially across species, but there is an overall trend toward greater flexure in small animals and less flexure in large animals. This trend is also observed ontogenetically, where younger individuals have more marked flexures than mature individuals. This is due to the negative allometric scaling of the brain, where smaller animals tend to have a proportionately larger brain that is more restricted by the size limits of the skull and spatial limits from other structures, such as the eyes. As a result, they tend to have increased flexures to accommodate the spatial restrictions of the skull.
Discernable features of mammalian endocasts are disproportionately cerebral (i.e., corresponding to the pallium of the telencephalon). Due to the development of the neocortex in mammals, the outer surface is mainly telencephalon which covers structures of the diencephalon and midbrain, with the impressions of ventral hindbrain and cerebellum also visible in endocasts. With increased encephalization in primates, other brain parts are positioned mostly inferior to the cerebrum and contribute to a flexion at the cranial base.
In humans, the cerebrum is disproportionately even larger and more superiorly positioned, enveloping most of the brain except for the cerebellum (a structure of the hindbrain). The folding of the cerebrum into convolutions made up of sulci and gyri is partially represented on fossils. In addition, overall cerebral form can also be studied. The shape and size of the human cerebellum is also represented in endocasts, however its very fine folds (called folia) are not imprinted on endocasts. A striking finding of cerebral shape comparison is that, while both present day and fossil Homo sapiens are similar in endocranial volume to Neanderthals, they have different endocranial shapes with only present day Homo sapiens being characterized by a “globular” endocranial shape. This globular shape is related to the emergence of taller frontal area, more bulging parietal areas, round occipital area housing a large and bulging cerebellum, and narrow and anterior-medially oriented temporal poles. As part of this process, the basicranium became more flexed. The cranial base also flexes during the first year of life of extant humans. This trait emerged relatively recently within the lineage and is addressed further on in the review.
Cerebral sulci
The boundaries of cerebral cortical areas in fossil hominins are often assumed to be closely, if not exactly, associated with sulci which are sometimes evident in extant species. Understanding the functional relevance of cerebral sulci and gyri is thus crucial for deriving as much information as possible from endocasts. It has been shown that the number of cortical areas increases with brain size across mammals as does the complexity of sulcal morphology across species and among humans. The number of distinct cortical areas, however, does not appear to vary substantially with brain size among anthropoid primates. Homologues of human prefrontal cortex areas, for example, have been described in macaque monkeys. In humans, the presence of the paracingulate sulcus as an additional fold in some subjects has been linked to subtle cytoarchitectural variation as well as behavioral differences (see Toro for a discussion). In macaques, thalamic inputs to the primary visual cortex have been found to be involved in the development of primary visual cortex histology as well as the positioning of the lunate sulcus. Computer simulations have found that convolutions may occur at cortical area borders as a mechanical consequence of cortical growth. This notion of mechanical stress is congruent with research relating the development of gyri to growth factors that increase neurogenesis as well as the finding that fold wavelength – the width of a fold – is conserved among primates given the relatively stable cortical thickness.
While we cannot test brain function in extinct species, we are able to use key features to make inferences about various functional brain regions and their boundaries. Two regions of the cortex differ considerably in sulcal morphology between humans and nonhuman primates and are of interest to paleoneurologists: the inferior frontal gyrus, in which Broca’s language area is situated, and the lunate sulcus, associated with changes in the size of the parietal association cortex relative to the occipital visual cortex. When part of the cortex has expanded large enough to fold over and cover another one, the overhanging part is called an operculum. Developmental studies show humans have gained frontal and orbital opercula in the inferior frontal gyrus, making the morphology of the sulci more complex. Additionally, humans never develop a deep lunate sulcus covering other gyri as seen in nonhuman primates, making their sulcal boundaries more simplified in this region.
It is a matter of debate in paleoanthropology to what extent evolutionary changes in sulcal patterns are causally linked to species differences in overall brain volume. Early australopiths had sulcal patterns more similar to extant great apes in form, while later, larger-brained members of Homo had sulci that more closely resemble modern humans, but the sulcal pattern in later australopiths and early Homo is still debated. Clarifying the timing and functional consequences of these sulcal changes requires new resources, more fossils, more comparative data from extant ape brains for reference, and innovative approaches from other disciplines.
Lateralization
Several brain functions in humans and many other vertebrates are lateralized, which is reflected in associated lateralized behaviors. Prime examples for asymmetrically organized brain functions are lateralized vocalization systems and limb preferences in many vertebrate species. In many nonhuman primate species, for example, there is asymmetry in hand skill and preference related to the motor demands of different actions. Behavioral lateralization in humans and nonhuman primates has been linked to hemispheric asymmetry in the anatomy of various brain regions, including the primary motor cortex and inferior frontal cortex, as well as the morphology of the corpus callosum. Indeed, it has been hypothesized that hemispheric specialization increased in hominins along with handedness, tool use and making, and language.
While extant primates in general exhibit lateralization in these faculties, humans are thought to stand out by showing more consistent and more robust functional lateralization patterns. The human cerebral cortex displays a larger degree and greater range of leftward directional asymmetry compared to chimpanzees, particularly in the posterior perisylvian region. Given that lateralization of brain functions has been suggested to be associated with maintaining rapid conduction within intra-hemispheric circuits to support time-critical computational processes, this difference could be considered an important step in human evolution as language and toolmaking capacities emerged. However, it is a matter of debate which aspects of brain asymmetry are uniquely human, as very little is known about brain asymmetry in great apes beyond data from chimpanzees. To fill this gap, endocranial imprints captured from computed tomography (CT) scans have been studied as proxies for brains. For example, Neubauer et al. measured the magnitude and pattern of endocranial shape asymmetry in humans, gorillas, orangutans, and chimpanzees. They found that the magnitude of asymmetry was about the same in humans, gorillas, and orangutans. Chimpanzee endocasts, however, were less asymmetrical on average than those of their great ape and human relatives. These endocranial results corroborate Gómez-Robles et al. findings on the differences between chimpanzee and human brains as determined from magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans, but the broader comparative context suggests a different evolutionary interpretation: perhaps chimpanzees are unusually symmetrical among hominids. Neubauer et al. also examined the pattern of asymmetry and were able to show that not only humans, but also chimpanzees, gorillas, and orangutans exhibited the pattern of asymmetry previously described as typically human: the left occipital lobe, the right frontal lobe, and the right temporal pole and right cerebellar lobe protruded more relative to their contralateral parts. These results challenge the long-held notion that the human asymmetry pattern is unique.
Evidence of lateralization in fossils might improve our understanding of the emergence and development of complex cognitive abilities in hominins. As summarized in Uomini and Ruck, hand preferences can be determined from behavioral evidence such as cave paintings (e.g., proportions of left and right handprints found), stone tools (e.g., direction of traces of use on stone tools) and striations on fossil teeth (when they were used in gripping an object), from directional asymmetries measured on skeletons (e.g., arm bones), and from endocranial asymmetries. For example, evidence of right-handedness at the population-level was deduced from dental striation analyses in Homo heidelbergensis, Homo neanderthalensis, and fossil and present day Homo sapiens. Furthermore, it was found that the average spatial asymmetry pattern on endocasts is shared among extant hominids and among fossil hominins, but that humans show a pattern of asymmetry more variable than great apes, which may reflect increased functional and developmental modularization of the human brain. Unfortunately, fossil evidence of behavioral and anatomical hemispheric asymmetries is scarce, and fossil preservation sometimes makes it difficult to observe and measure the underlying patterns of anatomical asymmetry.
TOEFL® 읽기 문제 5문항. 이 장의 한 대목을 그대로 옮기고 문항을 붙였습니다. 대목을 읽고 문제를 풉니다.
이 글은 위 출처의 원문을 그 라이선스(CC BY 4.0)에 따라 옮겼습니다. 참고문헌 목록과 인용 번호, 그림 · 표 · 각주 · 수식 · 부록은 빼고 절별로 나누어 실었으며, 그 밖의 문장은 원문 그대로입니다. 원 저작자와 발행 기관은 이 화면을 만들거나 검토하지 않았고, 이곳의 해석과 낱말 풀이는 공식 번역이 아닙니다.
